Facts of the Case
Dred Scott was a slave in Missouri. From 1833 to 1843, he resided in Illinois (a free state) and in the Louisiana Territory, where slavery was forbidden by the Missouri Compromise of 1820. After returning to Missouri, Scott filed suit in Missouri court for his freedom, claiming that his residence in free territory made him a free man. After losing, Scott brought a new suit in federal court. Scott's master maintained that no “negro” or descendant of slaves could be a citizen in the sense of Article III of the Constitution.
Questions
Was Dred Scott free or a slave?
Conclusions
-
The majority held that “a negro, whose ancestors were imported into [the U.S.], and sold as slaves,” whether enslaved or free, could not be an American citizen and therefore did not have standing to sue in federal court. Because the Court lacked jurisdiction, Taney dismissed the case on procedural grounds.
Taney further held that the Missouri Compromise of 1820 was unconstitutional and foreclose Congress from freeing slaves within Federal territories. The opinion showed deference to the Missouri courts, which held that moving to a free state did not render Scott emancipated. Finally, Taney ruled that slaves were property under the Fifth Amendment, and that any law that would deprive a slave owner of that property was unconstitutional.
In dissent, Benjamin Robbins Curtis criticized Taney for addressing the claim’s substance after finding the Court lacked jurisdiction. He pointed out that invalidating the Missouri Compromise was not necessary to resolve the case, and cast doubt on Taney’s position that the Founders categorically opposed anti-slavery laws.
John McLean echoed Curtis, finding the majority improperly reviewed the claim’s substance when its holding should have been limited to procedure. He also argued that men of African descent could be citizens because they already had the right to vote in five states.
The Future of Birthright Citizenship: What’s Next After Trump v. Barbara (Part Two)
On June 30, the Supreme Court held in Trump v. Barbara that nearly all children...
A Seat at the Sitting - March 2026
Each month, a panel of constitutional experts convenes to discuss the Court’s upcoming docket sitting...
Panel: Originalism, Birthright Citizenship and the 14th Amendment
Prof. Amanda Frost, David Lurton Massee, Jr., Professor of Law, Director, Immigration, Migration and Human Rights...
Welcome & Luncheon Debate: Resolved: The President Has the Indefeasible Power of Removal
Resolved: The President Has the Indefeasible Power of Removal Prof. Aditya Bamzai, Professor of Law, University...
Courthouse Steps Preview: Trump v. Barbara
On June 27, 2025, a class action lawsuit was filed in the United States District...
2025 Ron Rotunda Memorial Webinar
Judicial Independence and the Rule of Law: Where We've Been, Where We're Going, and What To Do About It
Professor Ron Rotunda wrote seminal law books that are still used in law schools across...
Courthouse Steps Decision: Trump v. CASA, Inc.
On January 20, 2025, President Trump issued an executive order effectively ending birthright citizenship for...
Daniel Webster Debate Series: Should the Court Overturn Citizens United?
The Federalist Society's Georgetown Law Chapter'sDaniel Webster Debate Series presents Daniel Webster Debate Series:Should...
Courthouse Steps Preview: Moore v. United States
On December 5, 2023, the Supreme Court will hear oral argument in Moore v. United...
PG-15: FedSoc Study Break: The Duty to Represent the Unpopular Client
30 Minutes. Your Questions. Their Answers.
The Federalist Society’s Professional Responsibility & Legal Education Practice Group, Student Division & The University...
Tiwari v. Friedlander: Which Rational Basis Test is it Anyway?
In Tiwari v. Friedlander, the Petitioners ask the Supreme Court to grant certiorari to address...
Talks with Authors: Created Equal: Clarence Thomas in His Own Words
Mark Paoletta and Michael Pack have co-edited a new book, Created Equal: Clarence Thomas in His...
Is the EEOC misusing the Freedom of Information Act to penalize employers that adopt mandatory employment arbitration programs?
The EEOC is denying employers’ FOIA requests for the EEOC’s charge investigation files when resulting...
Are We Still One People? Do We Hold These Truths?
Much has been written, published and broadcast about a Divided America—especially now, with the Dobbs...
Courthouse Steps Decision Webinar: Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization
On June 24, 2022, the US Supreme Court decided Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization. In...
Luncheon & Keynote Address
Featuring: Hon. William H. Pryor, Chief Judge, United States Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit Introduction...
Panel 2 - Better Believe It: Free Exercise and the First Amendment
Leading the charge for abolition during the Civil War-era, among others, were abolitionists with deeply...
Panel 1 - Different Perspectives on The Fourteenth Amendment
The Fourteenth Amendment, adopted in 1868, dramatically changed constitutional law. How are we to understand...
The Application of the Constitution to the Territories
with Omar Andino Figueroa
Please join the Evansville Lawyers Chapter for a Zoom webinar with Omar Andino Figueroa, Deputy Solicitor...
Against Living Common Goodism
Federalist Society Review, Volume 23
Today I want to discuss a new version of an old debate. In 1985, then-Attorney...
Against Living Common Goodism
Federalist Society Review, Volume 23
Today I want to discuss a new version of an old debate. In 1985, then-Attorney...
Panel VI: 1995 National Student Symposium, The Original Meaning of the Fourteenth Amendment [Archive Collection]
1995 National Student Symposium
On April 7-9, 1995, the Federalist Society held its fourteenth annual National Student Symposium at...
Book Review: Unborn Human Life and Fundamental Rights: Leading Constitutional Cases under Scrutiny
In Unborn Human Life and Fundamental Rights: Leading Constitutional Cases under Scrutiny (Peter Lang, 2019), editors William...
Panel IV: Is Originalism Possible? Normative Indeterminacy and the Judicial Role [Archive Collection]
1995 National Student Symposium
On April 7-9, 1995, the Federalist Society held its fourteenth annual National Student Symposium at...
Freedom of Thought on Campus: Discussion and Debate at Georgetown
Is open discussion and debate essential to the function of the university? Many universities, including...
Talks with Authors: The Great Dissenter: The Story of John Marshall Harlan
The Great Dissenter: The Story of John Marshall Harlan, America's Judicial Hero is a new book...
Feddie Night Festivus: Blackman vs. Everybody!
Columbus School of Law Student Chapter
The Federalist Society's Student Division &Columbus School of Law Student Chapter present Feddie Night Festivus:Blackman vs. Everybody! FeaturingUnprecedented...
Courthouse Steps Decision Webinar: Whole Woman's Health v. Jackson
A Federalist Society Webinar
On December 10, 2021, the U.S. Supreme Court decided Whole Woman's Health v. Jackson and dismissed the...
What Happened to Natural Law in American Jurisprudence?
Federalist Society Review, Volume 22
A Review of The Decline of Natural Law: How American Lawyers Once Used Natural Law and...
What Happened to Natural Law in American Jurisprudence?
Federalist Society Review, Volume 22
A Review of The Decline of Natural Law: How American Lawyers Once Used Natural Law and...
Panel II: How Effective Are Bills of Rights in Protecting Freedom and Civil Liberties? [Archive Collection]
1991 National Student Symposium
On March 1-2, 1991, the Federalist Society's Yale Law School student chapter hosted the annual...
Banquet Address by William J. Bennett [Archive Collection]
1991 Annual Lawyers Convention
On September 13-14, 1991, the Federalist Society hosted its fifth annual National Lawyers Convention at...
Panel III: The Modern Role of the Privileges or Immunities Clause [Archive Collection]
1988 National Student Symposium
On March 4-5, 1988, The Federalist Society's University of Virginia student chapter hosted the National...
Departmentalism: What is the Executive Role in Interpreting laws?
2021 Ohio Lawyers Chapters Conference
On May 7, 2021, the Federalist Society's Ohio lawyers chapters hosted the 2021 Ohio Chapters...
Which Rights Are We Mediating?
Federalist Society Review, Volume 21
A review of How Rights Went Wrong: Why Our Obsession With Rights Is Tearing America...
Session II: SCOTUS after the Barrett Confirmation
2021 Annual Florida Chapters Conference
On January 30, 2021, The Federalist Society's Florida lawyers chapters hosted their annual Florida Chapters...
Book Review: The Law of Law School, by Andrew Guthrie Ferguson and Jonathan Yusef Newton
Mentoring law students and advising people considering law school about the pros and cons of...
Panel II: Presidential Lawmaking Powers: Vetoes, Line Item Vetoes, Signing Statements, Executive Orders, and Delegations of Rulemaking Authority [Archive Collection]
The Presidency and Congress
On January 19-20, 1990, The Federalist Society hosted a conference at the Mayflower Hotel in...
Privileges or Immunities: More Than a Nullity, But Not Boundless
The Federalist Society is pleased to announce its Student Blog Initiative, a project of the...
Privileges or Immunities: More Than a Nullity, But Not Boundless
The Federalist Society is pleased to announce its Student Blog Initiative, a project of the...
Necessary & Proper Episode 60: Supreme Court Nominations and the Perils of Court-Packing
On November 17, 2020, the Federalist Society's Article I Initiative and the Little Rock Lawyers...
Supreme Court Nominations and the Perils of Court-Packing
Little Rock Lawyers Chapter - Online Event
On November 17, 2020, the Federalist Society's Article I Initiative and the Little Rock Lawyers...
Panel IV: The Role of the Legislative and Executive Branches in Interpreting the Constitution [Archive Collection]
1987 National Student Symposium
On April 3-5, 1987, the Federalist Society's Chicago Student Chapter hosted the sixth annual National...
The Future of Originalism: A Federalist Society Zoom Dialogue
Houston Lawyers Chapter & Austin Lawyers Chapter - Online Event
On May 27, 2020, the Federalist Society's Houston and Austin lawyers chapters co-hosted a Zoom...
Panel IV: Originalism and Interstate Relations
2020 National Student Symposium
On March 14, 2020, the Federalist Society held its 39th National Student Symposium. The Symposium...
To Bear Arms for Self-Defense: A “Right of the People” or a Privilege of the Few? Part 1
Federalist Society Review, Volume 21
Note from the Editor: The Federalist Society takes no positions on particular legal and public...
To Bear Arms for Self-Defense: A “Right of the People” or a Privilege of the Few? Part 1
Federalist Society Review, Volume 21
Note from the Editor: The Federalist Society takes no positions on particular legal and public...
Panel IV: The Open-Ended Clauses of the Constitution: Due Process, Privileges or Immunities, the Guarantee Clause and the Ninth Amendment [Archive Collection]
First Annual National Lawyers Convention
On January 30-31, 1987, the Federalist Society hosted its annual National Lawyers Convention at the...
Panel III: Precedent, The Amendment Process, and Evolution in Constitutional Doctrine [Archive Collection]
First Annual National Lawyers Convention
On January 30-31, 1987, the Federalist Society hosted its annual National Lawyers Convention at the...
The Mythical McCulloch
Federalist Society Review, Volume 21
A Review of The Spirit of the Constitution: John Marshall and the 200-Year Odyssey of...
Banquet and Discussion with Justice Clarence Thomas
2020 Annual Florida Chapters Conference
This fireside chat between Honorable Gregory G. Katsas and Justice Clarence Thomas was given on...
Panel 2: The Anti-Federalists and Theories of Originalism
2020 Annual Western Chapters Conference
On January 25, 2020, the Federalist Society hosted its annual Western Chapters Conference at the...
Keynote Address by Richard Epstein [Archive Collection]
A Symposium in Celebration of the Bicentennial of the Constitution
On October 16, 1987, The Federalist Society hosted a symposium in celebration of the bicentennial...
Horizontal Federalism: May States Project their Sovereignty Beyond Their Borders?
2019 National Lawyers Convention
On November 14, 2019, the Federalist Society's Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group hosted...
Showcase Panel III: Does Originalism Protect Unenumerated Rights?
2019 National Lawyers Convention
On November 16, 2019, the Federalist Society hosted the third showcase panel of the 2019...
Showcase Panel II: Why, or Why Not, Be an Originalist?
2019 National Lawyers Convention
On November 15, 2019, the Federalist Society hosted the second showcase panel of the 2019...
Opening Remarks with Governor Ron DeSantis
2019 National Lawyers Convention
On November 14, 2019, The Federalist Society opened its 2019 National Lawyers Convention at the...
Opening Remarks and Welcome to Arizona
2019 National Student Symposium
On March 15-16, 2019, the Federalist Society's student chapter at the ASU Sandra Day O'Connor...
Article: Debating Birthright Citizenship - Two Perspectives
Below are selections from the Federalist Society's Journal, Engage: Volume 17, Issue 1, articulating the legal...
Article: Debating Birthright Citizenship - Two Perspectives
Below are selections from the Federalist Society's Journal, Engage: Volume 17, Issue 1, articulating the legal...
The Lives of the Constitution
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group Teleforum
The Lives of the Constitution: Ten Exceptional Minds that Shaped America’s Supreme Law is a...
The Morality of Consent - Podcast
Professional Responsibilities Practice Group Podcast
The Federalist Society's Legal Classics Revisited series returns to the writing of Professor Alexander Bickel...
The Least Dangerous Branch? Reflections on Bickel’s Classic - Podcast
Professional Responsibilities & Legal Education Practice Group Podcast
The Federalist Society's Teleforum series, Legal Classics Revisited, will consider Professor Alexander Bickel's 1962 book,...
Administrative Law and Judicial Duty: Justice Thomas' Principled Stand Against Arbitrary Power
Few constitutional scholars would deny that the Supreme Court has made tragic—even shameful—errors in interpreting...
Administrative Law and Judicial Duty: Justice Thomas' Principled Stand Against Arbitrary Power
Few constitutional scholars would deny that the Supreme Court has made tragic—even shameful—errors in interpreting...
Birthright Citizenship: Two Perspectives
Engage, Volume 17, Issue 1
Note from the Editor: This pair of articles debates the original meaning of Section 1...
Birthright Citizenship: Two Perspectives
Engage, Volume 17, Issue 1
Note from the Editor: This pair of articles debates the original meaning of Section 1...
Implementing Obergefell v. Hodges - Podcast
Religious Liberties Practice Group Podcast
On June 26, 2015, by a 5 to 4 margin, in Obergefell v. Hodges, the...
Debating Birthright Citizenship - Podcast
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group Podcast
The Citizenship Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution states that "All...
America's Great Charter
Eight hundred years and a few weeks ago, a group of rebellious barons forced King...
America's Great Charter
Eight hundred years and a few weeks ago, a group of rebellious barons forced King...
Gay Marriage Cases Decided: Obergefell v. Hodges - Podcast
Religious Liberties Practice Group Podcast
In a 5-4 decision, the Supreme Court today resolved the gay marriage case, ruling that...
The Constitution: An Introduction - Podcast
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group Podcast
In their new book, The Constitution: An Introduction, constitutional scholar Michael Stokes Paulsen and his...
Justice Alito Reviews "The Constitution: An Introduction" by Michael Stokes Paulsen & Luke Paulsen
Engage Volume 16, Issue 1
The Constitution: An Introduction by Michael Stokes Paulsen & Luke Paulsen Reviewed by Justice Samuel...
Justice Alito Reviews "The Constitution: An Introduction" by Michael Stokes Paulsen & Luke Paulsen
Engage Volume 16, Issue 1
The Constitution: An Introduction by Michael Stokes Paulsen & Luke Paulsen Reviewed by Justice Samuel...
Our Lost Constitution: The Willful Subversion of America's Founding Document - Podcast
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group Podcast
The still-unfolding story of America’s Constitution is a history of heroes and villains—the flawed visionaries...
Is the Matthew Shepard and James Byrd Jr. Hate Crimes Act in Part Unconstitutional? - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
Congress premised the part of the Hate Crimes Prevention Act banning crimes based on race...
The Court Decides: The Prop 8 and DOMA Cases - Podcast
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group and Religious Liberties Practice Group Podcast
On June 26th, the U.S. Supreme Court decided two same sex marriage cases: the Proposition...
Same-Sex Marriage Debate
2013 Annual Western Conference
The closing event at the 2013 Annual Western Conference was a debate on same-sex marriage...
The Philosopher in Action: A Tribute to the Honorable Edwin Meese III
Engage Volume 13, Issue 1, March 2012
In December 2011, former U.S. Attorney General Edwin Meese celebrated his 80th birthday. While his...
The Philosopher in Action: A Tribute to the Honorable Edwin Meese III
Engage Volume 13, Issue 1, March 2012
In December 2011, former U.S. Attorney General Edwin Meese celebrated his 80th birthday. While his...
Illuminating Citizens United: What the Decision Really Did
Engage Volume 12, Issue 3, November 2011
In January 2010, the U.S. Supreme Court issued one of its most controversial decisions in...
Illuminating Citizens United: What the Decision Really Did
Engage Volume 12, Issue 3, November 2011
In January 2010, the U.S. Supreme Court issued one of its most controversial decisions in...
Birthright Citizenship
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
The Citizenship Clause of the 14th Amendment states that "All persons born or naturalized in the...
The Sotomayor Nomination, Part III
Online Debate
On May 26th, President Obama nominated Sonia Sotomayor to replace David Souter as an Associate...
What Place Does Religion Have in the Public Square?
George Mason Student Chapter
The George Mason Student Chapter held this event on March 18, 2009. Speakers: Dr. Jeremy Gunn,...
The Constitution and the Importance of Interpretation: Original Meaning
Louisville Lawyers Chapter, The Alexander Hamilton Historical Society of Kentucky, and the League of Women Voters of Kentucky
The Louisville Lawyers Chapter co-sponsored this event with The Alexander Hamilton Historical Society of Kentucky...
The Unbearable Wrongness of Roe v. Wade
Fordham Student Chapter
The following audio and video were recorded on March 5, 2009. This event was co-sponsored with the Catholic...
Special Session: Judicial Independence Dialogue
2008 National Lawyers Convention
Hon. William H., Pryor Jr., United States Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit Mr. H. Thomas...
The 2008 Election and the Federal Courts
Michigan Lawyers Chapter
On October 28, 2008, the Michigan Lawyers Chapter presented a debate on "The 2008 Election...
The Presidency and the Federal Courts: Historical Reflections
The Presidency and the Courts
Louis D. Bilionis, University of Cincinnati College of Law Wendy Long, Judicial Confirmation Network Jeffrey...
Balancing Individual Rights and National Security
Boston Lawyers Chapter
The Boston Lawyers Chapter presented this debate on National Security & Civil Rights on October...
How Should the Courts Interpret Split Decisions?
The Supreme Court occasionally renders plurality opinions, which may involve 4-1-4 decisions or any number...
The Missouri Plan - Event Audio
Kansas City Lawyers Chapter
On June 21, 2007, Missouri Governor Matt Blunt delivered an address on the Missouri judicial...
Implications of the Dred Scott Case for Appellate Review - Event Audio
Kansas City Lawyers Chapter
For the Kansas City Lawyers Chapter Third Thursday Luncheon, Judge Duane Benton of the United...
Implications of the Dred Scott Case for Appellate Review - Event Audio
Kansas City Lawyers Chapter
For the Kansas City Lawyers Chapter Third Thursday Luncheon, Judge Duane Benton of the United...
Abortion and the Courts
Online Debate
The Supreme Court has upheld the constitutionality of the Partial-Birth Abortion Ban Act, passed by...
Gay Marriage in California: Legal and Political Prospects
Religious Liberties Practice Group
In 1977, the California legislature amended its family code, Section 300, to read that marriage...
Five Questions on Immigration Reform
Below, two Federalist Society members pose and then answer questions about the Immigration Reform measures...
Five Questions on Immigration Reform
Below, two Federalist Society members pose and then answer questions about the Immigration Reform measures...
The RFRA Decision: A Blow for Judicial Supremacy and Against Religious Freedom
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group Newsletter - Volume 1, Issue 3, Fall 1997
It does not often happen that a "conservative" Supreme Court manages, in a single decision,...
The RFRA Decision: A Blow for Judicial Supremacy and Against Religious Freedom
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group Newsletter - Volume 1, Issue 3, Fall 1997
It does not often happen that a "conservative" Supreme Court manages, in a single decision,...
Whether There is a Constitutional Right to Die
Criminal Law & Procedure Practice Group Newsletter - Volume 1, Issue 2, Spring 1997
The existence of a constitutional right to die is currently under consideration by the United...
The Great Debate: Attorney General Ed Meese III - November 15, 1985
Speech by Attorney General Edwin Meese, III before The Federalist Society Lawyers Division on November 15, 1985
Attorney General Edwin Meese III Before the DC Chapter of the Federalist Society Lawyers Division...
The Great Debate: Attorney General Ed Meese III - November 15, 1985
Speech by Attorney General Edwin Meese, III before The Federalist Society Lawyers Division on November 15, 1985
Attorney General Edwin Meese III Before the DC Chapter of the Federalist Society Lawyers Division...
Courthouse Steps Decision Webinar: Whole Woman's Health v. Jackson
A Federalist Society Webinar
TeleforumDoes the Constitution Have Anything To Do with Constitutional Law?
Sullivans Steakhouse 300 Colorado StreetAustin,
Nationalizing Gay Marriage through the Side Door:
The Lessons of Dred Scott, Lemmon v. The People, and Article IV of the Constitution
Columbia Law.
New York, NY 10027