Our website is currently undergoing updates, some links may no longer work and content may change. Please check back soon.

Facts of the Case

Provided by Oyez

Dred Scott was a slave in Missouri. From 1833 to 1843, he resided in Illinois (a free state) and in the Louisiana Territory, where slavery was forbidden by the Missouri Compromise of 1820. After returning to Missouri, Scott filed suit in Missouri court for his freedom, claiming that his residence in free territory made him a free man. After losing, Scott brought a new suit in federal court. Scott's master maintained that no “negro” or descendant of slaves could be a citizen in the sense of Article III of the Constitution.


Questions

  1. Was Dred Scott free or a slave?

Conclusions

  1. The majority held that “a negro, whose ancestors were imported into [the U.S.], and sold as slaves,” whether enslaved or free, could not be an American citizen and therefore did not have standing to sue in federal court. Because the Court lacked jurisdiction, Taney dismissed the case on procedural grounds.

    Taney further held that the Missouri Compromise of 1820 was unconstitutional and foreclose Congress from freeing slaves within Federal territories. The opinion showed deference to the Missouri courts, which held that moving to a free state did not render Scott emancipated. Finally, Taney ruled that slaves were property under the Fifth Amendment, and that any law that would deprive a slave owner of that property was unconstitutional. 

    In dissent, Benjamin Robbins Curtis criticized Taney for addressing the claim’s substance after finding the Court lacked jurisdiction. He pointed out that invalidating the Missouri Compromise was not necessary to resolve the case, and cast doubt on Taney’s position that the Founders categorically opposed anti-slavery laws. 

    John McLean echoed Curtis, finding the majority improperly reviewed the claim’s substance when its holding should have been limited to procedure. He also argued that men of African descent could be citizens because they already had the right to vote in five states.

A Seat at the Sitting - March 2026

A Seat at the Sitting - March 2026

Each month, a panel of constitutional experts convenes to discuss the Court’s upcoming docket sitting...

Courthouse Steps Decision Webinar: Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization

Courthouse Steps Decision Webinar: Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization

On June 24, 2022, the US Supreme Court decided Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization. In...

Departmentalism: What is the Executive Role in Interpreting laws?

Departmentalism: What is the Executive Role in Interpreting laws?

2021 Ohio Lawyers Chapters Conference

On May 7, 2021, the Federalist Society's Ohio lawyers chapters hosted the 2021 Ohio Chapters...

Session II: SCOTUS after the Barrett Confirmation

2021 Annual Florida Chapters Conference

On January 30, 2021, The Federalist Society's Florida lawyers chapters hosted their annual Florida Chapters...

Banquet and Discussion with Justice Clarence Thomas

2020 Annual Florida Chapters Conference

This fireside chat between Honorable Gregory G. Katsas and Justice Clarence Thomas was given on...

Panel 2: The Anti-Federalists and Theories of Originalism

2020 Annual Western Chapters Conference

On January 25, 2020, the Federalist Society hosted its annual Western Chapters Conference at the...

Horizontal Federalism: May States Project their Sovereignty Beyond Their Borders?

2019 National Lawyers Convention

On November 14, 2019, the Federalist Society's Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group hosted...

Justice Alito Reviews "The Constitution: An Introduction" by Michael Stokes Paulsen & Luke Paulsen

Justice Alito Reviews "The Constitution: An Introduction" by Michael Stokes Paulsen & Luke Paulsen

Engage Volume 16, Issue 1

The Constitution: An Introduction by Michael Stokes Paulsen & Luke Paulsen   Reviewed by Justice Samuel...

Justice Alito Reviews "The Constitution: An Introduction" by Michael Stokes Paulsen & Luke Paulsen

Justice Alito Reviews "The Constitution: An Introduction" by Michael Stokes Paulsen & Luke Paulsen

Engage Volume 16, Issue 1

The Constitution: An Introduction by Michael Stokes Paulsen & Luke Paulsen   Reviewed by Justice Samuel...

The Constitution and the Importance of Interpretation: Original Meaning

Louisville Lawyers Chapter, The Alexander Hamilton Historical Society of Kentucky, and the League of Women Voters of Kentucky

The Louisville Lawyers Chapter co-sponsored this event with The Alexander Hamilton Historical Society of Kentucky...