Facts of the Case
The state of New York requires a person to show a special need for self-protection to receive an unrestricted license to carry a concealed firearm outside the home. Robert Nash and Brandon Koch challenged the law after New York rejected their concealed-carry applications based on failure to show “proper cause.” A district court dismissed their claims, and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit affirmed.
Questions
Does New York's law requiring that applicants for unrestricted concealed-carry licenses demonstrate a special need for self-defense violate the Second Amendment?
Conclusions
-
New York’s proper-cause requirement violates the Fourteenth Amendment by preventing law-abiding citizens with ordinary self-defense needs from exercising their Second Amendment right to keep and bear arms in public for self-defense.
The right to carry a firearm in public for self-defense is deeply rooted in history, and no other constitutional right requires a showing of “special need” to exercise it. While some “sensitive places” restrictions might be appropriate, Manhattan is not a “sensitive place.” Gun restrictions are constitutional only if there is a tradition of such regulation in U.S. history.
Justice Samuel Alito authored a concurring opinion arguing that the effect of guns on American society is irrelevant to the issue.
Justice Brett Kavanaugh authored a concurring opinion, in which Chief Justice John Roberts joined, noting that many state restrictions requiring background checks, firearms training, a check of mental health records, and fingerprinting, are still permissible because they are objective, in contrast to the discretionary nature of New York’s law.
Justice Amy Coney Barrett authored a concurring opinion noting two methodological points the Court did not resolve.
Justice Stephen Breyer authored a dissenting opinion, in which Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan joined. Justice Breyer argued that states should be able to pass restrictions in an effort to curb the number of deaths caused by gun violence, and the Court’s decision “severely burdens the States’ efforts to do so.”
Beyond Bruen: Exploring the Supreme Court's Second Amendment Jurisprudence Past, Present and Future
The Supreme Court's Second Amendment jurisprudence continues to evolve. This past Term, the Court issued...
From the Courthouse Steps: United States v. Hemani
In United States v. Hemani, the Supreme Court unanimously affirmed the dismissal of an indictment...
From the Courthouse Steps: Wolford v. Lopez
In Wolford v. Lopez, the Supreme Court held that Hawaii’s law prohibiting licensed concealed-carry permit...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: United States v. Hemani
On March 2, 2026, the Supreme Court will hear oral argument in United States v. Hemani....
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: Wolford v. Lopez
In New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen (2022), the Supreme Court invalidated...
Showcase Panel 1: Landmark SCOTUS Decisions of the 2020s
2025 National Lawyers Convention
CLE credit for this event is available at On-Demand CLE. This year marks the 20th anniversary...
Talks with Authors: Born Equal: Remaking America's Constitution, 1840–1920
In Born Equal: Remaking America’s Constitution, 1840–1920, Prof. Akhil Reed Amar traces the arc of...
Litigation Update: Attorney’s Fees as Deterrence in Civil Rights Litigation
When Congress amended the Civil Rights Act in 1976, it directed federal courts to use...
Trump v. Big Law
Discussing the Law Firm EOs & Associated Litigation
President Trump has issued several executive orders addressing alleged national security threats and discriminatory practices...
Litigation Update: United States v. Peterson
In February 2025, the Fifth Circuit issued an opinion in United States v. Peterson, ruling...
Practice Groups: Applying the Text and History Methodology to Looming Second Amendment Battles After Rahimi
2024 National Lawyers Convention
Last term, the Supreme Court decided United States v. Rahimi, which built upon the text-first,...
2024 Ron Rotunda Memorial Webinar: Profiles in Courage in the Legal Profession
Professor Ron Rotunda wrote seminal law books that are still used in law schools across...
The First Amendment in Trademark Law after Vidal v. Elster
In Vidal v. Elster (the “Trump Too Small” case), the Supreme Court unanimously upheld a...
2024 Annual Supreme Court Round Up
On Thursday, July 25, the Washington, D.C. Lawyers Chapter gathered for the annual Supreme...
Discussing Garland v. Cargill
Garland v. Cargill concerned whether bump stocks are considered "machineguns" as defined by Title 26...
Courthouse Steps Decision: United States v. Rahimi
United States v. Rahimi raised the question of whether 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(8), which prohibits...
In Rahimi, Gun Control Advocates Score a Minor (And Mostly Hollow) Victory
In an 8-1 opinion by Chief Justice Roberts, the Supreme Court in United States v....
Courthouse Steps Decision: Vidal v. Elster
What Are Its Implications for Trademark Law and First Amendment Free Speech Protections?
In recent years, the Supreme Court has decided two cases in which it held that...
A Conversation about Supreme Court Ethics and Journalistic Integrity
For several weeks, much media attention has focused on reports of flags flown outside the...
NetChoice and Murthy: Speech and Coercion in the Digital Age
What can state actors do to protect or interfere with online public discourse? The recent...
A Seat at the Sitting - March 2024
The March Docket in 90 Minutes or Less
Each month, a panel of constitutional experts convenes to discuss the Court’s upcoming docket sitting...
Challenges to Originalism V: Originalism is Not Up to the Task of Dealing with Modern Problems
The Federalist Society's Student Division & University of South Dakota School of Law Student...
A Seat at the Sitting - February 2024
The February Docket in 90 Minutes or Less
Each month, a panel of constitutional experts convenes to discuss the Court’s upcoming docket sitting...
Second Amendment: Will the Supreme Court Adhere to Bruen (and Originalism) in Rahimi and Beyond?
2023 National Lawyers Convention
Oral argument was held in U.S. v. Rahimi on November 7, 2023. The case asks...
Mere Natural Law
2023 National Lawyers Convention
The U.S. Supreme Court’s originalist jurisprudence has been on display in its most recent terms...
Showcase Panel II: Whither Precedent?
2023 National Lawyers Convention
No one maintains that the Court has always and forever been originalist in its orientation....
Showcase Panel I: Roundtable: Originalism on the Ground
2023 National Lawyers Convention
Trying to sort out what originalism means in practice requires integrating insights from all levels...
Litigation Update: Koons v. Platkin
Koons v. Platkin is a challenge to certain provisions of New Jersey Bill A4769/S3214 –...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: United States v. Rahimi
United States v. Rahimi, set to be argued before the Supreme Court this fall, raises...
The Second Amendment, From Bruen to Rahimi
On November 7, the Supreme Court will hear oral arguments in United States v....
A Seat at the Sitting - November 2023
The November Docket in 90 Minutes or Less
Each month, a panel of constitutional experts convenes to discuss the Court’s upcoming docket sitting...
Supreme Court Preview: What Is in Store for October Term 2023?
Co-Sponsored by the Faculty Division and Practice Groups
On September 26, 2023, the Federalist Society's Faculty Division and Practice Groups will host a panel at the Mayflower...
Ethics of Client Coercion Webinar
Is it ethical for in-house attorneys to leverage their employer’s economic clout to interfere with...
Originalism Carries On
Federalist Society Review, Volume 24
A review of Erwin Chemerinsky, A Momentous Year in the Supreme Court: October Term 2021...
A Seat at the Sitting - April 2023
The April Docket in 90 Minutes or Less
Each month, a panel of constitutional experts convenes to discuss the Court’s upcoming docket sitting...
Courthouse Steps Preview: Tyler v. Hennepin County
The Supreme Court Decides Whether Government Taking of Surplus Proceeds from a Tax-Foreclosure Sale Violates the Fifth Amendment
Geraldine Tyler, a ninety-three-year-old homeowner, owed Hennepin County, Minnesota, nearly $12,700 in delinquent property taxes,...
Panel V: Is Judicial Review Democratic?
2023 National Student Symposium
Judicial Review has been criticized throughout American history as undemocratic, creating what has been known...
Text-and-History or Means-End Scrutiny? A Response to Professor Nelson Lund's Critique of Bruen
Federalist Society Review, Volume 24
Professor Nelson Lund’s “Bruen’s Preliminary Preservation of the Second Amendment,” recently published in the Federalist...
Talks with Authors: An Introduction to Constitutional Law: 100+ Supreme Court Cases Everyone Should Know
Professors Randy Barnett and Josh Blackman will discuss the most important Supreme Court cases of...
Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard: Affirmative Action Goes to Court
2022 National Lawyers Convention
The panel is sponsored by our Civil Rights practice group and will focus on the...
The Judge’s Role in Choosing a Successor
2022 National Lawyer's Convention
Under the Constitution, two branches of government are formally involved in the selection of federal...
Special Session II: Second Amendment: Aftermath of Bruen; What's Next at the State Level?
National Lawyers Convention 2022
In June 2022, the Supreme Court decided the much-anticipated case, New York State Rifle and...
Special Session I: Dobbs, Roe, Casey, and the Rule of Law
2022 National Lawyers Convention
On June 24, 2022, the U.S. Supreme Court released a 6-3 decision in Dobbs v....
Bruen’s Preliminary Preservation of the Second Amendment
Federalist Society Review, Volume 23
A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right...
The Original Understanding of the Indian Commerce Clause: An Update
Federalist Society Review, Volume 23
The Congress shall have Power . . . To regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and...
Should the Future Be Determined by the Past? Bearing Arms After Bruen.
Professor Nelson Lund will moderate a debate between Professors Adam Winkler and Robert Leider on...
A Discussion on Dobbs
Please join the Federalist Society's Practice Groups for a virtual event on Dobbs v. Jackson...
The Future of Homemade Firearms: The Legal and Political Implications of ATF Final Rule 2021R-05F
Americans have been privately manufacturing and assembling firearms since before this country’s founding. Now, thanks...
From Guns to Websites: Clarifying Tiers of Scrutiny for Free-Speech Cases
In New York State Rifle & Pistol Association, Inc. v. Bruen, the Supreme Court ruled...
Courthouse Steps Decision: Carson v. Makin
On June 21, 2022, the Supreme Court decided Carson v. Makin. In a 6-3 opinion, the...
Courthouse Steps Decision: New York State Rifle & Pistol Association Inc. v. Bruen
On June 23, 2022, the Supreme Court decided New York State Rifle & Pistol Association...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: New York State Rifle and Pistol Association v. Bruen
Will the Supreme Court Recognize a Right to Bear Arms in Public?
In District of Columbia v. Heller (2008) and McDonald v. City of Chicago (2010), the Supreme Court decided for...
Second Amendment: Next Steps in the Unfolding Litigation Battle
2021 National Lawyers Convention
The 2021 National Lawyers Convention took place November 11-13, 2021 at the Mayflower Hotel in...
Feddie Night Fights: NYSRPA v. Bruen: What Rights Does the Second Amendment Guarantee Outside the Home?
Saint Louis Student Chapter
Feddie Night Fights. It’s On. The Federalist Society’s Student Division &Saint Louis University School of...
Bruen, Heller, and the Originalist Victory
Last week, the Court heard oral argument in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association...
Panel 3: Supreme Court Preview
Fifth Annual Kentucky Chapters Conference
This panel discussed the upcoming Supreme Court term, which began on October 4, 2021....
A Seat at the Sitting - November 2021
The November Docket in 90 Minutes or Less
Join us for the second episode of the Federalist Society’s Supreme Court Show: A Seat at...
New York State Rifle & Pistol Association, Inc. v. City of New York, New York [SCOTUSbrief]
Short video featuring Josh Blackman
For the first time in nearly a decade, the Supreme Court is taking another look...
Second Amendment Returns to Supreme Court in New York State Rifle
The U.S. Supreme Court is taking up a Second Amendment case for oral argument for...
Special Session II: Second Amendment: Aftermath of Bruen; What's Next at the State Level?
National Lawyers Convention 2022
The Mayflower Hotel1127 Connecticut Ave NW
Washington, DC 20006
2022 National Lawyers Convention
The Current State of the Legal Profession
The Mayflower Hotel1127 Connecticut Ave NW
Washington, DC 20006
SCOTUS REVIEW with Justice Bolick and Judge Eckerstrom
Arizona Student Chapter
University of Arizona James E. Rogers College of Law1201 E Speedway Blvd
Tucson, AZ 85721