Facts of the Case
In March 2018, the City of Philadelphia barred Catholic Social Services (CSS) from placing children in foster homes because of its policy of not licensing same-sex couples to be foster parents. CSS sued the City of Philadelphia, asking the court to order the city to renew their contract. CSS argued that its right to free exercise of religion and free speech entitled it to reject qualified same-sex couples because they were same-sex couples, rather than for any reason related to their qualifications to care for children.
The district court denied CSS’s motion for a preliminary injunction, and the Third Circuit affirmed, finding that the City’s non-discrimination policy was a neutral, generally applicable law and that CSS had not demonstrated that the City targeted CSS for its religious beliefs or was motivated by ill will against its religion.
Questions
To succeed on their free exercise claim, must plaintiffs prove that the government would allow the same conduct by someone who held different religious views, or only provide sufficient evidence that a law is not neutral and generally applicable?
Should the Court revisit its decision in Employment Division v. Smith?
Does the government violate the First Amendment by conditioning a religious agency’s ability to participate in the foster care system on taking actions and making statements that directly contradict the agency’s religious beliefs?
Conclusions
-
The refusal of Philadelphia to contract with CSS for the provision of foster care services unless CSS agrees to certify same-sex couples as foster parents violates the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment. Chief Justice John Roberts authored the majority opinion of the Court.
Philadelphia’s actions burdened CSS’s religious exercise by forcing it either to curtail its mission or to certify same-sex couples as foster parents, in violation of its stated religious beliefs. Although the Court held in Employment Division v. Smith that neutral, generally applicable laws may incidentally burden religion, the Philadelphia law was not neutral and generally applicable because it allowed for exceptions to the anti-discrimination requirement at the sole discretion of the Commissioner. Additionally, CSS’s actions do not fall within public accommodations laws because certification as a foster parent is not “made available to the public” in the usual sense of the phrase. Thus, the non-discrimination requirement is subject to strict scrutiny, which requires that the government show the law is necessary to achieve a compelling government interest.
The Court pointed out that the question is not whether the City has a compelling interest in enforcing its non-discrimination policies generally, but whether it has such an interest in denying an exception to CSS. The Court concluded that it did not.
Justice Amy Coney Barrett wrote a separate concurring opinion in which Justice Brett Kavanaugh joined and in which Justice Stephen Breyer joined as to all but the first paragraph. Justice Barrett acknowledged strong arguments for overruling Smith but agreed with the majority that the facts of the case did not trigger Smith.
Justice Samuel Alito authored an opinion concurring in the judgment, in which Justices Clarence Thomas and Neil Gorsuch joined. Justice Alito would overrule Smith, replacing it with a rule that any law that burdens religious exercise must be subject to strict scrutiny.
Justice Gorsuch authored an opinion concurring in the judgment, in which Justices Thomas and Alito joined, criticizing the majority’s circumvention of Smith.
Further analysis of the oral argument available at Oral Argument 2.0: https://argument2.oyez.org/2020/fulton-v-city-of-philadelphia/
Litigation Update: Miller v. McDonald
All fifty states mandate certain vaccinations for schoolchildren. Forty-six of them allow religious exemptions. New...
After Drummond: What’s Next in the Debate over Religious Charter Schools?
In Oklahoma Statewide Charter School Board v. Drummond, the U.S. Supreme Court took up the...
A Significant Year for Religious Liberty?
An Update on the 2024-2025 Supreme Court Term
For the first time in years, the U.S. Supreme Court is addressing questions of religious...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: Oklahoma Statewide Charter School Board v. Drummond
On October 20, 2023, the Oklahoma Attorney General Gentner Drummond sued the Oklahoma Statewide Charter...
The Roots, Applications, and Trajectory of the Church Autonomy Doctrine
The First Amendment’s Religion Clauses guarantee religious entities the freedom to make certain internal governance...
Litigation Update: Kluge v. Brownsburg Community School Corporation
Where should the line be drawn in the debate between the rights of persons to...
Litigation Update: Mid Vermont Christian School v. Saunders
From the Olympics to San Jose State, each month we hear of new controversies where...
Litigation Update: Smith v. City of Atlantic City
The Atlantic City Fire Department requires all personnel who respond to fires or other emergencies...
Religious Liberty and the Court: Looking Ahead to the 2024-2025 Term
The Federalist Society is proud to host Mark Rienzi, President of the Becket Fund and...
Understanding Justice Thomas and Justice Barrett’s Fight Over History
It’s unusual to see news articles about disagreements between Supreme Court Justices, especially with phrases...
Free Exercise, History and Tradition, and Preferred Pronouns: Key Takeaways from Vlaming v. West Point School Board
High school French teacher Peter Vlaming was fired from his job in West Point, Virginia,...
Free Exercise and Abortion
In the wake of the Supreme Court’s decision in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization...
Litigation Update: Roman Catholic Diocese of Albany v. Vullo
In 2017, New York passed a law requiring employers to cover abortions in their health...
Litigation Update: Roman Catholic Diocese of Albany v. Vullo
In 2017, New York passed a law requiring employers to cover abortions in their health...
303 Creative, Masterpiece Cakeshop, and the Fate of Free Exercise for Wedding Vendors
Over the past decade, the tension between First Amendment rights and public accommodations laws has...
State Department’s Proposed Foreign Assistance Nondiscrimination Requirements Raise Concerns
On January 19, 2024, the U.S. Department of State issued two notices of proposed rulemaking...
State Department’s Proposed Foreign Assistance Nondiscrimination Requirements Raise Concerns
On January 19, 2024, the U.S. Department of State issued two notices of proposed rulemaking...
Litigation Update: First Amendment Matters in the Classroom
The intersection of the First Amendment, parental rights, and educational texts has become a topic...
Litigation Update: Bella Health and Wellness v. Weiser
In Bella Health and Wellness v. Weiser, a Colorado faith-based healthcare provider is challenging a...
Deep Dive Episode 286: Litigation Update: Bella Health and Wellness v. Weiser
RTP's Fourth Branch Podcast
This is a podcast version of a live webinar held on December 13, 2023. The...
Litigation Update: Mahmoud v. McKnight
In Fall 2022 the Montgomery County Board of Education (MCBOE) revised its literature/ language arts...
Litigation Update: Rogers v. HHS & Maddonna v. HHS
Miracle Hill Ministries is one of nearly two dozen private entities with which the state...
Non-Affirmation of Child’s “LGBTQI+” Identity Is Abuse Under Proposed Foster Care Rule
On September 28, 2023, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Administration for Children...
Religious Liberty Pragmatism
Federalist Society Review, Volume 24
A review of Thomas C. Berg, Religious Liberty in a Polarized Age (Eerdmans 2023) In...
Religious Liberty Pragmatism
Federalist Society Review, Volume 24
A review of Thomas C. Berg, Religious Liberty in a Polarized Age (Eerdmans 2023) In...
Litigation Update: FCA v San Jose Unified School Dist.
Fellowship of Christian Athletes v. San Jose Unified School District concerned a Christian student club's...
Litigation Update: Bates v. Pakseresht
In Bates v. Pakseresht, Oregon mother-of-5 Jessica Bates is challenging the Oregon Department of Human...
Religious Liberty and the Court - Looking Ahead to the Next Term
For the past few Supreme Court terms we have hosted Mark Rienzi, President of the...
Mahmoud v. Montgomery County Public Schools: A Religious Liberty Controversy to Watch
In Maryland’s Montgomery County Public Schools, parents are forbidden to know when their elementary-school children...
2023 Annual Supreme Court Round Up
Registration is now closed. We will not be accepting walk-ins or on-site registration for this...
The Northwest Ordinance: Historically Significant, Still Relevant
Happy birthday to the Northwest Ordinance, which the Articles of Confederation Congress enacted on July...
The Northwest Ordinance: Historically Significant, Still Relevant
Happy birthday to the Northwest Ordinance, which the Articles of Confederation Congress enacted on July...
A Cord of Three Strands: How Kennedy v. Bremerton School District Changed Free Exercise, Establishment, and Free Speech Clause Doctrine
Federalist Society Review, Volume 24
In 2015, Bremerton High School football coach Joseph Kennedy lost his job for kneeling at...
Nine Agencies Propose Regulations for Partnerships with Faith-Based and Neighborhood Organizations
On January 13, 2023, nine agencies issued a notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM) titled “Partnerships...
Measuring and Evaluating Public Responses to Religious Rights Rulings
Federalist Society Review, Volume 23
The story of Jack Phillips and his cake shop—Masterpiece Cakeshop—is by now familiar. Jack Phillips...
Measuring and Evaluating Public Responses to Religious Rights Rulings
Federalist Society Review, Volume 23
The story of Jack Phillips and his cake shop—Masterpiece Cakeshop—is by now familiar. Jack Phillips...
Religious Liberty at the Supreme Court 2022
Please join these experts as they review religious liberty at the Supreme Court in 2022. Featuring:...
Panel 2 - Better Believe It: Free Exercise and the First Amendment
Leading the charge for abolition during the Civil War-era, among others, were abolitionists with deeply...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: Egbert v. Boule
A federal statute allows citizens to sue state and local officers for violating constitutional rights,...
Ramirez v. Collier: Religious Liberty on Death Row
The Supreme Court’s decision last month in Ramirez v. Collier was noteworthy for several reasons:...
Ramirez v. Collier: Religious Liberty on Death Row
The Supreme Court’s decision last month in Ramirez v. Collier was noteworthy for several reasons:...
Justice Breyer: His Legacy and Thoughts on His Replacement
Minnesota Lawyers Chapter
The Minnesota Lawyers Chapter of the Federalist Society held a Zoom webinar discussing Justice Breyer, his...
Abortion, Dobbs, and The Future of the Conservative Legal Movement
Evansville Lawyers Chapter
On February 18, 2022, the Evansville Lawyers Chapter hosted a Zoom webinar featuring Professor Josh...
Litigation Update: FEC v. Cruz for Senate
On January 19, 2022, the United States Supreme Court will hear an appeal by the Federal...
Religious Liberty after Fulton v. City of Philadelphia
2021 National Lawyers Convention
The 2021 National Lawyers Convention took place November 11-13, 2021 at the Mayflower Hotel in...
Religious Liberty after Fulton v. City of Philadelphia
2021 National Lawyers Convention
The 2021 National Lawyers Convention took place November 11-13, 2021 at the Mayflower Hotel in...
Courthouse Steps Pre-Argument Webinar: Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization
A Federalist Society Webinar
On December 1, 2021, the U.S. Supreme Court will hear Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization,...
2021 National Lawyers Convention Digital Survival Guide
Social Media Official Hashtag: #FedSoc2021 Federalist Society Twitter: @FedSoc Federalist Society Instagram: @FedSoc Regulatory Transparency...
Panel 3: Supreme Court Preview
Fifth Annual Kentucky Chapters Conference
This panel discussed the upcoming Supreme Court term, which began on October 4, 2021....
A Seat at the Sitting - November 2021
The November Docket in 90 Minutes or Less
Join us for the second episode of the Federalist Society’s Supreme Court Show: A Seat at...
2021 Supreme Court Preview
Jacksonville Lawyers Chapter - Online Event
On September 29, 2021, the Federalist Society's Jacksonville Lawyers Chapter hosted a virtual discussion giving...
The Search for a Workable Free Exercise Framework
Under Employment Division v. Smith, the Free Exercise Clause functions more like an antidiscrimination statute...
The Search for a Workable Free Exercise Framework
Under Employment Division v. Smith, the Free Exercise Clause functions more like an antidiscrimination statute...
An Extended Essay on Church Autonomy
Federalist Society Review, Volume 22
The doctrine of church autonomy[1] is distinct from the two more familiar lines of cases...
An Extended Essay on Church Autonomy
Federalist Society Review, Volume 22
The doctrine of church autonomy[1] is distinct from the two more familiar lines of cases...
In the Shadow of Sherbert: An Understanding of Smith as Judicial Codification
Like all of the rights guaranteed by the Bill of Rights, the right to freely...
In the Shadow of Sherbert: An Understanding of Smith as Judicial Codification
Like all of the rights guaranteed by the Bill of Rights, the right to freely...
Litigation Update: InterVarsity Christian Fellowship/USA v. University of Iowa et al.
Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group Teleforum
On July 16, 2021, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eight Circuit issued a...
Courthouse Steps Decision Webinar: Fulton v. City of Philadelphia
Religious Liberties Practice Group Teleforum
On June 17, 2021, the US Supreme Court unanimously decided Fulton v. City of Philadelphia...
Courthouse Steps Decision Webinar: Fulton v. City of Philadelphia
Religious Liberties Practice Group Teleforum
On June 17, 2021, the US Supreme Court unanimously decided Fulton v. City of Philadelphia...
Talks with Authors: Religious Liberty in Crisis
Religious Liberties Practice Group Teleforum
On June 16, 2021, The Federalist Society's Religious Liberties Practice Group hosted a teleforum titled...
Fulton v. City of Philadelphia - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
Featuring Mark L. Rienzi
On June 17th, 2021 the Supreme Court unanimously decided Fulton v. City of Philadelphia for...
Fulton v. City of Philadelphia - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
Featuring Mark L. Rienzi
On June 17th, 2021 the Supreme Court unanimously decided Fulton v. City of Philadelphia for...
From Employment Division v. Smith to Fulton v. City of Philadelphia: The Free Exercise Clause in 2021
Chattanooga and Nashville Lawyers Chapter - Online Event
On May 19, 2021 the Nashville and Chattanooga Lawyers Chapters co-hosted a discussion on the...
From Employment Division v. Smith to Fulton v. City of Philadelphia: The Free Exercise Clause in 2021
Chattanooga and Nashville Lawyers Chapter - Online Event
On May 19, 2021 the Nashville and Chattanooga Lawyers Chapters co-hosted a discussion on the...
Does The First Amendment Allow States To Require Religious Organizations To Pay for Abortions?
New York issued a new mandate that requires houses of worship to pay for abortions....
Does The First Amendment Allow States To Require Religious Organizations To Pay for Abortions?
New York issued a new mandate that requires houses of worship to pay for abortions....
Litigation Update: Meriwether v. Hartop
In a decision issued on March 26, 2021, the Sixth Circuit held Professor Nicholas Meriwether,...
We Are Free for a Reason
Federalist Society Review, Volume 22
A review of Free to Believe: The Battle Over Religious Liberty in America, by Luke...
Doctrine Briefing: The Ministerial Exception
In Our Lady of Guadalupe v. Morrissey-Berru (2020), the Supreme Court expanded on the ministerial exception doctrine it...
States have been violating religious schools’ First Amendment rights for decades. The Supreme Court may be about to stop them.
The Supreme Court rarely goes out of its way to make sweeping pronouncements. The Justices...
Session II: SCOTUS after the Barrett Confirmation
2021 Annual Florida Chapters Conference
On January 30, 2021, The Federalist Society's Florida lawyers chapters hosted their annual Florida Chapters...
How the Founders’ Natural Law Theory Illuminates the Original Meaning of Free Exercise
Federalist Society Review, Volume 22
In Fulton v. City of Philadelphia, the Supreme Court will consider whether Philadelphia’s 2018 policy...
SCOTUS Stops Cuomo’s COVID Synagogue Targeting
Greenville, Columbia, and Charleston South Carolina Lawyers Chapters
On December 17, 2020, the Federalist Society's Greenville, Columbia, and Charleston, South Carolina Lawyers Chapters...
Welcome & Luncheon Debate: Resolved: Employment Division v. Smith Should be Overruled
23rd Annual Federalist Society Faculty Conference
Welcome12:00 pm - 12:15pm Hon. Lee Liberman Otis, The Federalist Society Luncheon Debate: Resolved: Employment...
Courthouse Steps Decision Teleforum: Tanzin v. Tanvir
On December 10, the Supreme Court decided the case of Tanzin v. Tanvir. The 8-0 ruling...
Courthouse Steps Decision Teleforum: Roman Catholic Diocese of Brooklyn v. Cuomo
On November 25, 2020, the Supreme Court barred New York Governor Andrew Cuomo from enforcing...
Insufficiently Supported Causal Inferences: A Response to Barak-Corren and Tebbe
In November, the Supreme Court heard arguments in Fulton v. City of Philadelphia. That case...
Religious Liberties: Religious Liberty and the New Court
2020 National Lawyers Convention
On November 9, 2020, The Federalist Society's Religious Liberties Practice Group hosted a virtual panel...
Fulton v. City of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
featuring Mark Rienzi
On November 4, 2020, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Fulton v. City of...
Fulton v. City of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
featuring Mark Rienzi
On November 4, 2020, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Fulton v. City of...
NLC Panel of Interest: Religious Liberty and the New Court
A few days ago, on November 4, the U.S. Supreme Court heard oral arguments in a...
NLC Panel of Interest: Religious Liberty and the New Court
A few days ago, on November 4, the U.S. Supreme Court heard oral arguments in a...
United for Uzeugbunam
The Federalist Society is pleased to announce its Student Blog Initiative, a project of the...
United for Uzeugbunam
The Federalist Society is pleased to announce its Student Blog Initiative, a project of the...
Religious Liberty at the Supreme Court: Previewing the New Term
The Supreme Court's most recent term ended with several high-profile liberty rulings, including Espinoza v. Montana...
Special Topics in Religious Liberty Series #1: Recent and Upcoming Supreme Court Cases
In the 2019 Term, the U.S. Supreme Court issued three decisions with major implications for...
What Is The Best Way to Deal With Increasing Disputes over Religious Liberty?
Last term, the Supreme Court addressed several religious liberty-related matters in Bostock v. Clayton County,...
After Espinoza, What’s Left of the Establishment Clause?
Federalist Society Review, Volume 21
Note from the Editor: The Federalist Society takes no positions on particular legal and public...
Religious Liberty at the Supreme Court: The 2020 Term and Beyond
This summer, the Supreme Court decided several high-profile religious liberty cases. In Espinoza v. Montana Department...
Courthouse Steps Decision Teleforum: Espinoza v. Montana Department of Revenue
On June 30, the Supreme Court released its decision in the case of Espinoza v....
A Fulfillment of Judicial Prophecy: The Clash Between Religious Liberty and Nondiscrimination Law Reaches the Supreme Court
Catholic Social Services (CSS) of Philadelphia has offered services to needy children and families since...
Former Attorney General Meese Op-Ed on Fulton v. Philadelphia
Today, former Attorney General Ed Meese published an op-ed with Newsweek concerning a...
Litigation Update: COVID-19 and the Supreme Court’s Religious Liberty Cases
Amid a flurry of cancelations and postponements in response to the COVID-19 pandemic, many are...
Will the Supreme Court Revisit Employment Division v. Smith?
In 1990, the Supreme Court startled the nation with a decision in Employment Division v....
The Future of the Establishment Clause in the Roberts Court
2019 National Lawyers Convention
On November 14, 2019, the Federalist Society's Religious Liberty Practice Group held a panel for...
Litigation Update: Religious Foster Care Agencies and the First Amendment
What happens when governments try to exclude religious foster care agencies? Philadelphia put out an urgent...
The Future of the Establishment Clause in the Roberts Court
NLC Convention Panel: Religious Liberties Practice Group
Next Thursday’s Establishment Clause Panel at the Federalist Society National Lawyer’s Convention will be both...
The Future of the Establishment Clause in the Roberts Court
NLC Convention Panel: Religious Liberties Practice Group
Next Thursday’s Establishment Clause Panel at the Federalist Society National Lawyer’s Convention will be both...
Religious Liberty after Fulton v. City of Philadelphia
2021 National Lawyers Convention
The Mayflower Hotel1127 Connecticut Avenue, NW
Washington, DC 20036