Facts of the Case
Petitioner James L. Kisor is a veteran of the US Marine Corps who served in the Vietnam War. In 1982, Kisor filed a claim for disability benefits with the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) asserting that he suffered from post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) as a result of his service in Vietnam. Ultimately, the VA denied his claim in May 1983. In June 2006, Kisor sought review of his previously denied claim, and the VA granted him relief under 38 C.F.R. § 3.156(a), which allows a petitioner to “reopen” a denial by “submitting new and material evidence.” In his 2006 petition, Kisor identified materials supporting his claim that existed in 1983 but which were not associated with his file.
Notably, the VA did not grant Kisor relief under Section 3.156(c), which authorizes the agency to “reconsider” a previously denied claim in the event that it “receives or associates with the claims file relevant official service department records that existed and had not been associated with the claims file when VA first decided the claim.” This provision is more favorable to veterans because it provides for a retroactive effective date for any benefits awarded, whereas benefits granted under Section 3.156(a) are effective only on the date the application to reopen was filed.
The VA’s decision (technically made by the Board of Veterans Appeals) relied on the meaning of the term “relevant” as used in 38 C.F.R. § 3.156(c)(1). The VA found that the additional documents (Kisor’s Form 214 and the Combat History document) did not qualify as “relevant” for purposes of this section because it did not “suggest or better yet establish that [petitioner] has PTSD as a current disability.” In the VA’s view, records are not “relevant” when they are not “outcome determinative.”
Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims affirmed the Board’s decision, and the Federal Circuit affirmed as well.
Questions
Should Auer v. Robbins, 519 U.S. 452 (1997), and Bowles v. Seminole Rock & Sand Co., 325 U.S. 410 (1945), be overruled?
Conclusions
-
Auer v. Robbins, 519 U.S. 452 (1997), and Bowles v. Seminole Rock & Sand Co., 325 U.S. 410 (1945)—which direct courts to give deference to an agency’s reasonable reading of its own genuinely ambiguous regulations—are not overruled.
Justice Elena Kagan announced the judgment and delivered an opinion in which Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Stephen Breyer, and Sonia Sotomayor joined. Chief Justice Roberts joined in part, forming a majority of the Court for those parts.
Justice Kagan, writing for the 5-4 majority, first described the history of the case before it arrived before the Court.
Then, writing for a four-justice plurality, she described other examples of ambiguous regulations and explained the history of the doctrine of Auer deference. She explained that Auer deference is “rooted in a presumption that Congress would generally want the agency to play the primary role in resolving regulatory ambiguities” because agencies are best equipped to interpret the often-technical regulations at issue.
Writing again for the majority, Kagan continued to outline the requirements that must be met for Auer deference to apply: First, a court should not afford an agency Auer deference unless the regulation is genuinely ambiguous, a determination the court can make only after it has exhausted all the traditional tools of construction. Second, the agency’s reading must be reasonable, under the text, structure, and history of the regulation. Notwithstanding some courts’ interpretation to the contrary, the language “plainly erroneous” from Seminole Rock does not mean that agency constructions of rules are entitled to greater deference than agency constructions of statutes. Third, the regulatory interpretation must be one actually made by the agency; that is, it must be the agency’s authoritative or official position, not merely an ad hoc statement. Fourth, the interpretation must in some way implicate the agency’s substantive expertise, and fifth, it must reflect “fair and considered judgment.”
On behalf of the plurality, Kagan went on to address Kisor’s arguments. She explained that Auer is not inconsistent with the judicial review provision of the APA, nor does it circumvent the APA’s rulemaking requirements. Contrary to Kisor’s arguments, Kagan cited empirical evidence to support her position that Auer does not encourage agencies to issue vague and open-ended interpretations of those rules they prefer. Finally, she quickly dispensed of Kisor’s argument that it violates separation-of-powers principles.
On behalf of the majority, Kagan wrote that the doctrine of stare decisis cuts strongly against Kisor’s position. There is no “special justification” to reverse Auer, and even if the Court were wrong about its presumption of what Congress would want, Congress can correct it.
Applying the principles outlined in the opinion, a redo is necessary for two reasons: The Federal Circuit “jumped the gun” in declaring the regulation ambiguous, and it also “assumed too fast” that Auer deference should apply in the event of genuine ambiguity.
Chief Justice Roberts wrote a separate concurrence in part to reiterate Justice Kagan’s assertion that overturning Auer and Seminole Rock was not warranted. He also noted that the cases in which Auer deference is appropriate largely overlap with cases in which it would be unreasonable for a court to be persuaded by an agency's interpretation of its own regulation. He pointed out that the gulf between the majority’s position and Justice Gorsuch’s dissent is not so great as it may initially appear.
Justice Neil Gorsuch penned a separate opinion, in which Justices Clarence Thomas and Brett Kavanaugh joined and Justice Samuel Alito joined in part, concurring in the judgment but highly critical of Justice Kagan’s opinion. On behalf of himself and three other justices, Justice Gorsuch wrote a history of Auer deference, describing the decision and resulting doctrine “an accident.” He went on to explain that Auer is inconsistent with the Administrative Procedure Act and the separation of powers principle. On behalf of himself and Justices Thomas and Kavanaugh, Justice Gorsuch responded to Justice Kagan’s public policy considerations and argued that while the majority gave lip service to stare decisis, it effectively changed the test set forth in precedents—which effectively overrules it in all but name.
Justice Kavanaugh wrote a separate opinion concurring in the judgment, in which Justice Alito joined. In his opinion, Justice Kavanaugh emphasizes two points: first, he reiterates the Chief Justice’s point that “the distance between” the two main opinions in this case “is not as great as it may initially appear,” and second, he expresses agreement with the Chief Justice that the decision in this case addresses only judicial deference to agency interpretations of their own regulations, and not at all judicial deference to agency interpretations of statutes.
FCC Enforcement Bureau Reform
The Supreme Court’s decision in SEC v. Jarkesy will have significant impacts on agency authority in the...
Daniel Webster Debate Series: Should the Court Restore Chevron?
The Federalist Society's Georgetown Law Chapter's Daniel Webster Debate Series
The Federalist Society's Georgetown Law Chapter'sDaniel Webster Debate Series presents Daniel Webster Debate Series:Should the...
New Voices in Administrative Law II: The Supreme Court and Federal Court Jurisdiction
The development of standing jurisprudence has been inextricably intertwined with the growth of the administrative...
2024 Annual Supreme Court Round Up
On Thursday, July 25, the Washington, D.C. Lawyers Chapter gathered for the annual Supreme...
What’s Happening with Apprenticeship? – Recent Regulatory and Subregulatory Actions
Apprenticeship has been a significant focus of the Biden administration, and previously the Trump administration,...
Fireside Chat: “Why Separate Powers?” A Conceptual Introduction
2024 National Student Symposium
Professor Cass Sunstein and Judge Raymond Kethledge will open the symposium with a fireside chat...
Corner Post and 28 U.S.C. § 2401(a): Not Much to Look At?
Federalist Society Review, Volume 25
This term the U.S. Supreme Court will decide Corner Post, Inc. v. Board of Governors...
How Much Should Courts Defer to U.S. Sentencing Guidelines Commentary?
The federal circuit courts are irreconcilably split on a weighty question: How much deference should...
Chevron Is Dead, Long Live Chevron
The Supreme Court has agreed to revisit Chevron v. Natural Resources Defense Council (1984), the...
And the Walls Came Tumbling Down: The Liberation of Civil Society
As anyone who has seen a building collapse or a bridge buckle can attest, it...
Revitalizing the Nondelegation Doctrine
Federalist Society Review, Volume 23
A Review of The Administrative State Before the Supreme Court: Perspectives on the Nondelegation Doctrine (Peter...
Chevron and the States: A Conversation with Governors' General Counsel about Judicial Deference to State Administrative Agency Interpretations of State Laws
Deference doctrines utilized by the federal Judiciary when federal agencies act is the subject of...
Switchbacks at the DOJ: the Sessions, Brand, and Garland Memos
During President Biden’s first year in office, Attorney General Merrick Garland rescinded two key memos...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument Litigation Update: American Hospital Association v. Becerra
On Tuesday, November 30, 2021, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in American Hospital Association...
Administrative Inquisitions? How Agencies Initiate, Conduct, and Conclude Investigations
2021 National Lawyers Convention
The 2021 National Lawyers Convention took place November 11-13, 2021 at the Mayflower Hotel in...
In the Shadow of Skidmore and Seminole Rock?: Chevron and Auer Deference and Their Conceits
When an agency interprets a statute it administers, a court will defer to the agency’s...
A Change in Direction for the Federal Trade Commission?
Federalist Society Review, Volume 22
While antitrust and regulation are supposed to be two sides of the same coin,[1] there...
Certiorari and Stinson Deference
Administrative Law & Regulation Practice Group Teleforum
On June 16, 2021, The Federalist Society's Administrative Law & Regulation Practice Group hosted a...
Certiorari and Stinson Deference
Administrative Law & Regulation Practice Group Teleforum
On June 16, 2021, The Federalist Society's Administrative Law & Regulation Practice Group hosted a...
Certiorari and Stinson Deference
Administrative Law & Regulation Practice Group Teleforum
On June 16, 2021, The Federalist Society's Administrative Law & Regulation Practice Group hosted a...
Talks with Authors: Administrative Law Theory and Fundamentals: An Integrated Approach
Few fields are more in need of fresh thinking than administrative law. The author of Administrative Law...
Negative Legislation
Federalist Society Review, Volume 22
Modern commentators have spilled much ink on the undemocratic nature of congressional delegations to executive...
Kisor on Remand: Raising the Bar to “Genuinely Ambiguous” at Auer Step Zero
A recent decision from the Federal Circuit may provide a roadmap for the future of...
Timeless Concepts for a Trying Time: The Separation of Powers and Judicial Review
If men were angels, no government would be necessary. If angels were to govern men,...
Kisor and Gundy: The Future of Administrative Law?
Chicago Student Chapter
On February 15, 2021, Erin M. Hawley and Jennifer Nou joined the Federalist Society’s Chicago...
Bureaucracy With Bumper Guards: Better Than It Rules?
Federalist Society Review, Volume 22
A review of Law & Leviathan: Redeeming the Administrative State, by Cass Sunstein & Adrian...
Administrative Law & Regulation: Regulatory Practice and Oversight in 2021 and Beyond
2020 National Lawyers Convention
On November 9, 2020, The Federalist Society's Administration Law & Regulation Practice Group hosted a...
Administrative Law & Regulation: Regulatory Practice and Oversight in 2021 and Beyond
2020 National Lawyers Convention
On November 9, 2020, The Federalist Society's Administration Law & Regulation Practice Group hosted a...
We’re All Textualists Now? Implementing a Sound Interpretive Approach on the Trial Court and Beyond
Jacksonville Lawyers Chapter - Online Event
The Federalist Society's Jacksonville Lawyers Chapter held a virtual panel on August 12, 2020 to...
The End of Deference: How States Are Leading a (Sometimes Quiet) Revolution Against Administrative Deference Doctrines
Federalism and Separation of Powers Teleforum
In the last few years there has been a lot of critical attention directed towards Chevron and Seminole...
The End of Deference: How States Are Leading a (Sometimes Quiet) Revolution Against Administrative Deference Doctrines
Federalism and Separation of Powers Teleforum
In the last few years there has been a lot of critical attention directed towards Chevron and Seminole...
Courthouse Steps Decision Teleforum: Thryv, Inc. v. Click-To-Call Technologies, LP
In Thryv, Inc. v. Click-To-Call Technologies, LP (Supreme Court, April 20, 2020), the Supreme Court held that...
Executive Orders on Guidance: Implications and Next Steps
Executive Branch Review Week Teleforum
In October of 2019, President Trump issued an executive order that imposed a series of...
An Imagined Bloc and Other Figments
Federalist Society Review, Volume 21
A review of American Justice 2019: The Roberts Court Arrives, by Mark Joseph Stern (University...
Is Our Modern Administrative State Unmoored from the Morality of Law?
Federalist Society Review, Volume 21
A review of The Dubious Morality of Modern Administrative Law, by Richard A. Epstein (Manhattan Institute...
The New Definition of “WOTUS”: Analysis of the Trump Administration’s “Navigable Waters Protection Rule”
The Trump Administration recently released its final rule defining “waters of the United States” under...
Panel: Originalism and Stare Decisis
22nd Annual Federalist Society Faculty Conference
On January 3-4, 2020, the Federalist Society hosted its 22nd annual Faculty Conference at the...
Is Another Brand of Judicial Deference on the Chopping Block?
This teleforum will focus on the sundry problems with so-called "Brand X deference," whose name...
Is Another Brand of Judicial Deference on the Chopping Block?
This teleforum will focus on the sundry problems with so-called "Brand X deference," whose name...
Federalist Society Review, Volume 20
Federalist Society Review, Volume 20
The Federalist Society Review is the legal journal produced by the Federalist Society for Law...
Kisor v. Wilkie Makes Auer a Paper Tiger
Federalist Society Review, Volume 20
Note from the Editor: The Federalist Society takes no positions on particular legal and public...
Panel One: The Future of Administrative Law After Kisor
Third Circuit Chapters Conference
On October 24, 2019, The Federalist Society held its annual Third Circuit Chapters Conference. This...
Panel One: The Future of Administrative Law After Kisor
Third Circuit Chapters Conference
On October 24, 2019, The Federalist Society held its annual Third Circuit Chapters Conference. This...
Panel One: The Future of Administrative Law After Kisor
Third Circuit Chapters Conference
On October 24, 2019, The Federalist Society held its annual Third Circuit Chapters Conference. This...
The Future of Administrative Records after Department of Commerce v. New York
Until recently, the domain of administrative records under the Administrative Procedure Act of 1946 was...
Deep Dive Episode 74 – A Discussion on Current Department of Labor Priorities
Regulatory Transparency Project's Fourth Branch Podcast
The Department of Labor administers and enforces more than 180 federal laws, with mandates and...
Litigation Update: Gundy v. U.S.
Last term in Gundy v. U.S., without Justice Kavanaugh the Court was split between a...
Agency Staff Regulatory Guidance
Financial Services Practice Group Teleforum
Agency staff regulatory guidance, speeches, and settled enforcement actions can be helpful to the regulated...
Agency Staff Regulatory Guidance
Financial Services Practice Group Teleforum
Agency staff regulatory guidance, speeches, and settled enforcement actions can be helpful to the regulated...
Whistling in Chevronland: Why Department of Labor Interpretations of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act Whistleblower Provisions Do Not Deserve Judicial Deference
Federalist Society Review, Volume 20
Note from the Editor: The Federalist Society takes no positions on particular legal and public...
Deference and Independent Agencies
During the last week of its just-ended term, the Supreme Court handed down its much...
Deep Dive Episode 65 – Subdelegations of Rulemaking Power and the Appointments Clause
Regulatory Transparency Project and Administrative Law & Regulation Practice Group Teleforum
The strictures of the Appointments Clause are receiving renewed attention in the courts, including the...
Courthouse Steps Decision: The Census Citizenship Question, Department of Commerce v. New York
On June 27, the Supreme Court decided Department of Commerce v. New York, the legal challenge...
Deep Dive Episode 62 – An Update on Kisor v. Wilkie
Regulatory Transparency Project's Fourth Branch Podcast
Last week the Supreme Court decided the much-anticipated Kisor v. Wilkie case. The Court had...
Judicial Deference Determined: Kisor v. Wilkie
This morning the Supreme Court decided the much-anticipated Kisor v. Wilkie case. The Court had granted...
Judicial Deference Determined: Kisor v. Wilkie
This morning the Supreme Court decided the much-anticipated Kisor v. Wilkie case. The Court had granted...
One Year Later: Impact of Encino Motorcars on FLSA Litigation
Just over a year ago, in a case involving an obscure car dealership exemption from...
Gundy v. United States: Revisiting the Nondelegation Doctrine, or Not?
The U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Gundy v. United States disappointed some observers who were hoping...
Revisiting Judicial Deference
Seventh Annual Executive Branch Review Conference
The seventh annual Executive Branch Review Conference took place on May 8, 2019, at the...
Deep Dive Episode 40 – Kisor v. Wilkie
On Wednesday, March 27th, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Kisor v. Wilkie. The...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: Kisor v. Wilkie
On the morning of March 27, the Supreme Court will hear oral argument in Kisor...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: Kisor v. Wilkie
On the morning of March 27, the Supreme Court will hear oral argument in Kisor...
Courthouse Steps Decision Teleforum: Sturgeon v. Frost
In today's decision on Sturgeon v. Frost, the Supreme Court has held in favor of...
Kisor v. Wilkie [SCOTUSbrief]
Short video featuring Adam White
In 2006, Vietnam veteran James Kisor appealed the denial of his disability benefits by the...
Is There a Constitutional Issue in the USMCA?
Some argue that the United States Mexico Canada Agreement (USMCA) presents interesting questions about how...
A Most Unusual Brief From the Solicitor General: Threading the Needle on Auer Deference
Justice Department’s Response Brief in Kisor v. Wilkie Endeavors to Balance Competing Considerations – Criticizing a Major Modern Administrative-Law Doctrine, But Also Seeking to Prevent Its Overruling
Last week, the Solicitor General filed the United States’ eagerly anticipated response brief in Kisor...
Lunch Address by Don McGahn
2019 Annual Western Chapters Conference
On January 26, 2019, the Federalist Society hosted the annual Western Chapters Conference at the...
Reconsidering the Legal Status of Agency Guidance
In Holiday-Season Amendments to the Justice Department Manual, DOJ Continues the Trend of Downgrading the Status of Subregulatory Agency Guidance Documents
Late last year, the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) took a quiet but significant step...
Can and Should the Federal Judiciary Rein In Our Expansive Administrative State?
Federalist Society Review, Volume 20
Note from the Editor: The Federalist Society takes no positions on particular legal and public...
Certiorari and Stinson Deference
Administrative Law & Regulation Practice Group Teleforum
TeleforumCertiorari and Stinson Deference
Administrative Law & Regulation Practice Group Teleforum
TeleforumKisor and Gundy: The Future of Administrative Law?
Chicago Student Chapter
Zoom Webinar -- University of Chicago1111 East 60th Street
Chicago, IL 60615