Facts of the Case
In April 2011, police arrested four men in connection with a series of armed robberies. One of the men confessed to the crimes and gave the FBI his cell phone number and the numbers of the other participants. The FBI used this information to apply for three orders from magistrate judges to obtain "transactional records" for each of the phone numbers, which the judges granted under the Stored Communications Act, 18 U.S.C. 2703(d). That Act provides that the government may require the disclosure of certain telecommunications records when "specific and articulable facts show[] that there are reasonable grounds to believe that the contents of a wire or electronic communication, or the records or other information sought, are relevant and material to an ongoing criminal investigation." The transactional records obtained by the government include the date and time of calls, and the approximate location where calls began and ended based on their connections to cell towers—"cell site" location information (CSLI).
Based on the cell-site evidence, the government charged Timothy Carpenter with, among other offenses, aiding and abetting robbery that affected interstate commerce, in violation of the Hobbs Act, 18 U.S.C. 1951. Carpenter moved to suppress the government's cell-site evidence on Fourth Amendment grounds, arguing that the FBI needed a warrant based on probable cause to obtain the records. The district court denied the motion to suppress, and the Sixth Circuit affirmed.
Questions
Does the warrantless search and seizure of cell phone records, which include the location and movements of cell phone users, violate the Fourth Amendment?
Conclusions
-
The government's warrantless acquisition of Carpenter's cell-site records violated his Fourth Amendment right against unreasonable searches and seizures. Chief Justice John Roberts authored the opinion for the 5-4 majority. The majority first acknowledged that the Fourth Amendment protects not only property interests, but also reasonable expectations of privacy. Expectations of privacy in this age of digital data do not fit neatly into existing precedents, but tracking person's movements and location through extensive cell-site records is far more intrusive than the precedents might have anticipated. The Court declined to extend the "third-party doctrine"—a doctrine where information disclosed to a third party carries no reasonable expectation of privacy—to cell-site location information, which implicates even greater privacy concerns than GPS tracking does. One consideration in the development of the third-party doctrine was the "nature of the particular documents sought," and the level of intrusiveness of extensive cell-site data weighs against application of the doctrine to this type of information. Additionally, the third-party doctrine applies to voluntary exposure, and while a user might be abstractly aware that his cell phone provider keeps logs, it happens without any affirmative act on the user's part. Thus, the Court held narrowly that the government generally will need a warrant to access cell-site location information.
Justice Anthony Kennedy filed a dissenting opinion, in which Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito joined. Justice Kennedy would find that cell-site records are no different from the many other kinds of business records the government has a lawful right to obtain by compulsory process. Justice Kennedy would continue to limit the Fourth Amendment to its property-based origins.
Justice Thomas filed a dissenting opinion, emphasizing the property-based approach to Fourth Amendment questions. In Justice Thomas's view, the case should not turn on whether a search occurred, but whose property was searched. By focusing on this latter question, Justice Thomas reasoned, the only logical conclusion would be that the information did not belong to Carpenter.
Justice Alito filed a dissenting opinion, in which Justice Thomas joined. Justice Alito distinguishes between an actual search and an order "merely requiring a party to look through its own records and produce specified documents"—with the former being far more intrusive than the latter. Justice Alito criticizes the majority for what he characterizes as "allow[ing] a defendant to object to the search of a third party's property," a departure from long-standing Fourth Amendment doctrine.
Justice Gorsuch filed a dissenting opinion in which he emphasizes the "original understanding" of the Fourth Amendment and laments the Court's departure from it.
Remedies in Presidential Removal Cases: A Shifting Landscape
The Supreme Court's decision in Collins v. Yellen represented a paradigm shift. Now, in cases...
Victim Rights in Arizona's Constitution Clash With Sixth Amendment at Arizona Supreme Court
In 1990, Arizona was the first state in the nation to adopt a Victim’s Bill...
After Dobbs and Samia: The Potential Implications of Applying a Dobbs Lens to the Supreme Court’s Constitutional Criminal Jurisprudence
2023 National Lawyers Convention
Stare Decisis, a Latin term meaning “let it stand,” is a key element of how...
Iowa Supreme Court Upholds the Warrantless DNA Analysis of a Drinking Straw Collected from a Fast-Food Restaurant
In State v. Burns, the Iowa Supreme Court considered whether police violated the U.S. or...
The Rule of Completeness After Hemphill
In Hemphill v. New York, the Supreme Court ruled that the Confrontation Clause bars the...
The Rule of Completeness After Hemphill
In Hemphill v. New York, the Supreme Court ruled that the Confrontation Clause bars the...
Deep Dive Episode 198 – Eyes to The Sky: Privacy, Property, Innovation, and Commerce in The Age Of The Drone
Regulatory Transparency Project's Fourth Branch Podcast
Drones are rapidly becoming part of our everyday lives, and society will soon need to...
GEDMatch and the Fourth Amendment: No Warrant Required
He murdered 13 people, raped at least 50 women, and committed burglaries all across California...
GEDMatch and the Fourth Amendment: No Warrant Required
He murdered 13 people, raped at least 50 women, and committed burglaries all across California...
Rights and Wrongs: The Golden State Killer and Genetic Investigations
After 87 victims, 53 separate crime scenes, and multiple investigations spanning over four decades, the...
Deep Dive Episode 117 – How to Approach Data Collection and Breaches in the Age of COVID-19
Regulatory Transparency Project Teleforum
In an effort to combat the spread of COVID-19 and contain its impact, nations across...
Litigation Update: Associational Privacy at the Supreme Court
In NAACP v. Alabama ex rel. Patterson, the Supreme Court recognized a First Amendment right to privacy of...
Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) Renewal: Is Reform Needed?
Congress faces a March 15 deadline to renew the statutory authority for several key provisions...
Federalist Society Review, Volume 20
Federalist Society Review, Volume 20
The Federalist Society Review is the legal journal produced by the Federalist Society for Law...
Welcome to the New “Explainer Podcast”
Fourth Branch Series
American governments are facing several growing problems – such as how to address climate change...
Welcome to the New “Explainer Podcast”
Fourth Branch Series
American governments are facing several growing problems – such as how to address climate change...
Explainer Episode 7 – Carpenter v. United States
Regulatory Transparency Project's Fourth Branch Podcast
In this episode, Ashley Baker and Jennifer Huddleston discuss the implications of the famous privacy...
Civility, Courage, Humility: Lessons in Life and Law From a Justice
Federalist Society Review, Volume 20
A review of A Republic, If You Can Keep It, by Neil Gorsuch, https://www.amazon.com/Republic-If-You-Can-Keep/dp/0525576789/. ...
Civility, Courage, Humility: Lessons in Life and Law From a Justice
Federalist Society Review, Volume 20
A review of A Republic, If You Can Keep It, by Neil Gorsuch, https://www.amazon.com/Republic-If-You-Can-Keep/dp/0525576789/. ...
Carpenter v. United States: A Reevaluation of First Principles, One Year On
Federalist Society Review, Volume 20
Note from the Editor: The Federalist Society takes no positions on particular legal and public...
Carpenter v. United States: A Reevaluation of First Principles, One Year On
Federalist Society Review, Volume 20
Note from the Editor: The Federalist Society takes no positions on particular legal and public...
American Justice 2018: Book Review
“The Shifting Supreme Court” is the latest from the University of Pennsylvania’s “American Justice” series,...
Justice Gorsuch, Carpenter, & the Fourth Amendment [POLICYbrief]
Short video featuring Ashley Baker
Though Justice Neil Gorsuch filed one of the four dissenting opinions in Carpenter v. United...
Justice Gorsuch, Carpenter, & the Fourth Amendment [POLICYbrief]
Short video featuring Ashley Baker
Though Justice Neil Gorsuch filed one of the four dissenting opinions in Carpenter v. United...
Going Dark Phenomenon
Criminal Law & Procedure Practice Group and Regulatory Transparency Project Teleforum
What is the effect of encryption on government/law enforcement access to digital evidence? Default device...
Courthouse Steps Decision: Carpenter v. United States
Criminal Law & Procedure Practice Group Teleforum
In Carpenter, arrests made in an armed robbery case occurred because the Federal Bureau of...
Courthouse Steps: Carpenter v. United States
Criminal Law & Procedure and Telecommunications & Electronic Media Practice Groups Teleforum
Arrests made in an armed robbery case occurred because the Federal Bureau of Investigation was...
Carpenter v. United States [SCOTUSbrief]
Short video featuring Ilya Shapiro
Does the Fourth Amendment allow for a warrantless search and seizure of cellphone location data...
Supreme Court October 2017 Term Preview
Practice Groups Podcast
On Friday, October 6, The Federalist Society hosted a special 90-minute Teleforum to preview the significant...
Supreme Court October 2017 Term Preview
Practice Groups Podcast
On Friday, October 6, The Federalist Society hosted a special 90-minute Teleforum to preview the significant...
The Third Party Doctrine and Carpenter v. United States - Podcast
Criminal Law & Procedure Practice Group Podcast
According to the Fourth Amendment, “The right of the people to be secure in their...
Benefit-Cost Analysis and the Courts - Podcast
Administrative Law & Regulation Practice Group Podcast
This call highlighted recent trends in how the courts have considered benefit-cost analysis when reviewing...
Focusing on Carpenter v. United States
Rutgers-Camden Student Chapter
Rutgers School of Law - Camden217 N 5th St
Camden, NJ 08102