Facts of the Case
White and Hispanic candidates for promotion in the New Haven, CT fire department sued various city officials in the United States District Court for the District of Connecticut when the New Haven Civil Service Board (CSB) failed to certify two exams needed for the plaintiffs' promotion to Lieutenant and Captain. The CSB did not certify because the results of the test would have promoted a disproportionate number of white candidates in comparison to minority candidates. The plaintiffs argued that their rights under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, 42 U.S.C. Section 2000e, and the 14th Amendment Equal Protection Clause were violated. The federal district court granted the defendants' motion for summary judgment.
On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit affirmed. It reasoned that the CSB, by refusing to certify the results of the promotional exam, was trying to fulfill its obligations under the rules utilized by the plaintiffs in their argument and therefore was protected in its actions.
Questions
Can a municipality reject results from an otherwise valid civil service exam when the results unintentionally prevent the promotion of minority candidates?
Does 42 U.S.C. Section 2000e permit federal courts to relieve municipalities from having to comply with local laws that require strict compliance with race-blind merit selection procedures?
Conclusions
-
Maybe; fact dependent. Not answered. The Supreme Court held that by discarding the exams, the City of New Haven violated Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Justice Anthony M. Kennedy wrote the majority joined by Chief Justice John G. Roberts, and Justices Antonin G. Scalia, Clarence Thomas, and Samuel A. Alito. Before an employer can engage in intentional discrimination for the purpose of avoiding a "disparate impact" on a protected trait (race, color, religion, national origin), the employer must have a "strong basis in evidence" that it will be subject to "disparate impact liability" if it fails to take the discriminatory action. Here, the Court reasoned that New Haven failed to prove it had a "strong basis in evidence" that failing to discard the results of the exam would have subjected it to liability, as the exams were job-related, consistent with business necessity, and there was no evidence that an equally-valid, less-discriminatory alternative was available.
Justice Scalia wrote separately, concurring. He noted that the Court avoided answering whether the "disparate impact" provision of Title VII was consistent with the Equal Protection Clause. Justice Alito also wrote a concurring opinion and was joined by Justices Scalia and Thomas. He criticized the dissent for omitting key information in reaching its alternate conclusion.
Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg dissented and was joined by Justices John Paul Stevens, David H. Souter, and Stephen G. Breyer. She argued that the City of New Haven had good cause to believe it would be vulnerable to a Title VII lawsuit if it certified the exams. Moreover, she criticized the majority for ignoring "substantial flaws" in the exam.
Civil Rights: Developments in Disparate Impact Law & Policy
2024 National Lawyers Convention
The “disparate impact” approach to civil rights enforcement makes it presumptively illegal to use selection...
College Admissions After SFFA
On Thursday, June 29, 2023, the U.S. Supreme Court issued its decision in Students for...
Litigation Update: Louisiana v. EPA
Efforts to achieve “environmental justice” have been a top priority of the Biden Administration and...
Fourth Annual Gregory S. Coleman Memorial Lecture & Luncheon
Seventh Annual Texas Chapters Conference
On September 17-18, 2021, The Federalist Society's Texas chapters sponsored the seventh annual Texas Chapters...
Unleashed and Unbound: Living Textualism in Bostock v. Clayton County
Federalist Society Review, Volume 21
Note from the Editor: The Federalist Society takes no positions on particular legal and public...
Stare Decisis in Civil Rights Cases
2019 National Lawyers Convention
On November 15, 2019, the Federalist Society's Civil Rights Practice Group hosted a panel for...
Can You Recruit on Campus? - Podcast
Labor & Employment Law Practice Group Podcast
Are college job fairs and recruiting doomed as discriminatory activities? In February, a District Court...
The Kudzu of Civil Rights Law: Disparate Impact Spreads Into Educational “Resource Comparability”
Engage Volume 16, Issue 2
Note from the Editor: This article is about a Dear Colleague letter from the Department...
Supreme Court Upholds Disparate Impact: Texas Department of Housing and Community Affairs v. The Inclusive Communities Project, Inc. - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
On June 25, the Supreme Court issued a 5-4 decision that the Wall Street Journal has...
Texas Department of Housing and Community Affairs v. The Inclusive Communities Project - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
Post-Argument SCOTUScast featuring Todd Gaziano
On January 21, 2015, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Texas Department of Housing...
Disparate Impact Liability and the Fair Housing Act: Texas Department of Housing and Community Affairs v. The Inclusive Communities Project, Inc. - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
On Wednesday, January 21, 2015, the Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Texas Department of...
School Discipline and the Expansion of Disparate Impact - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
On January 8, 2014, the Department of Justice Civil Rights Division and the Department of...
Mt. Holly Settlement - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
The Supreme Court was less than one month away from hearing arguments in Mount Holly...
School Discipline and Disparate Impact
Engage Volume 13, Issue 1, March 2012
Note from the Editor: This paper analyzes the U.S. Department of Education’s proposed use of...
Lewis v. City of Chicago - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 06-17-2010 featuring Elizabeth K. Dorminey
On May 24, 2010, the Supreme Court announced its decision in Lewis v. City of...
Judicial Activism
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group
With the nomination of Elena Kagan to the U.S. Supreme Court, there is a great...
Two Civil Rights Decisions Close Out Supreme Court's 2008 Term
The Supreme Court’s 2008 Term concluded with opinions in two closely followed civil rights cases,...
Rothe Development Corp. v. Department of Defense
Civil Rights Practice Group
On Election Day, November 4, 2008, a panel of the Federal Circuit Court of Appeals...
SCOTUScast 7-13-09 featuring Michael Rosman
Ricci v. DeStefano
On Monday, June 29, the Supreme Court announced its decision in Ricci v. DeStefano. In...
2009 Annual Supreme Court Round Up
Washington, DC Lawyers Chapter
On July 10, 2009, former United States Solicitor General Theodore B. Olson delivered the Annual...
The Sotomayor Nomination, Part I
Online Debate
On May 26, President Obama nominated Sonia Sotomayor to replace David Souter as an Associate...
SCOTUScast 5-28-09 featuring Michael Rosman
Ricci v. DeStefano
On Wednesday, April 22, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Ricci v. DeStefano. The...
Civil Rights in the Age of Obama
Civil Rights Practice Group and The Heritage Foundation
Some of President Obama’s admirers and detractors have suggested that his election as President and...
The Obama Administration, the New Haven Firefighters Case, and More
New Federal Initiatives Project
Brought to you by the Civil Rights Practice Group The Obama administration filed an amicus brief...