Facts of the Case
Thomas Van Orden sued Texas in federal district court, arguing a Ten Commandments monument on the grounds of the state capitol building represented an unconstitutional government endorsement of religion. Orden argued this violated the First Amendment's establishment clause, which prohibits the government from passing laws "respecting an establishment of religion." The district court and the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled against Orden and said the monument served a valid secular purpose and would not appear to a reasonable observer to represent a government endorsement of religion.
Questions
Does a Ten Commandments monument on the grounds of a state capitol building violate the First Amendment's establishment clause, which barred the government from passing laws "respecting an establishment of religion?"
Conclusions
-
No. In 5-4 decision, and in a four-justice opinion delivered by Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist, the Court held that the establishment clause did not bar the monument on the grounds of Texas' state capitol building. The plurality deemed the Texas monument part of the nation's tradition of recognizing the Ten Commandments' historical meaning. Though the Commandments are religious, the plurality argued, "simply having religious content or promoting a message consistent with a religious doctrine does not run afoul of the establishment clause."
Louisiana's Ten Commandments Statute and the Establishment Clause
On June 19, 2024, the governor of Louisiana signed into law House Bill No. 71....
Louisiana's Ten Commandments Statute and the Establishment Clause
On June 19, 2024, the governor of Louisiana signed into law House Bill No. 71....
Talks with Authors: An Introduction to Constitutional Law: 100+ Supreme Court Cases Everyone Should Know
Professors Randy Barnett and Josh Blackman will discuss the most important Supreme Court cases of...
The Status of Use-Based Exclusions & Educational Choice After Espinoza
Federalist Society Review, Volume 21
Note from the Editor: The Federalist Society takes no positions on particular legal and public...
After Espinoza, What’s Left of the Establishment Clause?
Federalist Society Review, Volume 21
Note from the Editor: The Federalist Society takes no positions on particular legal and public...
After Espinoza, What’s Left of the Establishment Clause?
Federalist Society Review, Volume 21
Note from the Editor: The Federalist Society takes no positions on particular legal and public...
Exploring American Legion: What Shelving Lemon Could Mean for Monuments Litigation
In 2015, the Arkansas legislature authorized placement of a privately-donated Ten Commandments monument on the...
Exploring American Legion: What Shelving Lemon Could Mean for Monuments Litigation
In 2015, the Arkansas legislature authorized placement of a privately-donated Ten Commandments monument on the...
The American Legion v. American Humanist Association - Post-Decision Podcast
SCOTUScast featuring Christopher DiPompeo
On June 20, 2019, the Supreme Court decided The American Legion v. American Humanist Association,...
Courthouse Steps Decision Teleforum: The American Legion v. American Humanist Association
For decades, the law surrounding the constitutionality of monuments and memorials has been in disarray,...
Can a New Establishment Clause Jurisprudence Succeed in Protecting Religious Minorities Where Lemon Has Failed?
Federalist Society Review, Volume 20
Note from the Editor: The Federalist Society takes no positions on particular legal and public...
Can a New Establishment Clause Jurisprudence Succeed in Protecting Religious Minorities Where Lemon Has Failed?
Federalist Society Review, Volume 20
Note from the Editor: The Federalist Society takes no positions on particular legal and public...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: The World War I Cross Cases
What is the nature of government involvement in religious matters, and what is the future...
Interesting Establishment Clause Case in the Eleventh Circuit - Kondrat'Yev v. City of Pensacola
In May, the Eleventh Circuit will hear argument in Kondrat'Yev v. City of Pensacola (No....
Interesting Establishment Clause Case in the Eleventh Circuit - Kondrat'Yev v. City of Pensacola
In May, the Eleventh Circuit will hear argument in Kondrat'Yev v. City of Pensacola (No....
When a Pastor’s House Is a Church Home: Why the Parsonage Allowance Is Desirable Under the Establishment Clause
Federalist Society Review, Volume 18
Note from the Editor: This article discusses the parsonage allowance, whereby the value of a...
When a Pastor’s House Is a Church Home: Why the Parsonage Allowance Is Desirable Under the Establishment Clause
Federalist Society Review, Volume 18
Note from the Editor: This article discusses the parsonage allowance, whereby the value of a...
Keynote Address by Senator Ted Cruz
Second Annual Texas Chapters Conference
Senator Ted Cruz (R-TX) gave the keynote address at our Second Annual Texas Chapters Conference....
Religious Liberty after Scalia
Some people opine that Antonin Scalia was not a friend of religious liberty, and that...
Religious Liberty after Scalia
Some people opine that Antonin Scalia was not a friend of religious liberty, and that...
In Whose Name We Pray: Restoring the Establishment Clause in Town of Greece v. Galloway
Engage Volume 14, Issue 3 October 2013
Note from the Editor: This article is a discussion about the Establishment Clause issue in...
In Whose Name We Pray: Restoring the Establishment Clause in Town of Greece v. Galloway
Engage Volume 14, Issue 3 October 2013
Note from the Editor: This article is a discussion about the Establishment Clause issue in...
Salazar v. Buono and the Establishment Clause
Religious Liberties Practice Group
In 1934, with the permission of the U.S. government, the Veterans of Foreign Wars erected...
SCOTUScast 7-20-09 featuring Lee Strang
Pleasant Grove City v. Summum
On Wednesday, February 25, the Supreme Court announced its decision in Pleasant Grove City v....
A Look Back at the October Supreme Court 2007 Term
Is the DC gun ban constitutional? Do Guantanamo Bay prisoners have a constitutional right to...
Richard W. Garnett Reviews Divided By God: America’s Church-State Problem—And What We Should Do About It by Noah Feldman
The Supreme Court this past summer handed down rulings in three closely watched, eagerly anticipated,...
Richard W. Garnett Reviews Divided By God: America’s Church-State Problem—And What We Should Do About It by Noah Feldman
The Supreme Court this past summer handed down rulings in three closely watched, eagerly anticipated,...
It’s Not Just the Test That’s a Lemon, It’s How Some Judges Apply It
On March 2, 2005, the United States Supreme Court heard two cases involving public displays...
It’s Not Just the Test That’s a Lemon, It’s How Some Judges Apply It
On March 2, 2005, the United States Supreme Court heard two cases involving public displays...
It's Not Just the Test That's a Lemon, It's How Some Judges Apply It
On March 2, 2005, the United States Supreme Court heard two cases involving public displays...