Facts of the Case
An 1876 law provided that postmasters of the first, second, and third classes shall be appointed and may be removed by the President with the advice and consent of the Senate. President Woodrow Wilson removed Myers, a postmaster first class, without seeking Senate approval.
Questions
Did the Act unconstitutionally restrict the President's power to remove appointed officials?
Conclusions
-
Yes. After tracing legislative debate of the First Congress in 1789 which dealt with the interpretation of the President's appointment power, Chief Justice Taft concluded that the power to remove appointed officers is vested in the President alone. According to Taft, to deny the President that power would not allow him to "discharge his own constitutional duty of seeing that the laws be faithfully executed."
The End of Independent Agencies? Restoring Presidential Control of the Executive Branch
Federalist Society Review, Volume 22
On the day that President Joe Biden took office, among his first official acts was...
The Accidental Defender of the Constitution
Federalist Society Review, Volume 21
A Review of Defender in Chief: Donald Trump’s Fight for Presidential Power, by John Yoo,...
Life After Seila Law: The Emerging Presidential Removal Power Docket at the Supreme Court
The Federalist Society is pleased to announce its Student Blog Initiative, a project of the...
The Take Care Act
Yesterday, Senator Lee introduced a nine-page bill that would, following the next presidential election, eliminate...
Independent Agencies: How Independent is Too Independent?
2018 National Lawyers Convention
Justice Scalia put it bluntly in Morrison v. Olson: “There are now no lines.” Morrison,...
Independent Agencies: How Independent is Too Independent?
2018 National Lawyers Convention
Justice Scalia put it bluntly in Morrison v. Olson: “There are now no lines.” Morrison,...
Introducing “Article V 2.0”: The Compact for a Balanced Budget
Engage Volume 15, Issue 2
This article discusses the use of interstate compacts to advance Article V amendments to the U.S....
The States and the NLRB: A Study in Comparative Sovereignty
Engage Volume 12, Issue 3, November 2011
Under a system of government that diffuses power and makes institutional “[a]mbition . . ....
Independent Agencies: How Independent is Too Independent?
2018 National Lawyers Convention
The Mayflower Hotel - East Room1127 Connecticut Avenue, NW
Washington, DC 20036
