Facts of the Case
In 1996 California voters passed the Compassionate Use Act, legalizing marijuana for medical use. California's law conflicted with the federal Controlled Substances Act (CSA), which banned possession of marijuana. After the Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) seized doctor-prescribed marijuana from a patient's home, a group of medical marijuana users sued the DEA and U.S. Attorney General John Ashcroft in federal district court.
The medical marijuana users argued the Controlled Substances Act - which Congress passed using its constitutional power to regulate interstate commerce - exceeded Congress' commerce clause power. The district court ruled against the group. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals reversed and ruled the CSA unconstitutional as it applied to intrastate (within a state) medical marijuana use. Relying on two U.S. Supreme Court decisions that narrowed Congress' commerce clause power - U.S. v. Lopez (1995) and U.S. v. Morrison (2000) - the Ninth Circuit ruled using medical marijuana did not "substantially affect" interstate commerce and therefore could not be regulated by Congress.
Questions
Does the Controlled Substances Act (21 U.S.C. 801) exceed Congress' power under the commerce clause as applied to the intrastate cultivation and possession of marijuana for medical use?
Conclusions
-
No. In a 6-3 opinion delivered by Justice John Paul Stevens, the Court held that the commerce clause gave Congress authority to prohibit the local cultivation and use of marijuana, despite state law to the contrary. Stevens argued that the Court's precedent "firmly established" Congress' commerce clause power to regulate purely local activities that are part of a "class of activities" with a substantial effect on interstate commerce. The majority argued that Congress could ban local marijuana use because it was part of such a "class of activities": the national marijuana market. Local use affected supply and demand in the national marijuana market, making the regulation of intrastate use "essential" to regulating the drug's national market. The majority distinguished the case from Lopez and Morrison. In those cases, statutes regulated non-economic activity and fell entirely outside Congress' commerce power; in this case, the Court was asked to strike down a particular application of a valid statutory scheme.
Open Minds: Prof. Randy Barnett & Prof. Joshua Kleinfeld Part III
In Part Three of Open Minds with Prof. Randy Barnett and Prof. Joshua Kleinfeld, Prof....
Federal Court Recognizes Limits to Federal Power Over At-Home Distilling
What are the limits of the federal government’s powers? That critical question has been debated...
Panel 3: Securing the Rights of a Free People
What responsibility do states have in protecting the rights of their citizens? How should we...
Boiling Down the Enumerated Powers: CEI Challenges the Federal Ban on Home Distilling
Perhaps you have a friend or neighbor who homebrews beer in his basement. According to...
Banquet Dinner
2024 Florida Chapters Conference
Perspectives on the Role of the Nation’s Chief Legal Officer A Conversation with Three U.S. Attorneys...
Showcase Panel IV: How Originalist is the Supreme Court?
2023 National Lawyers Convention
Featuring: Prof. J. Joel Alicea, Co-Director, Project on Constitutional Originalism and the Catholic Intellectual Tradition,...
Showcase Panel II: Whither Precedent?
2023 National Lawyers Convention
No one maintains that the Court has always and forever been originalist in its orientation....
Defend the Constitution, Save the Planet: The Role of Public Interest Groups in Shaping Environmental Law
2023 National Lawyers Convention
The United States adopted its modern environmental statutes in the 1970s. Among other innovations, Congress...
The War on Independent Work: Why Some Regulators Want to Abolish Independent Contracting, Why They Keep Failing, & Why We Should Declare Peace
Federalist Society Review, Volume 24
There is a war on independent contracting. Martial metaphors are often overworked in the law....
Talks with Authors: An Introduction to Constitutional Law: 100+ Supreme Court Cases Everyone Should Know
Professors Randy Barnett and Josh Blackman will discuss the most important Supreme Court cases of...
Revitalizing the Nondelegation Doctrine
Federalist Society Review, Volume 23
A Review of The Administrative State Before the Supreme Court: Perspectives on the Nondelegation Doctrine (Peter...
Feddie Night Festivus: Blackman vs. Everybody!
Columbus School of Law Student Chapter
The Federalist Society's Student Division &Columbus School of Law Student Chapter present Feddie Night Festivus:Blackman vs. Everybody! FeaturingUnprecedented...
Originalism: Perspectives from the Bench
2021 National Lawyers Convention
The 2021 National Lawyers Convention took place November 11-13, 2021 at the Mayflower Hotel in...
The Separation of Powers and Political Polarization
2021 National Lawyers Convention
The 2021 National Lawyers Convention took place November 11-13, 2021 at the Mayflower Hotel in...
Fourth Annual Gregory S. Coleman Memorial Lecture & Luncheon
Seventh Annual Texas Chapters Conference
On September 17-18, 2021, The Federalist Society's Texas chapters sponsored the seventh annual Texas Chapters...
Litigation Update: Alabama Association of Realtors v. HHS
Practice Groups Teleforum
On August 26, 2021, the Supreme Court of the United States ruled in Alabama Association of...
Private Entities and Public Concern
Freedom of Thought Six-Part Series: Part 6
Aside from the purely legal questions already addressed in this programming series, how should we...
Federalism & Separation of Powers: Emergency Powers and the Rule of Law
2020 National Lawyers Convention
On November 13, 2020, The Federalist Society's Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group hosted...
Showcase Panel I: Law, Social Justice, Wokeness and the Protests: Where Do We Go From Here?
2020 National Lawyers Convention
On November 12, 2020, the Federalist Society hosted a virtual panel for the 2020 National...
Supreme Court Preview: What Is in Store for October Term 2020?
Co-Sponsored by the Faculty Division and Practice Groups
On October 1, 2020, the Federalist Society's Faculty Division and Practice Groups hosted a virtual...
Book Review: Marijuana Federalism: Uncle Sam and Mary Jane
A majority of states have legalized the sale and possession of marijuana for medicinal purposes....
Book Review: Marijuana Federalism: Uncle Sam and Mary Jane
A majority of states have legalized the sale and possession of marijuana for medicinal purposes....
The Future of Originalism: A Federalist Society Zoom Dialogue
Houston Lawyers Chapter & Austin Lawyers Chapter - Online Event
On May 27, 2020, the Federalist Society's Houston and Austin lawyers chapters co-hosted a Zoom...
Federal Liability Limitations for COVID-19 Exposure Claims
What are the constitutional or other limits on Congressional authority to limit lawsuits that seek...
Federalism, COVID-19, and the Administrative State
Executive Branch Review Week Teleforum
Questions of vertical and horizontal separation of powers have risen sharply during the coronavirus pandemic. ...
Constitutionality of Proposed Federal Liability Limitations for COVID-19 Exposure Claims
By Michael A. Carvin & Yaakov M. Roth Over the past weeks, the COVID-19 pandemic...
Ex-Prosecutors And The Federal Judiciary
Professional Responsibilities & Legal Education Practice Group Teleforum
Amongst the many studies of the makeup of the Federal Judiciary, one particularly noticeable characteristic is the...
The Mythical McCulloch
Federalist Society Review, Volume 21
A Review of The Spirit of the Constitution: John Marshall and the 200-Year Odyssey of...
Panel 1: The Anti-Federalists at the Founding
2020 Annual Western Chapters Conference
On January 25, 2020, the Federalist Society hosted its annual Western Chapters Conference at the...
Horizontal Federalism: May States Project their Sovereignty Beyond Their Borders?
2019 National Lawyers Convention
On November 14, 2019, the Federalist Society's Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group hosted...
More News on Powers Reserved Exclusively to the States
Federalist Society Review, Volume 20
Note from the Editor: The Federalist Society takes no positions on particular legal and public...
Panel 1: The Original Understanding of “Privileges or Immunities”
2019 National Student Symposium
On March 15-16, 2019, the Federalist Society's student chapter at the ASU Sandra Day O'Connor...
Panel Two: What are the Limits of Local Control?
2019 Annual Western Chapters Conference
When is it appropriate for states and cities to contradict or ignore federal law? Do...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: Tennessee Wine and Spirits Retailers Association v. Byrd
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group and Regulatory Transparency Project Teleforum
For the first time in over a decade, the Supreme Court has taken a case...
Courthouse Steps: Murphy v. National Collegiate Athletic Association Decided
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group Teleforum
On Monday, May 14, 2018, the Supreme Court decision came down in Murphy v. National...
The Relationship Between the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution
2018 National Student Symposium
In 1776, the Continental Congress declared the birth of a new nation. Six of the...
The Judicial Power: The Judicial Duty to Follow the Law or a Discretionary Power of Judicial Review?
2018 National Student Symposium
Hamilton referred to the federal judiciary as the “least dangerous” branch of the new federal...
Justice Department and Marijuana Enforcement
Criminal Law & Procedure Practice Group, Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group, and Regulatory Transparency Project Teleforum
On Thursday, January 4th, Attorney General Jeff Sessions withdrew a Justice Department memo issued in...
Weyerhaeuser v. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
Environmental Law & Property Rights Teleforum
Does the Endangered Species Act authorize FWS to designate as “critical habitat” for an endangered...
Tenth Annual Rosenkranz Debate: Lochner v. New York
2017 National Lawyers Convention
RESOLVED: Lochner v. New York: Still Crazy After All These Years. The Tenth Annual Rosenkranz Debate was...
Is Everyone Now for Federalism?
2017 National Lawyers Convention
President Trump's administration has helped renew interest in federalism among Democrats and liberals. Is there...
Panel Three: Federalism as a Check on Executive Authority
2017 Annual Texas Chapters Conference
EPA regulatory power, voting rights and redistricting, federal directives regarding transgender persons, the constitutionality of...
The Legacy of Justice Scalia
2017 Annual Florida Chapters Conference
This panel, The Legacy of Justice Scalia, was held on February 3, 2017, at the...
Showcase Panel II: Rules Versus Standards in Constitutional and Statutory Interpretation
2016 National Lawyers Convention
Justice Scalia believed that the rule of law required a law of rules rather than...
Federalism & Separation of Powers: Justice Scalia on Federalism and Separation of Powers
2016 National Lawyers Convention
Justice Scalia often said that, while he always tried to get the Bill of Rights...
Judge O'Scannlain's Tribute to Justice Scalia
Following the death of Justice Scalia, there have been numerous tributes – from articles and...
25 Years of Justice Clarence Thomas - Podcast
Practice Groups Podcast
On July 1, 1991, President George H. W. Bush nominated Clarence Thomas for the Supreme...
Taylor v. United States
Last week the Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Taylor v. United States. The issue raised...
Preserving Freedom: Federal vs. State Power
2016 Annual Western Chapters Conference
Sometimes federalism is invoked because we believe the best way to preserve freedom is to...
Book Review: The Right to Try
Engage, Volume 17, Issue 1
Note from the Editor: This book review discusses the controversial concept of the constitutional “right...
People for the Ethical Treatment of Property Owners v. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service: Did Gonzalez v. Raich Eviscerate All Constitutional Limits on Federal Power?
Engage Volume 17, Issue 1
Note from the Editor: This article discusses an ongoing case questioning the constitutionality of the...
Obama's Gun Rules and the Constitution
Supporters of Second Amendment rights should have little difficulty challenging President Obama’s new executive orders...
Litigation: Ten Years of the Roberts Court
2015 National Lawyers Convention
It has been ten years since John Roberts was appointed as the 17th Chief Justice...
Panel II: The Administrative State: Within the Bounds of Law?
17th Annual Faculty Conference
This panel was part of the 17th Annual Federalist Society Faculty Conference held on January...
Do State Attorneys General Have a Duty to Defend State Laws? - Podcast
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group Podcast
Recently U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder, citing the Supreme Court's 5-4 decision in United States...
Public Interest Litigation Workshop
16th Annual Faculty Conference
The Federalist Society's Faculty Division hosted this workshop on public interest litigation on Saturday, January 4, 2014, during...
Marijuana and the States: How Should Federalism Principles Inform the Federal Government'’s Response to State Marijuana Initiatives?
Sponsored by the Center for Business Law and Regulation at Case Western Reserve University School of Law and the Practice Groups of the Federalist Society
In 2013 voters in Colorado and Washington legalized the possession of marijuana under state law....
Showcase Panel II: Textualism and Constitutional Interpretation
2013 National Lawyers Convention
This panel will examine the growth of interest in recent years in original public meaning...
Federalism: Competitive versus Cooperative Federalism
2013 National Lawyers Convention
The American system of federalism is at the heart of many disagreements over important constitutional...
Sixth Annual Rosenkranz Debate and Luncheon
2013 National Lawyers Convention
RESOLVED: Courts are too Deferential to the Legislature The Sixth Annual Rosenkranz Debate was held...
The “Mens Rea” Component Within the Issue of the Over-Federalization of Crime
Engage Volume 14, Issue 2 July 2013
Introduction After decades of hastily passing federal criminal laws, the U.S. House of Representatives, through...
Terms of Engagement - Podcast
Administrative Law & Regulation Practice Group Podcast
In his new book, Terms of Engagement: How Our Courts Should Enforce the Constitution's Promise of...
Marijuana: Examining the Tensions Between State and Federal Laws - Podcast
Criminal Law & Procedure Practice Group Podcast
Although possession and distribution of marijuana is still a violation of international treaties and the...
Marijuana: Examining the Tensions Between State and Federal Laws - Podcast
Criminal Law & Procedure Practice Group Podcast
Although possession and distribution of marijuana is still a violation of international treaties and the...
Gun Control: Assessing Constitutionality and Effectiveness - Podcast
Criminal Law & Procedure Practice Group Podcast
President Obama has proposed, and Congress is currently debating, various gun control measures in reaction...
Showcase Panel I: Federalism and Federal Power
2012 National Lawyers Convention
The Rehnquist Court was famous for its resuscitation of some fairly modest constitutional limits on...
Over-Criminalization and Public Opinion - Podcast
Criminal Law & Procedure Practice Group Podcast
Over the last thirty years, the number of federal criminal laws has increased by one-third....
Upon Further Reflection: The Health Care Decision - Podcast
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group Podcast
With several weeks' time to reflect on the U.S. Supreme Court's health care case, Professor...
Judicial Activism - Podcast
Federalism and Separation of Powers Practice Group Podcast
With the completion of the U.S. Supreme Court’s term, there has been a great deal...
How the Supreme Court Has Subverted the Constitution
Las Vegas Lawyers Chapter
The Supreme Court has endorsed an exponential growth in federal government power, often at the...
Fla. v. Dept. of Health and Human Services & Nat'l Fed. of Ind. Business v. Sebelius - Severability - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 03-30-12 featuring David Rivkin and Ian Millhiser
On March 28, 2012, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Fla. v. Dept. of Health...
Obamacare in the Supreme Court
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group
The U.S. Supreme Court is now ready to hear oral argument in one of the...
Debate: The Constitutionality of the Affordable Care Act
2012 National Student Symposium
This debate will focus on the constitutionality of the Affordable Care Act. While specific attention...
Is the Affordable Care Act Constitutional?
Pennsylvania Student Chapter
On February 22, 2012, the University of Pennsylvania Student Chapter of the Federalist Society hosted...
A Conversation Between Judge Kozinski and Judge Reinhardt
Sixth Annual Western Conference
This discussion between Judge Alex Kozinski and Judge Stephen Reinhardt was featured at the Sixth...
Florida Constitutional Challenge to Obamacare: It All Comes Down to Broccoli
Engage Volume 12, Issue 3, November 2011
Note from the Editor: This paper provides an update on the litigation dealing with the...
Fourth Annual Rosenkranz Debate and Luncheon
2011 National Lawyers Convention
RESOLVED: Congress Acted Within Its Authority in Enacting the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act...
A Debate Over the Constitutionality of the Health Care Reform Act
Indianapolis Lawyers Chapter
On October 25, 2011, the Indianapolis Lawyers Chapter of the Federalist Society hosted a debate...
Supreme Court Preview: What Is in Store for October Term 2011?
October 3rd marks the first day of the 2011 Supreme Court term. This term the...
Panel Two: Economic Security
Cyber Security, National Security and Economic Security
Both President Bush and President Obama directed comprehensive reviews of America's cyber security strategy. The...
The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act
Jacksonville Lawyers Chapter & Florida Coastal Student Chapter
On March 10, 2011, the Jacksonville Lawyers Chapter and the Florida Coastal Student Chapter co-hosted...
Panel II: Federalism and Interstate Competition
2011 National Student Symposium
This panel will assess American federalism as a competitive institution that offers a marketplace of...
Luncheon Debate: The Constitutionality of the Individual Mandate
13th Annual Faculty Conference
Prof. Randy E. Barnett, Georgetown University Law Center Prof. Orin S. Kerr, The George Washington...
Litigation: Debating the Constitutionality of the Federal Health Care Legislation
2010 National Lawyers Convention
Prof. Randy E. Barnett, Carmack Waterhouse Professor of Legal Theory, Georgetown University Law Center Hon....
Showcase Panel I: Enumerated Powers, the Tenth Amendment, and Limited Government
2010 National Lawyers Convention
The Federal government’s power has vastly increased over the history of the Republic. To what...
Federalism: Is There Any Remaining Limit to Federal Power?
2010 National Lawyers Convention
Prof. John C. Eastman, Donald P. Kennedy Chair in Law, Director, Center for Constitutional Jurisprudence,...
The Individual Health Care Mandate and Enumerated Powers
Faculty Division
Shortly after the health care reform bill was signed into law, the attorneys general of...
Panel 3 - Originalism, Precedent and Judicial Restraint
2010 National Student Symposium
We often hear much about the perils of “judicial activism” and how a judge’s proper...
Panel 2 - Originalism and Construction: Does Originalism always provide the Answer?
2010 National Student Symposium
Recently, the so-called “new originalists” have embraced a concept called constitutional construction. Constructionist originalism responds...
2010 Health Care Reform Legislation
Nashville Lawyers Chapter
The Nashville Lawyers Chapter hosted this panel discussion on "2010 Health Care Reform Legislation" at...
Constitutional Interpretation & the Bill of Rights
2009 National Lawyers Convention
Much has been written in the past 200 years on how to interpret the language...
Litigation: The Future of Federal Pre-Emption
2009 National Lawyers Convention
Pre-emption issues are a perennial area of concern for the U.S. Supreme Court. Significant cases...
Individual Health Care Insurance Mandate Debate
Online Debate
Last Updated at 9 AM, Friday, November 6, 2009 This debate will focus on the following...
Constitutional Implications of an “Individual Mandate” in Health Care Reform
The Federalist Society takes no position on particular legal or public policy initiatives. Any expressions...
Federalism: The Roberts Court and Federalism
2008 National Lawyers Convention
Hon. Paul D. Clement, Former United States Solicitor General Hon. Walter E. Dellinger III, Duke...
Forum on Judge Bork's Article: "Individual Liberty and the Constitution"
Online Debate
In a recent article in "The American Spectator" Judge Bork set out some thoughts on individual liberty and...
Panel IV: Tradition and the People's Constitution
2008 Annual Student Symposium
The Federalist Society's Student Division presented this panel at the 2008 Annual Student Symposium on...
The Conservative and Libertarian Legal Movement: A 25 Year Retrospective
2007 National Lawyers Convention
The Federalist Society's Annual Convention Luncheon was held on November 17, 2007. 12:30 p.m. -...
Abigail Alliance v. von Eschenbach
Online Debate
In May 2006, a panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of...
Enforcement of the Clean Water Act
In the 2006 plurality decision in Rapanos v. United States, the Supreme Court limited the...
Partial-Birth Abortion Ban Act
Online Debate
On April 18, 2007, the Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of the Partial-Birth Abortion Ban...
Fair-weather Federalism - Event Audio
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group
There is a longstanding debate on the appropriate division of power between the Federal Government...
High on Federalism– How Gonzales v. Raich Gave the Federal Government Unbridled Power to Use and Abuse the Commerce Clause
Idaho Student Chapter
University of Idaho College of Law514 W. Jefferson St.
Boise, ID 83702