Our website is currently undergoing updates, some links may no longer work and content may change. Please check back soon.

Facts of the Case

Provided by Oyez

In 1996 California voters passed the Compassionate Use Act, legalizing marijuana for medical use. California's law conflicted with the federal Controlled Substances Act (CSA), which banned possession of marijuana. After the Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) seized doctor-prescribed marijuana from a patient's home, a group of medical marijuana users sued the DEA and U.S. Attorney General John Ashcroft in federal district court.

The medical marijuana users argued the Controlled Substances Act - which Congress passed using its constitutional power to regulate interstate commerce - exceeded Congress' commerce clause power. The district court ruled against the group. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals reversed and ruled the CSA unconstitutional as it applied to intrastate (within a state) medical marijuana use. Relying on two U.S. Supreme Court decisions that narrowed Congress' commerce clause power - U.S. v. Lopez (1995) and U.S. v. Morrison (2000) - the Ninth Circuit ruled using medical marijuana did not "substantially affect" interstate commerce and therefore could not be regulated by Congress.


Questions

  1. Does the Controlled Substances Act (21 U.S.C. 801) exceed Congress' power under the commerce clause as applied to the intrastate cultivation and possession of marijuana for medical use?

Conclusions

  1. No. In a 6-3 opinion delivered by Justice John Paul Stevens, the Court held that the commerce clause gave Congress authority to prohibit the local cultivation and use of marijuana, despite state law to the contrary. Stevens argued that the Court's precedent "firmly established" Congress' commerce clause power to regulate purely local activities that are part of a "class of activities" with a substantial effect on interstate commerce. The majority argued that Congress could ban local marijuana use because it was part of such a "class of activities": the national marijuana market. Local use affected supply and demand in the national marijuana market, making the regulation of intrastate use "essential" to regulating the drug's national market. The majority distinguished the case from Lopez and Morrison. In those cases, statutes regulated non-economic activity and fell entirely outside Congress' commerce power; in this case, the Court was asked to strike down a particular application of a valid statutory scheme.

The War on Independent Work: Why Some Regulators Want to Abolish Independent Contracting, Why They Keep Failing, & Why We Should Declare Peace

The War on Independent Work: Why Some Regulators Want to Abolish Independent Contracting, Why They Keep Failing, & Why We Should Declare Peace

Federalist Society Review, Volume 24

There is a war on independent contracting. Martial metaphors are often overworked in the law....

Fourth Annual Gregory S. Coleman Memorial Lecture & Luncheon

Seventh Annual Texas Chapters Conference

On September 17-18, 2021, The Federalist Society's Texas chapters sponsored the seventh annual Texas Chapters...

Ex-Prosecutors And The Federal Judiciary

Ex-Prosecutors And The Federal Judiciary

Professional Responsibilities & Legal Education Practice Group Teleforum

Amongst the many studies of the makeup of the Federal Judiciary, one particularly noticeable characteristic is the...

Panel 1: The Anti-Federalists at the Founding

2020 Annual Western Chapters Conference

On January 25, 2020, the Federalist Society hosted its annual Western Chapters Conference at the...

Horizontal Federalism: May States Project their Sovereignty Beyond Their Borders?

2019 National Lawyers Convention

On November 14, 2019, the Federalist Society's Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group hosted...

Panel Two: What are the Limits of Local Control?

2019 Annual Western Chapters Conference

When is it appropriate for states and cities to contradict or ignore federal law? Do...

Justice Department and Marijuana Enforcement

Justice Department and Marijuana Enforcement

Criminal Law & Procedure Practice Group, Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group, and Regulatory Transparency Project Teleforum

On Thursday, January 4th, Attorney General Jeff Sessions withdrew a Justice Department memo issued in...

Marijuana and the States: How Should Federalism Principles Inform the Federal Government'’s Response to State Marijuana Initiatives?

Sponsored by the Center for Business Law and Regulation at Case Western Reserve University School of Law and the Practice Groups of the Federalist Society

In 2013 voters in Colorado and Washington legalized the possession of marijuana under state law....

Showcase Panel I: Federalism and Federal Power

2012 National Lawyers Convention

The Rehnquist Court was famous for its resuscitation of some fairly modest constitutional limits on...

Panel II: Federalism and Interstate Competition

2011 National Student Symposium

This panel will assess American federalism as a competitive institution that offers a marketplace of...

Panel 2 - Originalism and Construction: Does Originalism always provide the Answer?

2010 National Student Symposium

Recently, the so-called “new originalists” have embraced a concept called constitutional construction. Constructionist originalism responds...