Facts of the Case
In 2002 Lakhdar Boumediene and five other Algerian natives were seized by Bosnian police when U.S. intelligence officers suspected their involvement in a plot to attack the U.S. embassy there. The U.S. government classified the men as enemy combatants in the war on terror and detained them at the Guantanamo Bay Naval Base, which is located on land that the U.S. leases from Cuba. Boumediene filed a petition for a writ of habeas corpus, alleging violations of the Constitution's Due Process Clause, various statutes and treaties, the common law, and international law. The District Court judge granted the government's motion to have all of the claims dismissed on the ground that Boumediene, as an alien detained at an overseas military base, had no right to a habeas petition. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit affirmed the dismissal but the Supreme Court reversed in Rasul v. Bush, which held that the habeas statute extends to non-citizen detainees at Guantanamo.
In 2006, Congress passed the Military Commissions Act of 2006 (MCA). The Act eliminates federal courts' jurisdiction to hear habeas applications from detainees who have been designated (according to procedures established in the Detainee Treatment Act of 2005) as enemy combatants. When the case was appealed to the D.C. Circuit for the second time, the detainees argued that the MCA did not apply to their petitions, and that if it did, it was unconstitutional under the Suspension Clause. The Suspension Clause reads: "The Privilege of the Writ of Habeas Corpus shall not be suspended, unless when in Cases of Rebellion or Invasion the public Safety may require it."
The D.C. Circuit ruled in favor of the government on both points. It cited language in the MCA applying the law to "all cases, without exception" that pertain to aspects of detention. One of the purposes of the MCA, according to the Circuit Court, was to overrule the Supreme Court's opinion in Hamdan v. Rumsfeld, which had allowed petitions like Boumediene's to go forward. The D.C. Circuit held that the Suspension Clause only protects the writ of habeas corpus as it existed in 1789, and that the writ would not have been understood in 1789 to apply to an overseas military base leased from a foreign government. Constitutional rights do not apply to aliens outside of the United States, the court held, and the leased military base in Cuba does not qualify as inside the geographic borders of the U.S. In a rare reversal, the Supreme Court granted certiorari after initially denying review three months earlier.
Questions
Should the Military Commissions Act of 2006 be interpreted to strip federal courts of jurisdiction over habeas petitions filed by foreign citizens detained at the U.S. Naval Base at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba?
If so, is the Military Commissions Act of 2006 a violation of the Suspension Clause of the Constitution?
Are the detainees at Guantanamo Bay entitled to the protection of the Fifth Amendment right not to be deprived of liberty without due process of law and of the Geneva Conventions?
Conclusions
-
A five-justice majority answered yes to each of these questions. The opinion, written by Justice Anthony Kennedy, stated that if the MCA is considered valid its legislative history requires that the detainees' cases be dismissed. However, the Court went on to state that because the procedures laid out in the Detainee Treatment Act are not adequate substitutes for the habeas writ, the MCA operates as an unconstitutional suspension of that writ. The detainees were not barred from seeking habeas or invoking the Suspension Clause merely because they had been designated as enemy combatants or held at Guantanamo Bay. The Court reversed the D.C. Circuit's ruling and found in favor of the detainees. Justice David H. Souter concurred in the judgment. Chief Justice John G. Roberts and Justice Antonin Scalia filed separate dissenting opinions.
Jurisdiction Stripping: Fact & Fiction Flowing Through the Mountain Valley Pipeline Case
Generally, when Congress strips courts of jurisdiction, it does so by implementing broad, forward-looking, statutory...
The Northwest Ordinance: Historically Significant, Still Relevant
Happy birthday to the Northwest Ordinance, which the Articles of Confederation Congress enacted on July...
Panel 1: State Constitutionalism in North Carolina
Inaugural North Carolina Chapters Conference
CLE credit anticipated. Featuring: Professor John Orth, William Rand Kenan Jr. Professor of Law, UNC...
Scalia’s Theory of the Suspension Clause in St. Cyr
Experts have long debated Congress’s power to withhold federal court jurisdiction. But in 2008, the...
Courthouse Steps Decision: Department of Homeland Security v. Thuraissigiam
On June 25, Justice Alito, writing for a five justice majority of the Supreme Court,...
Hernandez v. Mesa - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 7-24-17 featuring Steven Giaier
On June 26, 2017, the Supreme Court decided Hernandez v. Mesa. In 2010, Sergio Adrian...
Courthouse Steps: Hernandez v. Mesa Decided - Podcast
International & National Security Law Practice Group Podcast
On Monday, the Supreme Court vacated and remanded Hernandez v. Mesa to the Fifth Circuit. The case...
Hernandez v. Mesa - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 3-30-17 featuring Steven Giaier
On February 21, 2017, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Hernandez v. Mesa. In...
Courthouse Steps: Hernandez v. Mesa - Podcast
International & National Security Law Podcast
On February 21, the Supreme Court heard argument in Hernandez v. Mesa. In July of 2010,...
International & National Security Law: Justice Scalia’s Jurisprudence and National Security
2016 National Lawyers Convention
This panel will consider Justice Scalia's legacy in national security law, revisiting his opinions in...
Countdown to the National Lawyers Convention: What's "Conservative" about the "Roberts" Court?
Next week, I will participate in the Federalist Society’s National Lawyers Convention, in Washington, D.C.,...
The Legal and Policy Implications of Closing Guantánamo Bay - Podcast
International & National Security Law Practice Group Podcast
Would relocation of War on Terror detainees currently held at Guantánamo Bay, Cuba into the...
National Security, the U.N., and the Extraterritorial Application of Treaties - Podcast
International & National Security Law Practice Group Podcast
The United States Government has consistently interpreted the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights...
Book Review: Cosmic Constitutional Theory: Why Americans Are Losing Their Inalienable Right to Self-Governance
Engage Volume 14, Issue 2 July 2013
Other Reviews of Cosmic Constitutional Theory: •Marc O. Degirolami, The New Republic, Sept. 2012: http://www.newrepublic.com/book/review/cosmic-constitutional-theory-judicial-restraint...
The Use of Lethal Force on U.S. Citizens - Podcast
International & National Security Law Practice Group Podcast
As U.S. Sen. Rand Paul (Kentucky)'s filibuster of the confirmation of John O. Brennan, President...
Predator Drones and Targeted Killings
International & National Security Law Practice Group Podcast
In this Practice Groups Podcast, Professor Michael W. Lewis and ACLU National Security Project Litigation...
Engage Volume 11, Issue 3, December 2010
The Journal of the Federalist Society Practice Groups
*Online-Only Issue* Special Edition: Templeton Debates Eminent Domain after Kelo Ilya Somin & Saul Levmore...
A Fundamental Misconception of Separation of Powers: Boumediene v. Bush
Engage Volume 11, Issue 3, December 2010
Terrorists attacked the United States on September 11, 2001. Congress quickly authorized the President to...
Panel 1: Detention and Trial of Terrorist Suspects
Counterterrorism and the Obama Administration
Jonathan Hafetz, Esq., American Civil Liberties Union Elisa Massimino, Chief Executive Officer and Executive Director,...
Panel V: War Powers and the Executive
2009 National Student Symposium
The Federalist Society's Student Division presented this panel at the 2009 Annual Student Symposium on...
The War on Terror: Litigation Update
International & National Security Law Practice Group
Amidst numerous pending war-on-terror-related court cases, ranging from the upcoming Supreme Court's consideration of the...
Panel: Guantanamo Bay: the Problem of Judicial Review Post-Boumediene
11th Annual Faculty Conference
Dean Erwin Chemerinsky, University of California, Irvine School of Law Prof. Michael Ramsey, University of...
Keynote Address by George W. Bush
The Presidency and the Courts
George W. Bush, President of the United States Introduction: Peter W. Schramm, Ashbrook Center for...
Remarks by the President on Judicial Accomplishments and Philosophy
Transcript
Hilton Cincinnati Netherland PlazaCincinnati, Ohio 3:02 P.M. EDT THE PRESIDENT: Thank you very much. (Applause.) ...
Bar Watch Bulletin August 9 & 10, 2008
SCOTUS Review, American Press & War, the 14th Amendment, Human Rights, Climate Change, Women in Law, and Immigration
The American Bar Association's Annual Meeting will be taking place from August 7-12 in New...
Bar Watch Bulletin August 2008
Preview of Annual Meeting
Today we offer a preview of the ABA Annual Meeting in New York City. The...
A Look Back at the October Supreme Court 2007 Term
Is the DC gun ban constitutional? Do Guantanamo Bay prisoners have a constitutional right to...
Barwatch Bulletin February 13, 2008
House of Delegate Action
CENTER FOR HUMAN RIGHTS LUNCHEONThe Center for Human Rights' House of Delegates Luncheon featured Albert...
Supreme Court Term
Online Debate
The Supreme Court ended its OT07 term on June 26, 2008. We are hosting a live...
SCOTUScast 6-16-08 featuring Richard Epstein
Boumediene v. Bush and Munaf v. Geren
On June 12, the Supreme Court decided Boumediene v. Bush. The Court held that certain...
SCOTUScast 6-16-08 featuring David Rivkin
Boumediene v. Bush
On June 12, the Supreme Court decided Boumediene v. Bush. The Court held that certain...
SCOTUScast 6-16-08 featuring Richard Epstein
Boumediene v. Bush and Munaf v. Geren
On June 12, the Supreme Court decided Boumediene v. Bush. The Court held that certain...
SCOTUScast 6-16-08 featuring David Rivkin
Boumediene v. Bush
On June 12, the Supreme Court decided Boumediene v. Bush. The Court held that certain...
SCOTUScast 12-7-07 featuring Bradford Berenson
Boumediene v. Bush
On December 5th, 2007, the Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Boumediene v. Bush. The...
SCOTUScast 12-7-07 featuring Bradford Berenson
Boumediene v. Bush
On December 5th, 2007, the Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Boumediene v. Bush. The...
Boumediene v. Bush
Online Debate
Boumediene v. Bush arises on a writ of habeas corpus filed on behalf of Lakmar...
Engage Volume 8, Issue 3, June 2007
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW & REGULATION Gasoline, Markets, and Regulators by Andrew Morriss CIVIL RIGHTS The Legal...
Stripping Habeas Corpus Jurisdiction Over Non-Citizens Detained Outside the United States: Boumediene v. Bush and the Supreme Court
In the ongoing saga over the detainees held at Guantanamo Bay, the D.C. Circuit recently...
International & National Security Law: Justice Scalia’s Jurisprudence and National Security
2016 National Lawyers Convention
The Mayflower Hotel1127 Connecticut Avenue, NW
Washington, DC 20036
2016 National Lawyers Convention
The Jurisprudence and Legacy of Justice Scalia
The Mayflower Hotel1127 Connecticut Avenue, NW
Washington, DC 20036
Professor Govern began his legal career as an Army Judge Advocate, serving 20 years during peacetime and war in assignments that spanned the world. He has also served as an Assistant Professor of Law at the United States Military Academy and has taught at California University of Pennsylvania. Professor Govern has published widely and spoken frequently on international and comparative law, national security and homeland security law, military operations, and professional ethics.