Facts of the Case
The Christian Legal Society Chapter of the University of California, Hastings College of Law (CLS) filed suit against the university in a California federal district for violating its First Amendment rights. The Hastings College of Law failed to recognize the CLS as an official student organization because state law requires all registered student organizations to allow "any student to participate, become a member, or seek leadership positions, regardless of their status or beliefs." In contrast, CLS requires its members to attest in writing that "I believe in: The Bible as the inspired word of God; The Deity of our Lord, Jesus Christ, God's son; The vicarious death of Jesus Christ for our sins; His bodily resurrection and His personal return; The presence and power of the Holy Spirit in the work of regeneration; [and] Jesus Christ, God's son, is Lord of my life." The district court dismissed the case.
On appeal, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed, holding that the school's conditions on recognizing student groups were viewpoint neutral and reasonable. Therefore, the school's conditions did not violate the CLS's First Amendment rights.
Questions
Did the Ninth Circuit err when its holding runs directly contrary to the Seventh Circuit's 2006 decision in Christian Legal Society v. Walker?
Conclusions
-
No. The Supreme Court affirmed the Ninth Circuit, holding that the college's all-comers policy is a reasonable, viewpoint-neutral condition on access to the student organization forum; and, therefore, did not transgress First Amendment limitations. With Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg writing for the majority, the Court reasoned that the same considerations that have led the Court to apply a less restrictive level of scrutiny to speech in limited public forums, counseled the same result in this case. The Court further reasoned that, considering this constitutional inquiry occurs in the education context, Hasting's all-comers policy is reasonable and viewpoint neutral.
Justice John Paul Stevens, wrote separately, concurring. He agreed with the Court's holding and answered an argument raised by CLS that Hasting's Nondiscrimination Policy would be "plainly unconstitutional" if addressed in this case. He disagreed with CLS noting that while the First Amendment may protect CLS' discriminatory practices off campus, it does not require a public university to validate or support such practices. Justice Anthony M. Kennedy also concurred. He noted that to be effective, a limited forum will exclude some speakers based on their affiliation, as occurred in this case. Justice Samuel A. Alito, joined by Chief Justice John G. Roberts and Justices Antonin Scalia and Clarence Thomas, dissented. He critiqued the majority for expounding the principle: "no freedom for expression that offends prevailing standards of political correctness in our country's institutions of higher learning." He argued that the majority arms public institutions with a "handy weapon" for suppressing the speech of unpopular groups.
Panel 4: The NetChoice Problem
We know how to think about government coercion. We have ready and familiar frameworks for...
Panel Discussion: Legal Challenges Involving Gender Identity Post-Bostock
2023 Texas Chapters Conference
Litigation and legislation involving complex issues regarding gender identity are at the forefront of public...
Litigation Update: FCA v San Jose Unified School Dist.
Fellowship of Christian Athletes v. San Jose Unified School District concerned a Christian student club's...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: 303 Creative v. Elenis
On December 5,2022, the U.S. Supreme Court will hear oral argument in 303 Creative LLC...
A Seat at the Sitting - December 2022
The December Docket in 90 minutes or less.
Each month, a panel of constitutional experts convenes to discuss the Court’s upcoming docket sitting...
Panel 2 - Better Believe It: Free Exercise and the First Amendment
Leading the charge for abolition during the Civil War-era, among others, were abolitionists with deeply...
Showcase Panel III: Corporate and Academic Management Today
2021 National Lawyers Convention
The 2021 National Lawyers Convention took place November 11-13, 2021 at the Mayflower Hotel in...
Litigation Update: InterVarsity Christian Fellowship/USA v. University of Iowa et al.
Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group Teleforum
On July 16, 2021, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eight Circuit issued a...
We Are Free for a Reason
Federalist Society Review, Volume 22
A review of Free to Believe: The Battle Over Religious Liberty in America, by Luke...
Courthouse Steps Decision: USAID v. Alliance for Open Society International, Inc.
On Monday, the Supreme Court released its decision in United States Agency for International Development...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: USAID v. Alliance for Open Society International, Inc.
On May 5, 2020, the Supreme Court will hear arguments in an important First Amendment...
Lessons for University Administrators: Courts Protect Religious Student Groups on Campus
This fall, University of Iowa officials and their lawyer heard this from a federal judge:...
Kicked Off Campus: Religious Discrimination in the Supreme Court
Business Leaders in Christ v. University of Iowa
In recent years, the Supreme Court has been generally friendly to free speech and religious...
Litigation Update: BLinC v. U Iowa and the Future of CLS v. Martinez
Last week a federal judge issued a ruling for Business Leaders in Christ (“BLinC”), a...
Compelled Speech in Masterpiece Cakeshop: What the Supreme Court’s June 2018 Decisions Tell Us About the Unresolved Questions
Federalist Society Review, Volume 19
Note from the Editor: This article discusses the unresolved compelled-speech questions in Masterpiece Cakeshop v....
Courthouse Steps: Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado CRC
Religious Liberties Practice Group Teleforum
On December 5th, The Supreme Court will hear oral arguments in Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado...
Student Perspectives on Intellectual Diversity in Academia
Stanford Intellectual Diversity Conference
The proper education of America’s youth is arguably the most important social responsibility the university...
Panel: American Multiculturalism: Its Force and Limits From 1776 to Today
18th Annual Faculty Conference
Since before the Revolution, American legal and political traditions have supported many forms of multiculturalism,...
Litigation: Ten Years of the Roberts Court
2015 National Lawyers Convention
It has been ten years since John Roberts was appointed as the 17th Chief Justice...
Countdown to the National Lawyers Convention: What's "Conservative" about the "Roberts" Court?
Next week, I will participate in the Federalist Society’s National Lawyers Convention, in Washington, D.C.,...
Censoring Specialty License Plates - Podcast
Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group Podcast
Many states make money by letting a wide range of groups order specialty license plates...
How First Amendment Procedures Protect First Amendment Substance
2014 National Lawyers Convention
While the substance of constitutional rights is always important, it is often the procedures surrounding...
Free Speech: The First Amendment and Government Benefits
2013 National Lawyers Convention
The government (federal, state, and local) offers a wide range of benefits to groups. Some...
Free Speech: The First Amendment and Government Benefits
2013 National Lawyers Convention
The government (federal, state, and local) offers a wide range of benefits to groups. Some...
Showcase Panel I: Textualism and the Bill of Rights
2013 National Lawyers Convention
The new textualism has had a big impact on interpretation of the Bill of Rights....
Anti-discrimination and Individual Liberties: Elane Photography v. Willock - Podcast
Civil Rights and Religious Liberties Practice Groups Podcast
On August 22, the New Mexico Supreme Court ruled in Elane Photography v. Willock that...
Unlearning Liberty: Campus Censorship and the End of American Debate
Indianapolis Lawyers Chapter
On April 11, 2013, the Indianapolis Lawyers Chapter of the Federalist Society hosted an event...
Showcase Panel IV: An Examination of Substantive Due Process and Judicial Activism
2012 National Lawyers Convention
After it became clear at the oral argument the health care mandate law might be...
Showcase Panel III: Religion Clauses
2012 National Lawyers Convention
The current Supreme Court divided five to four in Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization v....
Showcase Panel III: Religion Clauses
2012 National Lawyers Convention
The current Supreme Court divided five to four in Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization v....
Liberty’s Refuge - Faculty Book Podcast
Faculty Division Podcast 07-06-12 featuring John Inazu and Michael McConnell
During the past decade, courts have struggled to reconcile anti-discrimination statutes with claims by private...
Liberty's Refuge: The Forgotten Freedom of Assembly
Faculty Division
Ask Americans what they think the First Amendment protects, and they will tell you “freedom...
Religious Liberties: Christian Legal Society vs. Martínez
2010 National Lawyers Convention
Prof. Richard W. Garnett, IV, Associate Dean, University of Notre Dame Law School Mr. Jordan...
2010 Annual Supreme Court Round Up
Washington, DC Lawyers Chapter
On July 9, 2010, former United States Solicitor General Gregory G. Garre delivered the Annual...
Christian Legal Society v. Martinez - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 06-30-10 featuring Richard A. Epstein
On June 28, 2010, the Supreme Court announced its decision in Christian Legal Society v....
Christian Legal Society v. Martinez – Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 04-23-10 featuring Richard A. Epstein
On April 19, 2010, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Christian Legal Society v....
Christian Legal Society v. Martínez
Religious Liberties Practice Group
The Federalist Society's Religious Liberties Practice Group, the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, and the...