Facts of the Case
A three-judge district court struck down North Carolina’s 2016 congressional map, ruling that the plaintiffs had standing to challenge the map and that the map was the product of partisan gerrymandering. The district court then enjoined the state from using the map after November 2018. North Carolina Republicans, led by Robert Rucho, head of the senate redistricting committee, appealed the decision to the Supreme Court.
Questions
Do the plaintiffs in this case have standing to pursue their partisan gerrymandering claims?
Are the plaintiffs’ partisan gerrymandering claims justiciable?
Is North Carolina’s 2016 congressional map an unconstitutional partisan gerrymander?
Conclusions
-
Partisan gerrymandering claims are not justiciable because they present a political question beyond the reach of the federal courts.
Chief Justice John Roberts delivered the 5-4 majority opinion. Federal courts are charged with resolving cases and controversies of a judicial nature. In contrast, questions of a political nature are “nonjusticiable,” and the courts cannot resolve such questions. Partisan gerrymandering has existed since prior to the independence of the United States, and, aware of this occurrence, the Framers chose to empower state legislatures, “expressly checked and balanced by the Federal Congress” to handle these matters. While federal courts can resolve “a variety of questions surrounding districting,” including racial gerrymandering, it is beyond their power to decide the central question: when has political gerrymandering gone too far. In the absence of any “limited and precise standard” for evaluating partisan gerrymandering, federal courts cannot resolve such issues.
Justice Elena Kagan filed a dissenting opinion, in which Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Stephen Breyer, and Sonia Sotomayor joined. Justice Kagan criticized the Court for sidestepping a critical question involving the violation of “the most fundamental of . . . constitutional rights: the rights to participate equally in the political process, to join with others to advance political beliefs, and to choose their political representatives.” Justice Kagan argued that by not intervening in the political gerrymanders, the Court effectively “encourage[s] a politics of polarization and dysfunction” that “may irreparably damage our system of government.” She argued that the standards adopted in lower courts across the country do meet the contours of the “limited and precise standard” the majority demanded yet purported not to find.
This case was consolidated with Lamone v. Benisek, No. 18-726, and the Court released a single opinion resolving both cases.
How Did State Constitutions Shape the American Founding?
The Founders Gave Us the Tools Series
In this Federalist Society America 250 series, experts analyze modern legal and policy debates through...
Courthouse Steps Decision: Bost v. Illinois State Board of Elections
Bost v. Illinois State Board of Elections involved whether a candidate for federal office has...
Integrity or Interference?: Evaluating the Constitutionality of Georgia's Election Integrity Act
Federalist Society Review, Volume 25
Recent political earthquakes such as the assassination attempt against former president Donald Trump and President...
Alexander v. South Carolina State Conference of the NAACP: New Rules for Partisan Gerrymanders, But Possibly Limited Effect
How do you separate race and political preference when establishing new congressional districts? The federal...
Alexander v. South Carolina State Conference of the NAACP: New Rules for Partisan Gerrymanders, But Possibly Limited Effect
How do you separate race and political preference when establishing new congressional districts? The federal...
Toward a More Confident State Constitutionalism
Federalist Society Review, Volume 25
This article is adapted from a speech Justice Markman delivered to the Florida Annual Education...
Standing and Section 2: Does Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act Provide a Private Right of Action?
In 2021, in Arkansas State Conference NAACP v. Arkansas Board of Apportionment, private litigants sued...
Fair Elections in an Era of Partisanship
2023 National Lawyers Convention
Recent years have seen unprecedented controversies about election rules, including mail-in ballots and drop boxes,...
The Judiciary's Federalist Revival
2023 National Lawyers Convention
In recent years, the U.S. Supreme Court has emphasized the federalist nature of our national...
North Carolina Supreme Court Reverses Itself In Two Election Law Cases Decided Months Prior
In December 2022, the North Carolina Supreme Court issued opinions in two cases—one striking down...
Lockstep or Step Alone: Considering Interpretations of the Federal Constitution When Interpreting State Constitutions
Many state constitutional provisions are worded similarly to provisions of the federal Constitution. At times,...
2023 Annual Supreme Court Round Up
Registration is now closed. We will not be accepting walk-ins or on-site registration for this...
Panel II: The Democratic Election Process: What is Fair and Who Decides Fairness?
2023 National Student Symposium
Democracy begins with elections. But the process for voting in our elections has been increasingly...
Panel I: What is Democracy?
2023 National Student Symposium
There has been much discussion about threats to democracy over the past year. But conceptions...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: Moore v. Harper
On December 7, 2022, the U.S. Supreme Court will hear oral argument in Moore v....
A Seat at the Sitting - December 2022
The December Docket in 90 minutes or less.
Each month, a panel of constitutional experts convenes to discuss the Court’s upcoming docket sitting...
Panel 2: The Law of Democracy: Recent and Future Developments in Election Law
Inaugural North Carolina Chapters Conference
CLE credit anticipated. Featuring: Rick Glazier, Executive Director, North Carolina Justice Center Professor Derek Muller,...
Litigation Update: State Legislatures, State Courts, and Federal Elections
Who decides the rules for federal elections? The Constitution generally assigns that power to the...
State Court Docket Watch: Harper v. Hall
In its 2019 decision in Rucho v. Common Cause, the U.S. Supreme Court closed the...
III: 21st Century Federalism: A View from the States (Roundtable)
2022 National Student Symposium
This panel will center discussion on the role of the states in our constitutional order—by...
Talks with Authors: Who Decides? States as Laboratories of Constitutional Experimentation
As federalism becomes an increasingly important principle of our constitutional structure, Chief Judge Jeffrey Sutton...
Panel One: Redistricting in Florida: 2010s vs. 2020s
Eighth Annual Florida Chapters Conference
The first panel of the Federalist Society's Eighth Annual Florida Chapters Conference featured an impressive...
Book Review: Who Decides?
Making the Most of States as Laboratories of Democracy: Applying and Extending Judge Sutton’s Analysis
Judge Jeffrey Sutton (who I must disclose at the outset is a good friend despite...
Book Review: Who Decides?
Making the Most of States as Laboratories of Democracy: Applying and Extending Judge Sutton’s Analysis
Judge Jeffrey Sutton (who I must disclose at the outset is a good friend despite...
Courthouse Steps Decision Webinar: Brnovich v. Democratic National Convention
Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group Teleforum
On July 1, 2021, the Supreme Court issued its decision in Brnovich, Attorney General of Arizona...
Panel II: A Cleaner Missouri? Redistricting: What We Can Expect
2021 Federalist Society Missouri State Conference
On March 8, 2021, the Federalist Society's Missouri lawyers chapters held a statewide conference via...
Wisconsin Presidential Election Litigation: DNC et al. v. Bostelmann et al.
Ahead of the 2020 presidential election, and in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic, election-related...
Wisconsin Presidential Election Litigation: DNC et al. v. Bostelmann et al.
Ahead of the 2020 presidential election, and in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic, election-related...
Wisconsin Election Law Panel
2020 Wisconsin Lawyers Chapters Conference
On September 1, 2020, the Federalist Society's Wisconsin lawyers chapters hosted their annual conference via...
Wisconsin Election Law Panel
2020 Wisconsin Lawyers Chapters Conference
On September 1, 2020, the Federalist Society's Wisconsin lawyers chapters hosted their annual conference via...
Recent Trends in the Roberts Court
Milwaukee Lawyers Chapter
On August 18, 2020, the Federalist Society's Milwaukee Lawyers Chapter hosted a virtual event on...
Why Proportional Representation Will Not Stem Redistricting Litigation But Will Undermine Normative Representative Values
Federalist Society Review, Volume 21
Note from the Editor: The Federalist Society takes no positions on particular legal and public...
Why Proportional Representation Will Not Stem Redistricting Litigation But Will Undermine Normative Representative Values
Federalist Society Review, Volume 21
Note from the Editor: The Federalist Society takes no positions on particular legal and public...
Escaping the Goldilocks Problem: A Proposal That Would Enable States to Avoid Redistricting Litigation
Federalist Society Review, Volume 21
Note from the Editor: The Federalist Society takes no positions on particular legal and public...
An Imagined Bloc and Other Figments
Federalist Society Review, Volume 21
A review of American Justice 2019: The Roberts Court Arrives, by Mark Joseph Stern (University...
An Imagined Bloc and Other Figments
Federalist Society Review, Volume 21
A review of American Justice 2019: The Roberts Court Arrives, by Mark Joseph Stern (University...
Panel 3: The Anti-Federalists and the Court
2020 Annual Western Chapters Conference
On January 25, 2020, the Federalist Society hosted its annual Western Chapters Conference at the...
Panel 2: The Anti-Federalists and Theories of Originalism
2020 Annual Western Chapters Conference
On January 25, 2020, the Federalist Society hosted its annual Western Chapters Conference at the...
Young Legal Scholars Paper Presentations
22nd Annual Federalist Society Faculty Conference
On January 3-4, 2020, the Federalist Society hosted its 22nd annual Faculty Conference at the...
Second Amendment in the Highest Court: NYSPRA v. City of New York
How much is too much? That was a principal question in the partisan gerrymandering case...
Second Amendment in the Highest Court: NYSPRA v. City of New York
How much is too much? That was a principal question in the partisan gerrymandering case...
Panel Three: Election Issues Roundtable
2019 Texas Chapters Conference
On September 14, 2019, The Federalist Society held a roundtable on election issues during its...
Courthouse Steps Decision: The Gerrymandering Cases, Rucho et al. v. Common Cause et al.
On June 27, the Supreme Court decided several redistricting cases in Rucho et al. v. Common...
Rucho v. Common Cause and Lamone v. Benisek - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast featuring Derek Muller
On March 26, 2019, the Supreme Court heard argument in Rucho v. Common Cause and...
Rucho v. Common Cause and Lamone v. Benisek - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast featuring Derek Muller
On March 26, 2019, the Supreme Court heard argument in Rucho v. Common Cause and...
Zombie Rulings and Public Elections
American politics could soon be the victim of “zombie rulings” if the activists seeking to...
Courthouse Steps Decision Webinar: Brnovich v. Democratic National Convention
Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group Teleforum
TeleforumWhere Do We Draw the Line? Partisan Gerrymandering & Rucho v. Common Cause
Northwestern Student Chapter
Northwestern Pritzker School of Law375 E. Chicago Ave
CHICAGO, IL 60611