Facts of the Case
The University of Michigan’s Office of Undergraduate Admissions (OUA) considers a number of factors in its evaluative process, such as high school grades, standardized test scores, curriculum strength, alumni relationships, geography, and leadership. The OUA also considers race and admits virtually every qualified applicant from certain groups determined to be “underrepresented minorities.” Beginning in 1998, the OUA used a point system in which students were awarded an additional 20 points for being a member of an underrepresented minority, and beginning in 1999, the University established an Admissions Review Committee to provide an additional level of consideration.
In 1995, Jennifer Gratz and Patrick Hamacher both applied for admission to the University of Michigan’ College of Literature, Science, and the Arts (LSA) as residents of the state of Michigan. Both are of Caucasian descent. Both were denied admission and told that, although they were qualified, they were not competitive enough applicants to be admitted on first review. In October 1997, Gratz and Hamacher filed a class action suit against the University, the LSA, Lee Bollinger, and James Duderstadt. They argued that the admission procedure discriminated against certain racial and ethnic groups in violation of the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment and Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. The district court held that the respondents had shown that a racially and ethnically diverse student body produced significant academic benefits but that the admission policies of 1995-1998 were problematic because they amounted to “holding seats” for certain minority groups. Therefore, the court granted summary judgment for the petitioners with respect to the admissions policies for 1995-1998 and for the respondents with respect to the policy that began in 1999. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit heard this case the same day as Grutter v. Bollinger, a similar case, and upheld the University’s admission policies in that case. The petitioners in this case then asked the Court to grant certiorari, despite the lack of opinion from the lower court, to resolve the issue.
Questions
Did the University of Michigan’s use of racial preferences in undergraduate admissions violate the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment and Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964?
Conclusions
-
Yes. Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist delivered the opinion for the 6-3 majority. The Court held that the OUA’s policies were not sufficiently narrowly tailored to meet the strict scrutiny standard. Because the policy did not provide individual consideration, but rather resulted in the admission of nearly every applicant of “underrepresented minority” status, it was not narrowly tailored in the manner required by previous jurisprudence on the issue.
In her concurring opinion, Justice Sandra Day O’Connor wrote that the record showed that the only individualized consideration in the admissions process came through the Admissions Review Committee. Because the Committee played only a small part in the overall admissions process, it was not sufficient to satisfy the strict scrutiny standard. Justice Clarence Thomas wrote a separate concurring opinion in which he argued that the Equal Protection Clause prohibits any racial discrimination for the purposes of higher education admission. The admission policy in question failed because it did not allow for sufficient consideration of non-racial factors in determining the admissibility of a candidate from an underrepresented minority group. In his separate opinion concurring in the judgment, Justice Stephen Breyer wrote that, in cases dealing with the Equal Protection Clause, the Court should distinguish between policies of inclusion and policies of exclusion because the former are much more likely to prove consistent with the intent of the Clause.
Justice John Paul Stevens wrote a dissenting opinion in which he argued that, because neither of the petitioners could receive any benefit from the relief being requested, precedent required that the case be dismissed. While they are entitled to relief for past wrongs, they cannot seek injunctive relief to prevent future harms to other parties. Justice David Souter joined in the dissent. In his separate dissent, Justice Souter wrote that, by making race only one of a number of factors to be considered, the admissions policy meets the requirements established by previous Equal Protection Clause jurisprudence. Because the point system and the Admissions Review Committee operate in conjunction with each other, there cannot be the “holding of seats” phenomenon that the majority opinion fears. Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg joined in the dissent. Justice Ginsburg also wrote a separate dissenting opinion in which she argued that, because there is no evidence that the OUA policies attempt to limit or decrease enrollment by any particular racial or ethnic group and there is no evidence of saving seats, the policies do not violate the Equal Protection Clause. Racial information about an applicant can be useful in admission considerations because it often serves to show what a student has accomplished and why the student is worthy of admission. Justice Souter joined in the dissent.
The Landmark Case Of Shaare Tefila v. Cobb
Federalist Society Review, Volume 25
A review of Annalise E. Glauz-Todrank, Judging Jewish Identity in the United States (Lexington Books 2023)...
Courthouse Steps Decision: SFFA v. Harvard
On Thursday, June 29, 2023, the Supreme Court issued its decision in Students for Fair...
Talks with Authors: An Introduction to Constitutional Law: 100+ Supreme Court Cases Everyone Should Know
Professors Randy Barnett and Josh Blackman will discuss the most important Supreme Court cases of...
Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard: Affirmative Action Goes to Court
2022 National Lawyers Convention
The panel is sponsored by our Civil Rights practice group and will focus on the...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: SFFA v. Harvard
On October 31, 2022, the U.S. Supreme Court will hear Students for Fair Admissions Inc....
A Seat at the Sitting - November 2022
The November Docket in 90 minutes or Less
Each month, a panel of experts convenes to discuss the Court’s upcoming docket sitting by...
College Admissions: Fair or Fixed?
As the Supreme Court prepares to hear two cases this fall that challenge race preferential...
Title VI, College Admissions, and Public Opinion
A Regulatory Transparency Project Webinar
With the Supreme Court about to hear two cases involving the use of race in...
Litigation Update: Cert Granted in Students for Fair Admission v. Harvard and Students for Fair Admission v. UNC Chapel Hill
Breaking news: The Supreme Court granted certiorari in two petitions pending before the Supreme Court...
Why Racial Preferences Harm Higher Education
An article of faith among leftists is that we must give preferences to certain “underrepresented”...
Panel One: Racial Preferences in Higher Education: What are the Consequences and What Will the Supreme Court Do?
2021 Third Circuit Chapters Conference
Despite the fact that Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibits racial...
Gender Based Board Quotas, the Fourteenth Amendment, and Meland v. Weber
In-House Counsel Working Group, Civil Rights Practice Group, and Regulatory Transparency Project Teleforum
On June 21, 2021, the Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ruled a shareholder-plaintiff...
A Discussion: Students for Fair Admissions v. President and Fellows of Harvard College
In Students for Fair Admissions v. President and Fellows of Harvard College, petitioning Asian-American students...
Should the Supreme Court Take Note of “Th’ Iliction Returns” Next Time It Addresses Race-Preferential Admissions Policies?
Federalist Society Review, Volume 22
“[N]o matter whether th’ constitution follows th’ flag or not, th’ Supreme Court follows th’...
Diversity and Elimination of Bias CLE Teleforum: An update to the Harvard Case and the Meaning of Diversity in a Multi-Racial Era
Professional Responsibilities Practice Group Diversity CLE Teleforum
Electronic Sign In: Click Here (Sign-in now!) Written Materials: Click Here Certificate of Attendance: Click Here (Fill in the form...
Diversity and Elimination of Bias CLE Teleforum: The Harvard Case and the Meaning of Diversity in a Multi-Racial Era
Professional Responsibilities & Legal Education Teleforum
*** Please note: CLE is no longer available for this teleforum/podcast.*** Electronic Sign In: Click...
Accounting for Race 101: Virginia Universities and Racial Preferences
Regulatory Transparency Project
On September 10, 2019, The Federalist Society hosted a luncheon cosponsored with the Center for...
Discrimination Against Minorities
2018 National Lawyers Convention
In 2014, Students for Fair Admissions (SFFA) sued Harvard University, alleging that Harvard was violating...
Solicitor General Francisco Attempts to Fast-Track DACA Litigation to SCOTUS
U.S. Solicitor General Noel Francisco petitioned the Supreme Court on Monday to grant certiorari before...
Solicitor General Francisco Attempts to Fast-Track DACA Litigation to SCOTUS
U.S. Solicitor General Noel Francisco petitioned the Supreme Court on Monday to grant certiorari before...
Law Firm Preferences - Podcast
Major American corporations are pressuring their outside law firms to meet diversity goals both firm-wide and...
Fisher v. UT–Austin and the Future of Racial Preferences in College Admissions
Federalist Society Review, Volume 17, Issue 2
Note from the Editor: This article discusses the Supreme Court’s recent decision in Fisher v. University...
Fisher v. UT–Austin and the Future of Racial Preferences in College Admissions
Federalist Society Review, Volume 17, Issue 2
Note from the Editor: This article discusses the Supreme Court’s recent decision in Fisher v. University...
A Conflict of Principles: The Battle Over Affirmative Action at the University of Michigan
Engage Volume 16, Issue 3
Carl Cohen's book, A Conflict of Principles: The Battle Over Affirmative Action at the University of...
A Conflict of Principles: The Battle Over Affirmative Action at the University of Michigan
Engage Volume 16, Issue 3
Note from the Editor: This book review discusses the contentious issue of affirmative action. The Federalist...
A Conflict of Principles: The Battle Over Affirmative Action at the University of Michigan
Engage Volume 16, Issue 3
Note from the Editor: This book review discusses the contentious issue of affirmative action. The Federalist...
Supreme Court Preview: Fisher
An "Honest" Affirmative Action Defense?
In the long running case of Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin, insufficient notice...
Supreme Court Preview: Fisher
An "Honest" Affirmative Action Defense?
In the long running case of Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin, insufficient notice...
Anecdotes as Evidence: Proving Public Contracting Discrimination in a Strict Scrutiny World
Engage Volume 16, Issue 2
Note from the Editor: This article is about the use of anecdotal evidence to justify...
Anecdotes as Evidence: Proving Public Contracting Discrimination in a Strict Scrutiny World
Engage Volume 16, Issue 2
Note from the Editor: This article is about the use of anecdotal evidence to justify...
College Admissions and Affirmative Action - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
The battle over the use of affirmative action in college admissions seems far from over,...
Panel II: Racial Preferences and Promoting Diversity: Are These Policies Taking Us in the Right Direction?
Civil Rights in the United States
The Obama administration is widely perceived to be an avid proponent of racial preferences. As...
The Twilight of Race-Based Preferences in College Admissions
Michigan Lawyers Chapter
The Michigan Lawyers Chapter hosted this event on February 12, 2014, at Thomas M. Cooley...
Schuette v. Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action Oral Argument Courthouse Steps - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
On Tuesday, October 15, the Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Schuette v. Coalition to Defend...
Schuette v. Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action Oral Argument Courthouse Steps - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
On Tuesday, October 15, the Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Schuette v. Coalition to Defend...
Supreme Court Update: Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
The affirmative action case, Fisher v. University of Texas, was decided, 7-1, by the U.S....
2013 Annual Supreme Court Round Up
Washington, DC Lawyers Chapter
On July 8, 2013, Miguel Estrada of Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP delivered the Annual Supreme...
Fisher v. University of Texas - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 6-25-13 featuring Gail Heriot and Peter Kirsanow
On June 24, 2013 the Supreme Court announced its decision in Fisher v. University of...
Fisher v. University of Texas: Affirmative Action Revisited by the Supreme Court - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
Fisher v. University of Texas is being heralded as the blockbuster case of this year’s...
Affirmative Action for Men? Strange Silences and Strange Bedfellows in the Public Debate over Discrimination Against Women in College Admissions
Engage Volume 12, Issue 3, November 2011
While some news reports indicate that discrimination against women on the basis of sex1 in...
Civil Rights: Affirmative Action in the Obama Era
2009 National Lawyers Convention
Ms. Shirley J. Wilcher, Executive Director, American Association for Affirmative Action Prof. Theodore M. Shaw,...
Free Speech & Election Law: Freedom of Speech vs. Anti-Discrimination Laws
2008 National Lawyers Convention
An employer is sued for hostile work environment harassment because it doesn't stop its employees...
Barwatch Bulletin for February 9, 2008
February 9, 2008
ABA President Bill Neukom Press Conference ABA President Bill Neukom hosted a press conference on...
Barwatch Bulletin for February 9, 2008
February 9, 2008
ABA President Bill Neukom Press Conference ABA President Bill Neukom hosted a press conference on...
Panel IV: Tradition and the People's Constitution
2008 Annual Student Symposium
The Federalist Society's Student Division presented this panel at the 2008 Annual Student Symposium on...
SCOTUScast 6-29-07 featuring Gail Heriot
Parents Involved in Community Schools v. Seattle School District No. 1 and Meredith v. Jefferson County
On June 28, 2007, the U.S. Supreme Court delivered its decision on Parents Involved in...
Sordid Business: The Supreme Court Confronts the Constitutionality of Racial Preferences in K-12 Education
It is a sordid business, this divvying us up by race.—Chief Justice Roberts The...
Sordid Business: The Supreme Court Confronts the Constitutionality of Racial Preferences in K-12 Education
It is a sordid business, this divvying us up by race.—Chief Justice Roberts The...
A Roadmap for the Continuing Legal Challenge to Race-Based Admissions
The higher education establishment breathed a sigh of relief in June when the Supreme Court’s...
Gender Based Board Quotas, the Fourteenth Amendment, and Meland v. Weber
In-House Counsel Working Group, Civil Rights Practice Group, and Regulatory Transparency Project Teleforum
TeleforumRace Preferences After Grutter
The City Club of Cleveland 850 Euclid Ave., Second FloorCleveland, 44115