Facts of the Case
Carol Anne Bond worked for the chemical manufacturer Rohm and Haas. When she learned that her friend Myrlinda Haynes was pregnant and that Bond's husband was the father, she used her connections with the chemical company to obtain the means for revenge. She stole and purchased highly toxic chemicals that she applied to Haynes' doorknobs, car door handles, and mailbox. Haynes suffered a minor burn, and after contacting a federal investigator, Bond was identified as the perpetrator. She was charged with several violations of the Chemical Weapons Convention Implementation Act of 1998 (Act).
In the district court, Bond moved to dismiss the case and argued that Congress did not have the authority to enforce the Act because it subverted states' rights in violation of the Tenth Amendment. The district court denied the motion, and Bond conditionally pled guilty with the understanding that she could continue to appeal the decision regarding the validity of the Act. She was sentenced to six years in prison. Bond renewed her challenge to the Act in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, which held that Bond did not have standing to appeal. The U.S. Supreme Court reversed the decision and held that the case must be considered on its merits. The case was remanded back to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 3d Circuit. The Court of Appeals held that the Act was within Congress' power to enact and enforce.
Questions
Does Congress have the authority to enact legislation that enforces a treaty but goes beyond the scope of the treaty and intrudes on traditional state prerogatives?
Can the Chemical Weapons Convention Implementation Act be properly interpreted so that it does not apply to ordinary poisoning cases, which have been traditionally handled by state and local authorities?
Conclusions
-
No, yes. Chief Justice John G. Roberts, Jr. delivered the opinion for the 6-3 majority. The Court held that federal law typically does not intrude on the ability of states to regulate local matters, and the Chemical Weapons Convention Implementation Act is not an exception to that general rule. While Congress has the authority to create legislation to enforce treaties, it must do so while respecting the traditional division of sovereign responsibility between the federal government and the states. The Court also held that it is incumbent upon the courts to be sure of Congress' intent before ruling based on such a rationale; in this case, because there is no evidence that Congress intended the statute to have expansive powers, it must be read more narrowly. In fact, the language of the statute suggests that the facts of this case do not match the types of situations the statute was enacted to govern.
Justice Antonin Scalia wrote an opinion concurring in the judgment in which he argued that, in determining whether the Chemical Weapons Convention Implementation Act covers Bond's actions, the majority opinion overstepped its bounds and performed Congress' duty. Justice Scalia also wrote that it was clear from the wording of the statute that Bond's actions were covered, and the majority opinion's interpretation of the statute made it so broad as to be unintelligible. However, the statute was unconstitutional because it infringed on the rights of the states. Justice Clarence Thomas and Justice Samuel A. Alito, Jr. joined in the opinion concurring in the judgment. In his separate opinion concurring in the judgment, Justice Thomas wrote that, while Congress has the power to create laws that enforce treaties, that power does not extend to the enforcement of laws that would infringe on states' rights. The historical context of this "Treaty Power" indicates that it was meant to be limited to international affairs and not interfere with the constitutional structure of federal and state power. Justice Scalia and Justice Alito joined in the concurrence in judgment. Justice Alito also wrote a separate opinion concurring in the judgment in which he argued that the statute went beyond Congress' power to enforce treaties and is therefore unconstitutional.
Is the Corporate Transparency Act Unconstitutional?: Government Appeals a District Court Ruling That Said “Yes,” With More Challenges In Progress
On March 1, 2024, Judge Liles Burke in the Northern District of Alabama held in...
Courthouse Steps Decision: Sackett v. Environmental Protection Agency
Join us for a special in-person event at Hunton Andrews Kurth on Sackett v. EPA.
Sponsors: Environmental Law & Property Rights Practice GroupDC Young Lawyers ChapterHunton Andrews Kurth LLP Where:Hunton...
Principles of State Constitutional Interpretation
Federalist Society Review, Volume 23
State constitutionalism—the practice of state courts deciding cases on independent state constitutional grounds—is a vital...
Principles of State Constitutional Interpretation
Federalist Society Review, Volume 23
State constitutionalism—the practice of state courts deciding cases on independent state constitutional grounds—is a vital...
Is There a Constitutional Issue in the USMCA?
Some argue that the United States Mexico Canada Agreement (USMCA) presents interesting questions about how...
Showcase Panel I: Justice Scalia: Text Over Intent and the Demise of Legislative History
2016 National Lawyers Convention
Until 1986, most conservative lawyers favored following the original intentions of the Framers of the...
Clean Power Plan Oral Argument Recap - Podcast
Environmental Law & Property Rights Practice Group Podcast
On Tuesday, September 27, the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals heard en banc West Virginia...
Clean Power Plan Litigation Update - Podcast
Environmental Law & Property Rights Practice Group Podcast
On Tuesday, September 27, the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals will hear West Virginia v....
Supreme Court Preview: Newman
Insider Trading: the Headless Monster
On Monday, October 5, the Supreme Court declined to wade into the issue of what...
Affordable Care Act Case Decided: King v. Burwell - Podcast
Administrative Law & Regulation Practice Group Podcast
On June 25 the Supreme Court held that Affordable Care Act subsidies are available to...
Does EPA’s Clean Power Plan Proposal Violate the States’ Sovereign Rights?
Engage Volume 16, Issue 1
Note from the Editor: This article discusses the Environmental Protection Agency’s Clean Power Plan under...
Does EPA’s Clean Power Plan Proposal Violate the States’ Sovereign Rights?
Engage Volume 16, Issue 1
Note from the Editor: This article discusses the Environmental Protection Agency’s Clean Power Plan under...
Whitfield v. United States - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 4-3-15 featuring John Stinneford
On January 13, 2015, the Supreme Court issued its decision in Whitfield v. United States....
Texas Department of Housing and Community Affairs v. The Inclusive Communities Project - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
Post-Argument SCOTUScast featuring Todd Gaziano
On January 21, 2015, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Texas Department of Housing...
Disparate Impact Liability and the Fair Housing Act: Texas Department of Housing and Community Affairs v. The Inclusive Communities Project, Inc. - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
On Wednesday, January 21, 2015, the Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Texas Department of...
Whitfield v. United States - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 1-13-15 featuring John Stinneford
On December 2, 2014, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Whitfield v. United States....
Panel II: The Administrative State: Within the Bounds of Law?
17th Annual Faculty Conference
This panel was part of the 17th Annual Federalist Society Faculty Conference held on January...
Bank Robbery and Kidnapping -- Whitfield v. United States - Podcast
Criminal Law & Procedure Practice Group Podcast
In 2008, Larry Whitfield attempted to rob a credit union. In the aftermath of the...
Something Fishy in Sarbanes-Oxley? Yates v. United States - Podcast
Criminal Law & Procedure Practice Group Podcast
At issue in Yates v. United States is the "anti-shredding" provision of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act...
Supreme Court Preview: What Is in Store for October Term 2014?
Co-Sponsored by the Faculty Division and the Practice Groups
October 6th will mark the first day of the 2014 Supreme Court term. Thus far, the...
2014 Annual Supreme Court Round Up
Washington, DC Lawyers Chapter
On July 18, 2014, Thomas Hungar of Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP and Noel Francisco of Jones Day delivered the...
Loughrin v. United States - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 7-15-14 featuring Todd Braunstein
On June 23, 2014, the Supreme Court issued its decision in Loughrin v. United States....
Bond v. United States - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 6-11-14 featuring Nicholas Quinn Rosenkranz
On June 2, 2014, the Supreme Court decided Bond v. United States. The question in...
Bond v. United States - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 6-11-14 featuring Nicholas Quinn Rosenkranz
On June 2, 2014, the Supreme Court decided Bond v. United States. The question in...
Bond v. U.S. Decided - Podcast
Environmental Law & Property Rights and Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Groups Podcast
On June 2, 2014, the U.S. Supreme Court decided Bond v. U.S. The Court did...
Newly Proposed CO2 Rules - Podcast
Environmental Law & Property Rights Practice Group Podcast
In an effort to address air pollution and global warming, on June 2, 2014, the...
Panel II: Detained Suspected Terrorists: Try in Military Courts or Civilian Courts?
2014 National Student Symposium
This panel will address the ongoing debate regarding trying, convicting and punishing suspected terrorists. Should...
US v. Bond: Expanding Congress' Power? - Podcast
Criminal Law & Procedure, Federalism & Separation of Powers, and International & National Security Law Practice Groups Courthouse Steps Podcast
Do the Constitution’s structural limits on federal authority impose constraints on the scope of Congress’...
Bond v. United States - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 11-08-13 featuring Nicholas Quinn Rosenkranz
On November 5, 2013, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Bond v. United States....
Bond v. United States - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 11-08-13 featuring Nicholas Quinn Rosenkranz
On November 5, 2013, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Bond v. United States....
Supreme Court Preview: What Is in Store for October Term 2013?
Co-sponsored by the Practice Groups and the Faculty Division
October 7th will mark the first day of the 2013 Supreme Court term. Thus far,...
Supreme Court Preview: What Is in Store for October Term 2013?
Co-sponsored by the Practice Groups and the Faculty Division
October 7th will mark the first day of the 2013 Supreme Court term. Thus far,...
Sleeping Giant?: Section Two of the Thirteenth Amendment, Hate Crimes Legislation, and Academia’s Favorite New Vehicle for the Expansion of Federal Power
Engage Volume 13, Issue 3 October 2012
A brief look at the Thirteenth Amendment might suggest that it has rather limited application...
Luncheon Debate: Resolved: Congress's Enumerated Powers Cannot be Increased by Treaty
15th Annual Faculty Conference
The Federalist Society's Facutly Division hosted this debate on Saturday, January 5, 2013, during the 15th...
Showcase Panel I: Federalism and Federal Power
2012 National Lawyers Convention
The Rehnquist Court was famous for its resuscitation of some fairly modest constitutional limits on...
Supreme Court Preview: What Is in Store for October Term 2012?
Co-sponsored by the Practice Groups, the Washington DC Lawyers Chapter, and the Faculty Division
October 1st marks the first day of the 2012 Supreme Court Term. Thus far the...
The States and the NLRB: A Study in Comparative Sovereignty
Engage Volume 12, Issue 3, November 2011
Under a system of government that diffuses power and makes institutional “[a]mbition . . ....
The States and the NLRB: A Study in Comparative Sovereignty
Engage Volume 12, Issue 3, November 2011
Under a system of government that diffuses power and makes institutional “[a]mbition . . ....
Bond v. United States - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 07-28-11 featuring John C. Eastman
On June 16, 2011, the Supreme Court announced its decision in Bond v. United States....