Facts of the Case
In 1994, while enrolled at Virginia Polytechnic Institute (Virginia Tech), Christy Brzonkala alleged that Antonio Morrison and James Crawford, both students and varsity football players at Virginia Tech, raped her. In 1995, Brzonkala filed a complaint against Morrison and Crawford under Virginia Tech's Sexual Assault Policy. After a hearing, Morrison was found guilty of sexual assault and sentenced to immediate suspension for two semesters. Crawford was not punished. A second hearing again found Morrison guilty. After an appeal through the university's administrative system, Morrison's punishment was set aside, as it was found to be "excessive." Ultimately, Brzonkala dropped out of the university. Brzonkala then sued Morrison, Crawford, and Virginia Tech in Federal District Court, alleging that Morrison's and Crawford's attack violated 42 USC section 13981, part of the Violence Against Women Act of 1994 (VAWA), which provides a federal civil remedy for the victims of gender-motivated violence. Morrison and Crawford moved to dismiss Brzonkala's suit on the ground that section 13981's civil remedy was unconstitutional. In dismissing the complaint, the District Court found that that Congress lacked authority to enact section 13981 under either the Commerce Clause or the Fourteenth Amendment, which Congress had explicitly identified as the sources of federal authority for it. Ultimately, the Court of Appeals affirmed.
Questions
Does Congress have the authority to enact the Violence Against Women Act of 1994 under either the Commerce Clause or Fourteenth Amendment?
Conclusions
-
No. In a 5-4 opinion delivered by Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist, the Court held that Congress lacked the authority to enact a statute under the Commerce Clause or the Fourteenth Amendment since the statute did not regulate an activity that substantially affected interstate commerce nor did it redress harm caused by the state. Chief Justice Rehnquist wrote for the Court that [i]f the allegations here are true, no civilized system of justice could fail to provide [Brzonkala] a remedy for the conduct of...Morrison. But under our federal system that remedy must be provided by the Commonwealth of Virginia, and not by the United States." Dissenting, Justice Stephen G. Breyer argued that the majority opinion "illustrates the difficulty of finding a workable judicial Commerce Clause touchstone." Additionally, Justice David H. Souter, dissenting, noted that VAWA contained a "mountain of data assembled by Congress...showing the effects of violence against women on interstate commerce."
Panel V: Is Judicial Review Democratic?
2023 National Student Symposium
Judicial Review has been criticized throughout American history as undemocratic, creating what has been known...
Federal Government Orders Surrender of Personal Property Under . . . its Police Power?: Courts Grapple with Bump Stock Rule as a Fifth Amendment Taking
In December 2018, the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives (ATF) issued a rule...
Federal Liability Limitations for COVID-19 Exposure Claims
What are the constitutional or other limits on Congressional authority to limit lawsuits that seek...
Constitutionality of Proposed Federal Liability Limitations for COVID-19 Exposure Claims
By Michael A. Carvin & Yaakov M. Roth Over the past weeks, the COVID-19 pandemic...
Party Like It’s 1935?: Gundy v. United States and the Future of the Non-Delegation Doctrine
Federalist Society Review, Volume 19
Note from the Editor: This article discusses Gundy v. United States, a case involving the...
Showcase Panel IV: Administrative Agencies and the Separation of Powers
2017 National Lawyers Convention
This panel will examine the history of the emergence of the Administrative State and will...
Warning to Corporate Counsel: If State AGs Can Do This to ExxonMobil, How Safe Is Your Company? - Podcast
Corporations, Securities, & Antitrust Practice Group Podcast
Nation-states have long fought wars for control of oil. In a novel development, American states...
The Legacy of Justice Scalia
2017 Annual Florida Chapters Conference
This panel, The Legacy of Justice Scalia, was held on February 3, 2017, at the...
Federalism & Separation of Powers: Justice Scalia on Federalism and Separation of Powers
2016 National Lawyers Convention
Justice Scalia often said that, while he always tried to get the Bill of Rights...
Political Correctness on Campus
Stanford Intellectual Diversity Conference
Political correctness in the classroom can be seen as a consequence of a lack of...
People for the Ethical Treatment of Property Owners v. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service: Did Gonzalez v. Raich Eviscerate All Constitutional Limits on Federal Power?
Engage Volume 17, Issue 1
Note from the Editor: This article discusses an ongoing case questioning the constitutionality of the...
Bond v. U.S. Decided - Podcast
Environmental Law & Property Rights and Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Groups Podcast
On June 2, 2014, the U.S. Supreme Court decided Bond v. U.S. The Court did...
Sixth Annual Rosenkranz Debate and Luncheon
2013 National Lawyers Convention
RESOLVED: Courts are too Deferential to the Legislature The Sixth Annual Rosenkranz Debate was held...
The “Mens Rea” Component Within the Issue of the Over-Federalization of Crime
Engage Volume 14, Issue 2 July 2013
Introduction After decades of hastily passing federal criminal laws, the U.S. House of Representatives, through...
Sleeping Giant?: Section Two of the Thirteenth Amendment, Hate Crimes Legislation, and Academia’s Favorite New Vehicle for the Expansion of Federal Power
Engage Volume 13, Issue 3 October 2012
A brief look at the Thirteenth Amendment might suggest that it has rather limited application...
Address by Senator Mike Lee
2012 National Lawyers Convention
Senator Mike Lee of Utah addressed attendees of the Federalist Society's 2012 National Lawyers Convention...
Upon Further Reflection: The Health Care Decision - Podcast
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group Podcast
With several weeks' time to reflect on the U.S. Supreme Court's health care case, Professor...
Obamacare in the Supreme Court
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group
The U.S. Supreme Court is now ready to hear oral argument in one of the...
Debate: The Constitutionality of the Affordable Care Act
2012 National Student Symposium
This debate will focus on the constitutionality of the Affordable Care Act. While specific attention...
Is the Affordable Care Act Constitutional?
Pennsylvania Student Chapter
On February 22, 2012, the University of Pennsylvania Student Chapter of the Federalist Society hosted...
Florida Constitutional Challenge to Obamacare: It All Comes Down to Broccoli
Engage Volume 12, Issue 3, November 2011
Note from the Editor: This paper provides an update on the litigation dealing with the...
Fourth Annual Rosenkranz Debate and Luncheon
2011 National Lawyers Convention
RESOLVED: Congress Acted Within Its Authority in Enacting the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act...
A Debate Over the Constitutionality of the Health Care Reform Act
Indianapolis Lawyers Chapter
On October 25, 2011, the Indianapolis Lawyers Chapter of the Federalist Society hosted a debate...
Panel III: The Welfare State and American Exceptionalism
2011 National Student Symposium
With the recent passage of President Barack Obama's health care legislation, it is time to...
Luncheon Debate: The Constitutionality of the Individual Mandate
13th Annual Faculty Conference
Prof. Randy E. Barnett, Georgetown University Law Center Prof. Orin S. Kerr, The George Washington...
Litigation: Debating the Constitutionality of the Federal Health Care Legislation
2010 National Lawyers Convention
Prof. Randy E. Barnett, Carmack Waterhouse Professor of Legal Theory, Georgetown University Law Center Hon....
Address by Senator-Elect Michael S. Lee
2010 National Lawyers Convention
Hon. Michael S. Lee, United States Senator-Elect, Utah Introduction: Mr. Leonard A. Leo, Executive Vice President,...
Panel 4 - Does the Originalism of the Fourteenth Amendment Guarantee Justice for All?
2010 National Student Symposium
Often, critics argue that originalism will trap us in the sins of societies past, doomed...
2010 Health Care Reform Legislation
Nashville Lawyers Chapter
The Nashville Lawyers Chapter hosted this panel discussion on "2010 Health Care Reform Legislation" at...
Individual Health Care Insurance Mandate Debate
Online Debate
Last Updated at 9 AM, Friday, November 6, 2009 This debate will focus on the following...
Constitutional Implications of an “Individual Mandate” in Health Care Reform
The Federalist Society takes no position on particular legal or public policy initiatives. Any expressions...
Federalism: The Roberts Court and Federalism
2008 National Lawyers Convention
Hon. Paul D. Clement, Former United States Solicitor General Hon. Walter E. Dellinger III, Duke...
Panel IV: Tradition and the People's Constitution
2008 Annual Student Symposium
The Federalist Society's Student Division presented this panel at the 2008 Annual Student Symposium on...
Fair-weather Federalism - Event Audio
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group
There is a longstanding debate on the appropriate division of power between the Federal Government...
The War on Terrorism: Law Enforcement or National Security?
George Terwilliger*Theodore Cooperstein**Shawn Gunnarson***Daniel Blumenthal****Robert Parker***** The horrific events of September 11th were immediately labeled...
Hot Topics: Judicial Activism
When President George W. Bush announced his first nominations for the federal bench, he declared,...