Facts of the Case
Clyde Reed, pastor of Good News Community Church (Good News), rented space at an elementary school in Gilbert, Arizona, and placed about 17 signs in the area announcing the time and location of Good News' services. Gilbert has an ordinance (Sign Code) that restricts the size, number, duration, and location of certain types of signs, including temporary directional ones, to prevent improper signage. After Good News received an advisory notice from Gilbert that it violated the Sign Code, Good News sued Gilbert and claimed that the Sign Code violated the Free Speech Clause of the First Amendment and the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.
The district court found that the Sign Code was constitutional since it was content-neutral and was reasonable in light of the government interests. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed and held that, even though an official would have to read a sign to determine what provisions of the Sign Code applied, the restrictions were not based on the content of the signs, and the Sign Code left open other channels of communication.
Questions
Does an ordinance restricting the size, number, duration, and location of temporary directional signs violate the Free Speech Clause of the First Amendment or the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment?
Conclusions
-
Yes. Justice Clarence Thomas wrote the opinion for the 9-0 majority. The Court held that the restrictions were subject to strict scrutiny because they were content-based restrictions, or restrictions that were applied differently depending on the message of the sign. Because these restrictions were content-based on their face, the Court need not examine justifications or the government’s motives in determining whether the restrictions are subject to strict scrutiny. Despite the Town of Gilbert’s argument that the restrictions do not single out a specific nonprofit or church but restrict all, the Court stated that the First Amendment prohibits censorship of all speech on a whole topic. The Court also held that the restrictions cannot survive strict scrutiny because they had no compelling interest in adding restrictions to only a certain type of sign.
In his concurring opinion, Justice Samuel A. Alito, Jr. wrote that this decision does not preclude towns from continuing to regulate signs, but it does stop them from restricting them in an unconstitutional manner. Justice Anthony M. Kennedy and Justice Sonia Sotomayor joined in the concurrence. Justice Stephen G. Breyer wrote a separate opinion concurring in the judgment in which he argued that content discrimination should have been the consideration and legal analysis, and that this case did not trigger strict scrutiny. The presumption against constitutionality is too strong to use automatically and was unnecessary in this case as there was another, more appropriate method of analysis available. In her separate opinion concurring in the judgment, Justice Elena Kagan wrote that constantly using strict scrutiny to judge government-regulated communication is too restrictive and would water down the meaning of strict scrutiny. The risk that the government will limit the public’s ability to debate ideas with these regulations is very low and does not warrant strict scrutiny. In this case, the restrictions were not brought on by any reason or need, and so they did not pass any level of scrutiny. Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Breyer joined in the concurrence in the judgment.
Courthouse Steps Decision: Chiles v. Salazar
Chiles v. Salazar addressed whether a Colorado law prohibiting “conversion therapy” violates the First...
Litigation Update: Kluge v. Brownsburg Community School Corporation
Where should the line be drawn in the debate between the rights of persons to...
Litigation Update: Mid Vermont Christian School v. Saunders
From the Olympics to San Jose State, each month we hear of new controversies where...
Addressing Antisemitism in Higher Education
In the wake of the October 7, 2023 terrorist attack in Israel, there have been...
Litigation Update: FCA v San Jose Unified School Dist.
Fellowship of Christian Athletes v. San Jose Unified School District concerned a Christian student club's...
Measuring and Evaluating Public Responses to Religious Rights Rulings
Federalist Society Review, Volume 23
The story of Jack Phillips and his cake shop—Masterpiece Cakeshop—is by now familiar. Jack Phillips...
Litigation Update: Volokh et al v. James
In early December, Prof. Eugene Volokh, Rumble Canada, and Locals Technology filed a complaint in...
Special Session II: Second Amendment: Aftermath of Bruen; What's Next at the State Level?
National Lawyers Convention 2022
In June 2022, the Supreme Court decided the much-anticipated case, New York State Rifle and...
Panel 3: Supreme Court Preview
Fifth Annual Kentucky Chapters Conference
This panel discussed the upcoming Supreme Court term, which began on October 4, 2021....
A Seat at the Sitting - November 2021
The November Docket in 90 Minutes or Less
Join us for the second episode of the Federalist Society’s Supreme Court Show: A Seat at...
Severability and Article III Powers
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group Teleforum
What should the Supreme Court do when it finds one provision of a statute unconstitutional? There is a...
Free Speech & Election Law: Rule of Law, or Just Making it Up? First Amendment Tiered Scrutiny
2020 National Lawyers Convention
On November 10, 2020, The Federalist Society's Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group hosted...
Courthouse Steps Decision: The Limits of Robocalls, Barr v. American Association of Political Consultants, Inc.
In Barr v. American Association of Political Consultants, Inc., the Supreme Court held unconstitutional a...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: Barr v. American Association of Political Consultants Inc.
The oral argument for this case will be held on May 6, 2020. At issue...
Citizens’ Secret Recording and the First Amendment
For over half a century, federal law and most states have regulated secretly recording speech...
Minnesota Voters Alliance v. Mansky Strikes Down a Vague Ban on Speech in Polling Places, But Future Bans May Be Upheld
Federalist Society Review, Volume 19
Note from the Editor: This article discusses the Supreme Court’s opinion in Minnesota Voters Alliance...
ABA Model Rule 8.4(g) Cannot Survive the Supreme Court’s Recent Decisions in NIFLA and Matal
The United States Supreme Court’s decision eight weeks ago in National Institute of Family and...
Courthouse Steps: NIFLA v. Becerra Decided
Religious Liberties and Free Speech & Election Law Practice Groups Teleforum
NIFLA is a religiously-affiliated pro-life pregnancy clinic that sought to enjoin the California Reproductive Freedom,...
Off-Label Promotion and Free Speech in Medicine
Regulatory Transparency Project Teleforum
Federal regulation strictly limits how pharmaceutical companies share information about the legal use of their...
ABA Watch: Unconstitutional and Blatantly Political, Model Rule 8.4(g)
In 2016 the American Bar Association added new Rule 8.4(g) to its Model Rules of...
Deep Dive Episode 4 – "Uber of the Sky": The Story of Flytenow
Regulatory Transparency Project Teleforum
Flytenow was a ridesharing platform for small planes. The company was founded by two pilots,...
Debate—State Blaine Amendments
2017 Annual Western Chapters Conference
The Supreme Court has agreed to hear oral arguments in Trinity Lutheran Church of Columbia, Inc. v....
Free Speech & Election Law: Originalism and the First Amendment
2016 National Lawyers Convention
Has Originalism played a significant role in the Supreme Court's free speech jurisprudence? One scholar...
Ballot Selfies are Free Speech - Podcast
Free Speech and Election Law Practice Group Podcast
On Wednesday, September 28, the First Circuit Court of Appeals decided Rideout v. Gardner, the...
Sign Crimes
Violating recent Supreme Court precedent, cities are punishing advertisers based on the content of their speech
Entrepreneurs wishing to advertise new products or services are often thwarted by local ordinances that...
Redskins Trademark in Court, and More - Podcast
Litigation Practice Group Podcast
Can the government police speech it thinks is offensive? The Lanham Act allows the government...
2015 Annual Supreme Court Round Up
Washington, DC Lawyers Chapter
On July 10, 2015, Miguel Estrada of Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP delivered the Annual Supreme Court Round...
The Court Speaks on Free Speech - Podcast
Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group Podcast
On Jun 18, the U.S. Supreme Court decided two cases with free speech implications. In...
The Court Speaks on Free Speech - Podcast
Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group Podcast
On Jun 18, the U.S. Supreme Court decided two cases with free speech implications. In...
Walker v. Texas Division, Sons of Confederate Veterans, Inc and Reed v. Town of Gilbert - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 6-23-15 featuring Eugene Volokh.
On June 18, 2015, the Supreme Court issued two highly anticipated decisions in free speech...
Walker v. Texas Division, Sons of Confederate Veterans, Inc and Reed v. Town of Gilbert - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 6-23-15 featuring Eugene Volokh.
On June 18, 2015, the Supreme Court issued two highly anticipated decisions in free speech...
SCOTUS Opinions: 6/18/2015
(1) Brumfield v. Cain: By a vote of 5-4 the judgment of the Fifth Circuit...
Holt v. Hobbs - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 2-4-15 featuring Jordan Lorence
On January 20, 2015, the Supreme Court issued its decision in Holt v. Hobbs, which...
Reed v. Town of Gilbert, Arizona - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 1-15-15 featuring Hans von Spakovsky
On January 12, 2015, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Reed v. Town of...
Reed v. Town of Gilbert, Arizona - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 1-15-15 featuring Hans von Spakovsky
On January 12, 2015, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Reed v. Town of...
A Sign of Things to Come?: Reed v. Town of Gilbert - Podcast
Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group Podcast
On January 12, 2015, the U.S. Supreme Court heard oral argument in Reed v. Town...
A Sign of Things to Come?: Reed v. Town of Gilbert - Podcast
Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group Podcast
On January 12, 2015, the U.S. Supreme Court heard oral argument in Reed v. Town...
Coming Soon to a School Near You?: Common Core - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
The Common Core State Standards attempts to define what K-12 students should know at the...
College Admissions and Affirmative Action - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
The battle over the use of affirmative action in college admissions seems far from over,...
Prisoner Beards and Religious Freedom: Holt v. Hobbs - Podcast
Religious Liberties Practice Group Podcast
The Supreme Court will rule on the religious liberty rights of prisoners in one of...
Supreme Court October Term 2014 Preview - Podcast
Practice Groups Courthouse Steps Podcast
A panel of notable constitutional experts discussed the likely highlights, including the denial of cert...