Facts of the Case
In early 2002, a many years-long effort by Senators John McCain and Russell Feingold to reform the way that money is raised for--and spent during-- political campaigns culminated in the passage of the Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act of 2002 (the so-called McCain-Feingold bill sometimes referred to as BCRA). Its key provisions were a) a ban on unrestricted ("soft money") donations made directly to political parties (often by corporations, unions, or wealthy individuals) and on the solicitation of those donations by elected officials; b) limits on the advertising that unions, corporations, and non-profit organizations can engage in up to 60 days prior to an election; and c) restrictions on political parties' use of their funds for advertising on behalf of candidates (in the form of "issue ads" or "coordinated expenditures").
The campaign finance reform bill contained an unusual provision providing for an early federal trial and a direct appeal to the Supreme Court of the United States, by-passing the typical federal judicial process. In May a special three-judge panel struck down portions of the Campaign Finance Reform Act's ban on soft-money donations but upheld some of the Act's restrictions on the kind of advertising that parties can engage in. The ruling was stayed until the Supreme Court could hear and decide the resulting appeals.
Questions
Does the "soft money" ban of the Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act of 2002 exceed Congress's authority to regulate elections under Article 1, Section 4 of the United States Constitution and/or violate the First Amendment's protection of the freedom to speak?
Do regulations of the source, content, or timing of political advertising in the Campaign Finance Reform Act of 2002 violate the First Amendment's free speech clause?
Conclusions
-
With a few exceptions, the Court answered "no" to both questions in a 5-to-4 decision written by Justices Sandra Day O'Connor and John Paul Stevens. Because the regulations dealt mostly with soft-money contributions that were used to register voters and increase attendance at the polls, not with campaign expenditures (which are more explicitly a statement of political values and therefore deserve more protection), the Court held that the restriction on free speech was minimal. It then found that the restriction was justified by the government's legitimate interest in preventing "both the actual corruption threatened by large financial contributions and... the appearance of corruption" that might result from those contributions.
In response to challenges that the law was too broad and unnecessarily regulated conduct that had not been shown to cause corruption (such as advertisements paid for by corporations or unions), the Court found that such regulation was necessary to prevent the groups from circumventing the law. Justices O'Connor and Stevens wrote that "money, like water, will always find an outlet" and that the government was therefore justified in taking steps to prevent schemes developed to get around the contribution limits.
The Court also rejected the argument that Congress had exceeded its authority to regulate elections under Article I, Section 4 of the Constitution. The Court found that the law only affected state elections in which federal candidates were involved and also that it did not prevent states from creating separate election laws for state and local elections.
[In total, the Court addressed 21 sections of federal law. We have distilled these disparate components into 12 separate votes which we detail at the end of this document.]
Practice Groups: The Continued Independence of the Judiciary
2024 National Lawyers Convention
Recent times have seen growing criticism of the Supreme Court's legitimacy, with some claiming that...
Panel 2: The Challenge of Citizens United
How did corporate rights evolve to include expressive constitutional rights akin to those of a...
Litigation Update: FEC v. Cruz for Senate
On January 19, 2022, the United States Supreme Court will hear an appeal by the Federal...
Private Power and Eminent Domain
2021 National Lawyers Convention
The 2021 National Lawyers Convention took place November 11-13, 2021 at the Mayflower Hotel in...
Keynote Address by Judge Janice Rogers Brown
2021 Ohio Lawyers Chapters Conference
On May 7, 2021, the Federalist Society's Ohio lawyers chapters hosted the 2021 Ohio Chapters...
Panel Three: Election Issues Roundtable
2019 Texas Chapters Conference
On September 14, 2019, The Federalist Society held a roundtable on election issues during its...
Supreme Court Review: Justice Gorsuch at Year One
2018 Texas Chapters Conference
On September 7-8, 2018, the Federalist Society's Fort Worth Lawyers Chapter hosted the fourth annual...
Panel 2: Campaign Finance and Free Speech
2017 National Student Symposium
Congress' passage of the Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act of 2002 did not end the debate...
Showcase Panel IV: ROUNDTABLE: Areas of Constitutional Doctrine Transformed
2016 National Lawyers Convention
The final Showcase panel examines Justice Scalia's transformation of five very important areas of Supreme...
Administrative Law & Regulation: The Evolution of Justice Scalia's Views on Administrative Law
2016 National Lawyers Convention
For all of his many contributions to modern American jurisprudence, no area of law bears...
Book Review: The Intimidation Game
Federalist Society Review, Volume 17, Issue 2
Note from the Editor: This article favorably reviews Kimberley Strassel’s new book about efforts by...
Supreme Court to Consider Honest-Services Fraud: Oral Arguments Heard in Robert F. McDonnell v. United States - Podcast
Criminal Law & Procedure and Free Speech & Election Law Practice Groups Podcast
On Wednesday, April 27, the United States Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Robert F....
Banquet Keynote Address by Paul Clement
2016 National Student Symposium
After nearly 30 years of serving as an intellectual titan and conservative champion on the...
Free Speech: A Right to Speak Anonymously? Political Contributors and Reporters’ Confidential Sources
2015 National Lawyers Convention
Supporters of mandated disclosure of the source of speech (or of money used to pay...
Litigation: Ten Years of the Roberts Court
2015 National Lawyers Convention
It has been ten years since John Roberts was appointed as the 17th Chief Justice...
Crime and Politics: Wisconsin Supreme Court Rules in "John Doe" Investigation - Podcast
Criminal Law & Procedure Practice Group Podcast
On Thursday July 16, 2015, the Wisconsin Supreme Court issued an opinion and order ending...
How First Amendment Procedures Protect First Amendment Substance
2014 National Lawyers Convention
While the substance of constitutional rights is always important, it is often the procedures surrounding...
Are Major Changes in Compelled Speech Coming? Conflict Minerals, Meat Labeling, and More - Podcast
Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group Podcast
Corporations’ First Amendment rights have been litigated frequently. One area of interest in the Circuit...
The Internal Revenue Service
Second Annual Executive Branch Review Conference
The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) is in the headlines almost daily. This panel will discuss...
Closing Panel: The Electorate and the Courts
2013 National Lawyers Convention
The Federalist Society's Practice Groups presented this panel on "The Electorate and the Courts" on...
Criminal Law: Criminal Law Enforcement versus the Free Press
2013 National Lawyers Convention
What are the First Amendment rights of press in the context of criminal investigations, and...
Showcase Panel I: Textualism and the Bill of Rights
2013 National Lawyers Convention
The new textualism has had a big impact on interpretation of the Bill of Rights....
ABA House of Delegates Considers Policies on Religious Profiling, SLAPPs, and Campaign Finance
ABA Watch August 2012
Religious Profiling The Section of Individual Rights and Responsibilities Criminal Justice Section has proposed Recommendation...
How the Supreme Court Has Subverted the Constitution
Las Vegas Lawyers Chapter
The Supreme Court has endorsed an exponential growth in federal government power, often at the...
Illuminating Citizens United: What the Decision Really Did
Engage Volume 12, Issue 3, November 2011
In January 2010, the U.S. Supreme Court issued one of its most controversial decisions in...
Fourth Annual Rosenkranz Debate and Luncheon
2011 National Lawyers Convention
RESOLVED: Congress Acted Within Its Authority in Enacting the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act...
Free Speech: Anonymity and The First Amendment
2010 National Lawyers Convention
Prof. Lloyd Hitoshi Mayer, University of Notre Dame Law School Hon. A. Raymond Randolph, United...
2010 Annual Supreme Court Round Up
Washington, DC Lawyers Chapter
On July 9, 2010, former United States Solicitor General Gregory G. Garre delivered the Annual...
Panel 3 - Originalism, Precedent and Judicial Restraint
2010 National Student Symposium
We often hear much about the perils of “judicial activism” and how a judge’s proper...
Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission – Post-Decision Debate SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 01-22-10 featuring Edward B. Foley, Erik S. Jaffe, & Bradley A. Smith
On January 21, 2009, the Supreme Court announced its decision in Citizens United v. FEC. ...
Supreme Court October Term 2009: What Is in Store?
October 5th marks the first day of the 2009 Supreme Court term. Thus far the...
Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission – Post-Re-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 09-10-09 featuring James Bopp, Jr.
On September 9th, 2009, the Supreme Court heard re-argument in Citizens United v. Federal Election...
2009 Annual Supreme Court Round Up
Washington, DC Lawyers Chapter
On July 10, 2009, former United States Solicitor General Theodore B. Olson delivered the Annual...
Showcase Panel III: Second Look Doctrines: Should Congress be Empowered to Override the Court? Should Voters in State Initiatives and Referenda be Able to Override State Supreme Courts?
2008 National Lawyers Convention
Some scholars have praised Canada, Britain, and Israel for having a form of judicial review...
Litigation: Civil Litigation under the Roberts Court
2008 National Lawyers Convention
The Roberts Court -- is it pro-business? Many Court watchers say so. But, whether pro-business...
Election Finance and 527s
2008 Election Law Conference
On October 7, 2008, the Federalist Society presented the 2008 Election Law Conference. This panel will...
SCOTUScast 6-26-08 featuring Ben Ginsberg
Davis v. Federal Election Commission
On June 26, 2008, the Supreme Court decided Davis v. Federal Election Commission, holding that...
SCOTUS term
Online Debate
On June 28, 2007, the Supreme Court handed down its last decisions of the Spring...
SCOTUScast 6-30-07 featuring Donald J. Simon
Federal Election Commission v. Wisconsin Right to Life, Inc.
On June 25, 2007, the U.S. Supreme Court delivered its decision on the Federal Election...
SCOTUScast 5-1-07 featuring James Bopp, Jr. and Donald J. Simon
Wisconsin Right to Life v. the Federal Election Commission
On April 25, 2007, the U.S. Supreme Court heard oral arguments in the Wisconsin Right...
Public Financing of Campaigns - Event Audio
Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group
With the federal government and most states restricting individual, corporate, and union contributions to campaigns,...
Lunch with Paul Clement
Wrigley Mansion 2501 East Telawa TrailPhoenix, 85016