Facts of the Case
The Securities and Exchange Commission (“Commission”) commenced an administrative enforcement action against Raymond J. Lucia and Raymond J. Lucia Companies, Inc. (collectively “Petitioners”) for alleged anti-fraud violations of the Investment Advisers Act arising from the way they presented their retirement wealth management strategy to prospective clients. An administrative law judge (“ALJ”) found liability and imposed sanctions including a lifetime industry bar against Petitioners. The Commission granted the parties’ petitions for review, and found that Petitioners had committed anti-fraud violations and imposed the same sanctions as the ALJ. The Commission also rejected the argument that the administrative proceedings had been unconstitutional because the ALJ who handed down the initial decision was a constitutional Officer who had not been appointed pursuant to the Appointments Clause under Article II, Section 2, Clause 2 of the Constitution.
Petitioners asked the D.C. Circuit to vacate the Commission’s decision and order under review on the grounds that the ALJ who made the administrative ruling was a constitutional Officer who had not been appointed in accordance with the Appointments Clause. The appeals court rejected this argument, explaining that Commission ALJs were not constitutional Officers within the meaning of the Appointments Clause, primarily because of their lack of authority to issue final decisions on behalf of the Commission pursuant to the agency’s regulatory scheme.
Questions
Are administrative law judges of the Securities and Exchange Commission Officers of the United States within the meaning of the Appointments Clause?
Conclusions
-
In a 7-2 opinion, the Court reversed and remanded, holding that administrative law judges of the Securities and Exchange Commission are “officers of the United States” subject to the Constitution’s Appointments Clause.
In an opinion authored by Justice Kagan, the Court began by stating that under its precedent, as established in United States v. Germaine, 99 U.S. 508 (1879), and Buckley v. Valeo, 424 U.S. 1 (1976), to be classified as an officer rather than an employee, a person needs to have a “continuing” position established by law, and must “exercis[e] significant authority pursuant to the laws of the United States.” It went on to explain that the factors in Freytag v. Commissioner, 501 U.S. 868 (1991), the case directly governing the instant matter, matched up almost exactly to the elements in Lucia’s case.
In Freytag, the Court ruled that U.S. Tax Court “special trial judges” (STJs) were officers because they met the elements required under Germaine and Buckley, and because they had significant discretion in addition to considerable responsibilities in presiding over administrative proceedings. These responsibilities included “tak[ing] testimony, conduct[ing] trials, rul[ing] on the admissibility of evidence, and hav[ing] the power to enforce compliance with discovery orders.” The Court reasoned that the SEC’s ALJs, like the STJs in Freytag, held a continuing office established by law, and exercised the same degree of discretion when carrying out the same functions as the STJs. But in contrast with the Tax Court STJs, whose decisions were always required to be reviewed by a regular Tax Court judge, the SEC ALJs’ decisions were not always subject to review; if the SEC decided against review then the ALJ’s decision would become final and be “deemed the action of the Commission.” As such, the SEC ALJs were officers of the United States subject to the Appointments Clause.
In light of this conclusion, because Lucia had made a timely challenge in his case to the constitutional validity of the ALJ’s appointment, he was entitled to a new hearing before a properly appointed official.
Justice Thomas filed a concurring opinion, in which Justice Gorsuch joined.
Justice Breyer filed an opinion concurring in the judgment in part and dissenting in part, and was joined by Justices Ginsburg and Sotomayor as to Part III.
Justice Sotomayor filed a dissenting opinion, in which Justice Ginsburg joined.
You’re Fired! Trump, Tenure Protection, and the Future of Humphrey’s Executor
The recent flurry of firings in the federal government has sparked new questions surrounding the...
The Future of Securities Self-Regulation After Alpine
Alpine Securities Corp. v. Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (“Alpine’) raises a challenge to the constitutionality...
Is FTC Administrative Litigation Constitutional?
Axon and Jarkesy have renewed scrutiny of the constitutionality and fairness of FTC’s administrative litigation. For example, the...
A Seat at the Sitting - December 2023
The December Docket in 90 Minutes or Less
Each month, a panel of constitutional experts convenes to discuss the Court’s upcoming docket sitting...
Deep Dive Episode 285 - Loper Bright and the Next Steps for Chevron Deference at the Supreme Court
Regulatory Transparency Project's Fourth Branch Podcast
This Term, the Supreme Court will hear Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo—a case concerning judicial...
Loper Bright and the Next Steps for Chevron Deference at the Supreme Court
This Term, the Supreme Court will hear Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo—a case concerning judicial...
The Demise of the SEC’s Adjudication System
This post was originally published at Notice & Comment. Earlier this month on a Friday...
The Administrative State on Trial?
EBRXI
The Supreme Court continues to accept for review cases that challenge agency authority on separation...
Panel I: What is Democracy?
2023 National Student Symposium
There has been much discussion about threats to democracy over the past year. But conceptions...
SEC v. Cochran - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
Margaret Little
On November 7, 2022, the U.S. Supreme Court heard oral argument in Michelle Cochran v. U.S....
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: SEC v. Cochran
On November 7, 2022, the U.S. Supreme Court will hear oral argument in Michelle Cochran...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: SEC v. Cochran
On November 7, 2022, the U.S. Supreme Court will hear oral argument in Michelle Cochran...
A Seat at the Sitting - November 2022
The November Docket in 90 minutes or Less
Each month, a panel of experts convenes to discuss the Court’s upcoming docket sitting by...
Groundhog Day at the Supreme Court: SEC v. Cochran
Well, it’s Groundhog Day at the Securities and Exchange Commission. Again. At least, that’s what...
Revitalizing the Nondelegation Doctrine
Federalist Society Review, Volume 23
A Review of The Administrative State Before the Supreme Court: Perspectives on the Nondelegation Doctrine (Peter...
Revitalizing the Nondelegation Doctrine
Federalist Society Review, Volume 23
A Review of The Administrative State Before the Supreme Court: Perspectives on the Nondelegation Doctrine (Peter...
A Seat at the Sitting - April 2022
The April Docket in 90 Minutes or Less
Each month, a panel of constitutional experts convenes to discuss the Court’s upcoming docket sitting by...
FedSoc Study Break: Administrative Law
30 Minutes. Your Questions. Their Answers.
The Federalist Society's Student Division & NYU School of Law Chapter present Administrative Law Featuring:...
Cochran v. SEC: Vindicating Article III Jurisdiction over the Structural Constitution and ALJs
In Cochran v. SEC the Fifth Circuit court of appeals sitting en banc opened the doors...
Severability and Article III Powers
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group Teleforum
What should the Supreme Court do when it finds one provision of a statute unconstitutional? There is a...
Talks with Authors: Administrative Law Theory and Fundamentals: An Integrated Approach
Few fields are more in need of fresh thinking than administrative law. The author of Administrative Law...
Courthouse Steps Decision Teleforum: Carr v. Saul
On April 22, 2021, the U.S. Supreme Court decided Carr v. Saul. Writing for the...
When the Government Changes Sides in Ongoing Litigation
On March 26, 2021, the Federalist Society's Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group hosted...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument Teleforum: Carr v. Saul
On March 3, 2021, the Supreme Court will hear oral arguments in Carr v. Saul. This...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument Teleforum: Mnuchin v. Collins
The case of Mnuchin v. Collins will have oral arguments before the Supreme Court on December 9,...
Collins v. Mnuchin- Post-Argument SCOTUScast
featuring Elizabeth Slattery
On December 9, 2020 the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Collins v. Mnuchin (consolidated...
Appointments Clause Back in the Supreme Court: Patent Office Judges as Principal or Inferior Officers
Federalism and Separation of Powers Practice Group Teleforum
Eleven months ago the Federal Circuit held that the Administrative Patent Judges who serve on...
Book Review: The Dubious Morality of Modern Administrative Law by Richard Epstein
Richard Epstein’s The Dubious Morality of Modern Administrative Law examines how the growth of the...
Is Our Modern Administrative State Unmoored from the Morality of Law?
Federalist Society Review, Volume 21
A review of The Dubious Morality of Modern Administrative Law, by Richard A. Epstein (Manhattan Institute...
Is Our Modern Administrative State Unmoored from the Morality of Law?
Federalist Society Review, Volume 21
A review of The Dubious Morality of Modern Administrative Law, by Richard A. Epstein (Manhattan Institute...
Panel 2: The Anti-Federalists and Theories of Originalism
2020 Annual Western Chapters Conference
On January 25, 2020, the Federalist Society hosted its annual Western Chapters Conference at the...
Gundy v. United States: Revisiting the Nondelegation Doctrine, or Not?
The U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Gundy v. United States disappointed some observers who were hoping...
American Justice 2018: Book Review
“The Shifting Supreme Court” is the latest from the University of Pennsylvania’s “American Justice” series,...
American Justice 2018: Book Review
“The Shifting Supreme Court” is the latest from the University of Pennsylvania’s “American Justice” series,...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: Kisor v. Wilkie
On the morning of March 27, the Supreme Court will hear oral argument in Kisor...
Rulemaking by Adjudication: Who Am I to Judge?
2018 National Lawyers Convention
When Congress delegates to a federal agency the responsibility for implementing, administering, and enforcing a...
Independent Agencies: How Independent is Too Independent?
2018 National Lawyers Convention
Justice Scalia put it bluntly in Morrison v. Olson: “There are now no lines.” Morrison,...
Showcase Panel I: What is Regulation For?
2018 National Lawyers Convention
The administrative state, with roots over a century old, was founded on the premise that...
Supreme Court Roundup: October Term 2017 [SCOTUSbrief]
Short video featuring Thomas Lee and Jennifer Mascott
While the Supreme Court’s last term included a number of blockbuster decisions, the majority of...
Supreme Court Roundup: October Term 2017 [SCOTUSbrief]
Short video featuring Thomas Lee and Jennifer Mascott
While the Supreme Court’s last term included a number of blockbuster decisions, the majority of...
Administrative Law's Assault On Civil Liberty: Lucia Vs. SEC
Justice Kagan's succinct opinion in Lucia v. SEC sent shockwaves through the secretive world of administrative...
Administrative Law's Assault On Civil Liberty: Lucia Vs. SEC
Justice Kagan's succinct opinion in Lucia v. SEC sent shockwaves through the secretive world of administrative...
The ALJ Executive Order: A Modest Step Towards Re-Integrating the Executive Branch
“Our Constitution was adopted to enable the people to govern themselves, through their elected leaders....
The ALJ Executive Order: A Modest Step Towards Re-Integrating the Executive Branch
“Our Constitution was adopted to enable the people to govern themselves, through their elected leaders....
The Supreme Court Tackles Patent Reform: Inter Partes Review Under the AIA Undermines the Structural Protections Offered by Article III Courts
Federalist Society Review, Volume 19
Note from the Editor: This article criticizes Justice Clarence Thomas’ opinion in Oil States. It...
Courthouse Steps: Lucia v. SEC Decided
Litigation and Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group Teleforum
In Lucia v. SEC, the SEC fined the petitioner Raymond J. Lucia $300,000 and barred...
Is it a Taking When the Government Floods Your House?
Environmental Law & Property Rights Practice Group Teleforum
In the aftermath of Hurricane Harvey, the US Army Corps of Engineers deliberately flooded thousands...
Reforming Administrative Adjudication
Administrative Law & Regulation Practice Group Teleforum
Agencies formally adjudicate a massive number of federal cases with administrative law judges. This delegation...
Civil Service Reform
Sixth Annual Executive Branch Review Conference
The Sixth Annual Executive Branch Review Conference is scheduled for Tuesday, April 17 at the...
The Deregulatory Landscape
Sixth Annual Executive Branch Review Conference
The Sixth Annual Executive Branch Review Conference is scheduled for Tuesday, April 17 at the...
Courthouse Steps: Lucia v. SEC
Administrative Law and Regulation and Litigation Practice Group Teleforum
In Lucia v. SEC, the SEC fined the petitioner Raymond J. Lucia $300,000 and barred...
Introduction to Originalism and Federalism: Where Are the Courts Heading?
2018 Ohio Lawyers Chapters Conference
Since the 1980s, the originalist approach to constitutional interpretation has gained greater and greater acceptance...
Is the FDA’s Rule on Cigars & Vaping Products Constitutional?
Regulatory Transparency Project Teleforum
Invoking the Tobacco Control Act, the FDA issued an omnibus regulation of cigars, pipe tobacco,...
Preview: Lucia v. SEC
Litigation Practice Group Teleforum
The SEC fined the petitioner Raymond J. Lucia $300,000 and barred him from working as an...
Courthouse Steps: Minnesota Voters Alliance v. Mansky
Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group Teleforum
Most states have laws that prohibit electioneering within polling places on election day, and the...
En Banc D.C. Circuit Upholds CFPB Constitutionality
Regulatory Transparency Project Teleforum
On Wednesday, January 31, the full United States Court of Appeals for the District of...
Showcase Panel I: Administrative Agencies and the Federal Judiciary
2017 National Lawyers Convention
Statutory administrative law judges (ALJ) located within each agency adjudicate administrative law cases brought by...
Burgess v. FDIC, the Appointments Clause, and the Separation of Powers
Last week, the Fifth Circuit became the third circuit court to consider whether administrative law...
Docket Watch: Burgess v. FDIC, the Appointments Clause, and the Separation of Powers
Last week, the Fifth Circuit became the third circuit court to consider whether administrative law...
Docket Watch: Burgess v. FDIC, the Appointments Clause, and the Separation of Powers
Last week, the Fifth Circuit became the third circuit court to consider whether administrative law...
Courthouse Steps: D.C. Circuit En Banc Argument - Podcast
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group Podcast
The D.C. Circuit heard a rare doubleheader of en banc arguments on major structural separation...