Facts of the Case
During the Civil Rights movement of the 1960s, the New York Times published an ad for contributing donations to defend Martin Luther King, Jr., on perjury charges. The ad contained several minor factual inaccuracies. The city Public Safety Commissioner, L.B. Sullivan, felt that the criticism of his subordinates reflected on him, even though he was not mentioned in the ad. Sullivan sent a written request to the Times to publicly retract the information, as required for a public figure to seek punitive damages in a libel action under Alabama law.
When the Times refused and claimed that they were puzzled by the request, Sullivan filed a libel action against the Times and a group of African American ministers mentioned in the ad. A jury in state court awarded him $500,000 in damages. The state supreme court affirmed and the Times appealed.
Questions
Did Alabama's libel law unconstitutionally infringe on the First Amendment's freedom of speech and freedom of press protections?
Conclusions
-
To sustain a claim of defamation or libel, the First Amendment requires that the plaintiff show that the defendant knew that a statement was false or was reckless in deciding to publish the information without investigating whether it was accurate. In a unanimous opinion authored by Justice Brennan, the Court ruled for the Times. When a statement concerns a public figure, the Court held, it is not enough to show that it is false for the press to be liable for libel. Instead, the target of the statement must show that it was made with knowledge of or reckless disregard for its falsity. Brennan used the term "actual malice" to summarize this standard, although he did not intend the usual meaning of a malicious purpose. In libel law, “malice” had meant knowledge or gross recklessness rather than intent, since courts found it difficult to imagine that someone would knowingly disseminate false information without a bad intent.
Arthur N. Rupe Debate: Section 230 in the Algorithmic Age
The Michigan Law Federalist Society is pleased to host students and attorneys from across...
Panel & Fireside Chat with Solicitors General T. Elliot Gaiser and Eric Wessan
Preserving Judicial Independence in a Time of Political Division
Featuring: James Burnham, President, Vallecito Capital Jay Edelson, Founder & CEO, Edelson PC Prof. Nicole Stelle Garnett, John...
Freedom of Thought: On Building a Courageous and Effective Career
2024 National Lawyers Convention
Accomplishing anything of significance in this political environment requires courage. The legal industry has a...
The First Amendment in Trademark Law after Vidal v. Elster
In Vidal v. Elster (the “Trump Too Small” case), the Supreme Court unanimously upheld a...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: NetChoice Cases
Two cases involving NetChoice, a company that represents social media giants like Facebook, Twitter, Google,...
Panel One: Judicial Independence and Trust: Has Article III Become Too Political?
2024 Western Chapters Conference
All levels of the judiciary have faced increased attacks on their independence in recent years....
Mere Natural Law
2023 National Lawyers Convention
The U.S. Supreme Court’s originalist jurisprudence has been on display in its most recent terms...
Panel I: New York Times v. Sullivan
2023 Florida Young Lawyers Summit
In 1964, the U.S. Supreme Court issued its opinion in New York Times v. Sullivan...
Courthouse Steps Decision: Counterman v. Colorado
In Counterman v. Colorado, the Court considered a question of free speech and criminal law: whether,...
Courthouse Steps Decision: United States v. Hansen
On Friday, June 23, 2023, the Supreme Court released its decision in United States v....
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: Counterman v. Colorado
On April 19, 2023, the Court is set to consider a question of free speech...
Section 230 Goes to Court: Gonzalez v. Google and the Future of the Electronic Town Square
Social media platforms have emerged as the new “town square” and a key forum for...
Talks with Authors: An Introduction to Constitutional Law: 100+ Supreme Court Cases Everyone Should Know
Professors Randy Barnett and Josh Blackman will discuss the most important Supreme Court cases of...
Special Session II: Second Amendment: Aftermath of Bruen; What's Next at the State Level?
National Lawyers Convention 2022
In June 2022, the Supreme Court decided the much-anticipated case, New York State Rifle and...
Liar, Liar: False Statements and the Freedom of Speech
What can the government do to counter "disinformation" or other statements that it believes to...
[Archive Collection] Panel III: Freedom of Speech and Press: Permissible and Impermissible Content Based Restrictions
1986 National Student Symposium
On March 7-8, 1986, The Federalist Society hosted its annual National Student Symposium at Stanford...
State Court Docket Watch: Cleveland Metro. Bar Assn. v. Morton
In Cleveland Metropolitan Bar Association v. Morton,[1] the Ohio Supreme Court sanctioned an attorney for...
Featured Fireside Chat with Gov. Ron DeSantis and Kayleigh McEnany [Florida Chapters Conference]
Eighth Annual Florida Chapters Conference
Forida Governor Ron Desantis and former White House Press Secretary Kayleigh McEnany held a fireside...
Panel One: Big Tech: Government Regulation of Social Media Content Moderation by Big Tech: Good or Bad?
2022 Missouri Chapters Conference
The 2022 Missouri Chapters Conference took place on January 24, 2022, at the Missouri State...
Panel Two: Defending Unpopular Clients: The Ethics of Targeting Attorneys, Firms, and Clients for Reprisals
2022 Missouri Chapters Conference
The 2022 Missouri Chapters Conference took place on January 24, 2022, at the Missouri State...
Panel IV: Intellectual and Informational Property Rights [Archive Collection]
1989 National Student Symposium
On March 10-11, 1989, the Federalist Society's University of Michigan student chapter hosted the eighth...
Navigating High Profile Defamation
Practice Groups Teleforum
The rise in cancel culture aided by online activity—and more recently by the national press—can...
Revisiting New York Times v. Sullivan
Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group Teleforum
On April 21, 2021, the Federalist Society's Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group hosted...
The Future of Section 230
DC Young Lawyers Chapter - Online Event
On March 30, 2021, the Federalist Society's DC Young Lawyers Chapter and the Regulatory Transparency...
Freedom of Thought Pick of the Week: Judge Silberman's Dissent
The Tah v. Global Witness majority opinion, and even the first two parts of Judge Silberman's...
Ricky Vaughn's Prosecution and the First Amendment
The DOJ has charged Douglas Mackey, aka Ricky Vaughn, with conspiracy “to injure, oppress, threaten, or...
Book Review: The Second Founding: An Introduction to the Fourteenth Amendment
The Fourteenth Amendment is now over 150 years old. The Supreme Court has long rejected...
Free Speech & Election Law: Rule of Law, or Just Making it Up? First Amendment Tiered Scrutiny
2020 National Lawyers Convention
On November 10, 2020, The Federalist Society's Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group hosted...
Panel: Social Media and Freedom of Speech
21st Annual Federalist Society Faculty Conference
Over the past year, there have been a number of discussions about social media and...
The First Amendment and Commercial/Economic Speech
2018 Annual Western Chapters Conference
Although the First Amendment makes no distinction between types of speech, courts have consistently offered...
Young Legal Scholars Paper Presentations
20th Annual Federalist Society Faculty Conference
The winners of our Young Legal Scholars Paper Competition will present their papers, and various...
New York Times Co. v. Sullivan: A Landmark Case for Free Speech [No. 86]
Short video featuring Eugene Volokh
Are political ads protected under the First Amendment? In this episode of No. 86, Professor...
The Future of Libel Law
2017 National Lawyers Convention
Libel law leads two lives. Most famously, there is the life of presidential candidates and...
Banquet Keynote Address by Richard Epstein
2017 National Student Symposium
Professor Richard Epstein delivered the keynote address titled "A common lawyer looks at the constitutional...
Panel 1: Privacy and Freedom of the Press
2017 National Student Symposium
The Internet has made information not only much more accessible, it has allowed almost anyone...
Supreme Court Preview: Packingham v. North Carolina - Podcast
Criminal Law & Procedure Practice Group Podcast
On February 27, the Supreme Court will hear oral argument in Packingham v. North Carolina....
Showcase Panel IV: ROUNDTABLE: Areas of Constitutional Doctrine Transformed
2016 National Lawyers Convention
The final Showcase panel examines Justice Scalia's transformation of five very important areas of Supreme...
Free Speech & Election Law: Originalism and the First Amendment
2016 National Lawyers Convention
Has Originalism played a significant role in the Supreme Court's free speech jurisprudence? One scholar...
Young Legal Scholars Paper Presentations
18th Annual Faculty Conference
This panel was part of the 18th Annual Federalist Society Faculty Conference held on January...
Showcase Panel I: The Original View of Congress
2015 National Lawyers Convention
What was the founders' conception of the role of Congress? Was that conception clearly understood?...
Non-Media Speech: Is it Free? - Podcast
Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group Podcast
The First Amendment reads, in part, "Congress shall make no law . . .abridging the...
How First Amendment Procedures Protect First Amendment Substance
2014 National Lawyers Convention
While the substance of constitutional rights is always important, it is often the procedures surrounding...
Criminal Law: Criminal Law Enforcement versus the Free Press
2013 National Lawyers Convention
What are the First Amendment rights of press in the context of criminal investigations, and...
Showcase Panel I: Textualism and the Bill of Rights
2013 National Lawyers Convention
The new textualism has had a big impact on interpretation of the Bill of Rights....
Judge Robert H. Bork: His Life and Legacy - Podcast
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group and Litigation Practice Group Podcast
With the recent passing of Judge Robert Bork, the Federalist Society hosted a very special...
2012 Annual Supreme Court Round Up
Washington, DC Lawyers Chapter
On July 6, 2012, former U.S. Solicitor General Theodore Olson delivered the Annual Supreme Court Round Up...
Writing Law Review Articles
2012 National Student Symposium
On March 3, 2012, Prof. Eugene Volokh of UCLA School of Law delivered a lecture...
Snyder v. Phelps - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 11-30-10 featuring Calvin R. Massey
On October 6, 2010 the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Snyder v. Phelps. The...
Free Speech: Anonymity and The First Amendment
2010 National Lawyers Convention
Prof. Lloyd Hitoshi Mayer, University of Notre Dame Law School Hon. A. Raymond Randolph, United...
The Constitution and the Importance of Interpretation: Original Meaning
Louisville Lawyers Chapter, The Alexander Hamilton Historical Society of Kentucky, and the League of Women Voters of Kentucky
The Louisville Lawyers Chapter co-sponsored this event with The Alexander Hamilton Historical Society of Kentucky...
The Constitution & American Exceptionalism: Citation of Foreign Law
2007 National Lawyers Convention
What relationship is there between the ideology and reality of American exceptionalism and our ideas...
Gay Marriage in California: Legal and Political Prospects
Religious Liberties Practice Group
In 1977, the California legislature amended its family code, Section 300, to read that marriage...
Professor Calvin R. Massey joined the Hastings faculty in 1987. Prior to teaching at Hastings, he practiced law in San Francisco.