Facts of the Case
Both Pennsylvania and Rhode Island adopted statutes that provided for the state to pay for aspects of non-secular, non-public education. The Pennsylvania statute was passed in 1968 and provided funding for non-public elementary and secondary school teachers’ salaries, textbooks, and instructional materials for secular subjects. Rhode Island’s statute was passed in 1969 and provided state financial support for non-public elementary schools in the form of supplementing 15% of teachers’ annual salaries.
The appellants in the Pennsylvania case represented citizens and taxpayers in Pennsylvania who believed that the statute violated the separation of church and state described in the First Amendment. Appellant Lemon also had a child in Pennsylvania public school. The district court granted the state officials’ motion to dismiss the case. In the Rhode Island case, the appellees were citizens and tax payers of Rhode Island who sued to have the statute in question declared unconstitutional by arguing that it violated the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. The district court found in favor of the appellees and held that the statute violated the First Amendment.
Questions
Do statutes that provide state funding for non-public, non-secular schools violate the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment?
Conclusions
-
Yes. Chief Justice Warren E. Burger delivered the opinion for the 8-0 majority as to the Pennsylvania statute and 8-1 as to the Rhode Island statute. The Court held that a statute must pass a three-pronged test in order to avoid violating the Establishment Clause. The statute must have a secular legislative purpose, its principal or primary effect must be one that neither promotes nor inhibits religion, and it must not foster “excessive government entanglement with religion.” The Court held that both the state statutes in question had secular legislative purposes because they reflected the desire of the states to ensure minimum secular education requirements were being met in the non-public schools. The Court did not reach a holding regarding the second prong of the test, but it did find that the statutes constituted an excessive government entanglement with religion. In the Rhode Island program, the amount of oversight of teachers and curricula required to ensure that there is no unnecessary injection of religion into secular topics would require the government to become excessively involved in the nuances of religious education. The same danger holds true for the Pennsylvania statute, which additionally provides state funding directly to a church-related organization. Government financial involvement in such institutions inevitably leads to “an intimate and continuing relationship” between church and state. The Court also noted the potential political implications of public funding, as there is a risk of religious issues becoming politically divisive.
In his concurring opinion, Justice William O. Douglas wrote that the intrusion of the government into the running of non-public schools through grants and other funding creates the entanglement that the Establishment Clause prohibits. He also argued that non-secular schools are so thoroughly governed by religious ideologies that any amount of public funding supports those doctrines, which the Framers of the Constitution dictated the government must not do. Justice Hugo L. Black joined in the concurrence, and Justice Thurgood Marshall joined in the parts relating to case numbers 569 and 570. Justice William J. Brennan, Jr. wrote a separate concurrence in which he argued that the danger was not only that religion would infiltrate the government, but also that the government would push secularization onto religious creeds. An analysis of the statutes in question shows that they impermissible involve the government in “essentially religious activities,” which the Establishment Clause is meant to prevent. In his opinion concurring in part and dissenting in part, Justice Byron R. White wrote that the majority opinion goes too far and, in restricting the use of state funds in non-secular schools, creates an obstacle to the use of public funds for secular education. He argued that there was no proof that religion would invade secular education or that the government oversight of the use of public funds would be so extensive as to constitute entanglement.
Justice Thurgood Marshall did not participate in the discussion or decision of case number 89.
Litigation Update: Ten Commandments in Public Schools
This week, the en banc U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit held that...
What Was an "Establishment of Religion" at the Founding?
The Founders Gave Us the Tools Series
In this Federalist Society America250 series, experts analyze modern legal and policy debates through the...
Litigation Update: Attorney’s Fees as Deterrence in Civil Rights Litigation
When Congress amended the Civil Rights Act in 1976, it directed federal courts to use...
Courthouse Steps Decision: Medina v. Planned Parenthood South Atlantic
in July of 2018, Governor Henry McMaster of South Carolina issued an executive order to...
Courthouse Steps Decision: Catholic Charities Bureau, Inc. v. Wisconsin Labor & Industry Review Commission
Wisconsin’s unemployment insurance program provides financial assistance to those who have lost their job through...
Tracking and Ending Religious Discrimination
A new project sponsored by a coalition of organizations seeks to track the various ways...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: Catholic Charities Bureau, Inc. v. Wisconsin Labor & Industry Review Commission
On March 31, 2025, the Supreme Court will hear oral arguments in Catholic Charities Bureau...
Litigation Update: Bethesda University v. Cho
Bethesda University, a private Christian university founded around Pentecostal theology, faced an internal leadership dispute,...
Environmental Law & Property Rights: Environmental Law in a Post-Chevron World— How Should Congress, Agencies, and States Respond?
2024 National Lawyers Convention
This year, in a pair of decisions known as Loper Bright, the Supreme Court overruled...
Religious Liberty and the Court: Looking Ahead to the 2024-2025 Term
The Federalist Society is proud to host Mark Rienzi, President of the Becket Fund and...
A Religious Charter School? A Discussion on the Limits of State Action and Demands of the Free Exercise Clause
On June 25, 2024, the Oklahoma Supreme Court ruled that the nation’s first religious charter...
New Voices in Administrative Law II: The Supreme Court and Federal Court Jurisdiction
The development of standing jurisprudence has been inextricably intertwined with the growth of the administrative...
Free Exercise and Abortion
In the wake of the Supreme Court’s decision in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization...
Litigation Update: Roman Catholic Diocese of Albany v. Vullo
In 2017, New York passed a law requiring employers to cover abortions in their health...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: City of Grants Pass, Oregon v. Johnson
City of Grants Pass, Oregon v. Johnson questions if prohibiting sleeping/camping on public property under...
303 Creative, Masterpiece Cakeshop, and the Fate of Free Exercise for Wedding Vendors
Over the past decade, the tension between First Amendment rights and public accommodations laws has...
Litigation Update: First Amendment Matters in the Classroom
The intersection of the First Amendment, parental rights, and educational texts has become a topic...
Loper and Labor Law: Implications of a Possible Decrease in Deference on New Rulemaking
On January 18, the Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo and...
A Seat at the Sitting - January 2024
The January Docket in 90 Minutes or Less
Each month, a panel of constitutional experts convenes to discuss the Court’s upcoming docket sitting...
Establishing an Agreement to Disagree About Church and State
Federalist Society Review, Volume 24
A review of Nathan Chapman & Michael McConnell, Agreeing to Disagree: How the Establishment Clause...
Religious Liberty in the Work-and-Market-place
2023 National Lawyers Convention
The Supreme Court’s decisions in 303 Creative LLC v. Elenis and in Groff v. DeJoy...
Groff v. DeJoy: The Death of the “De Minimis” Test Breathes Life Back into Religious Accommodation
Federalist Society Review, Volume 24
In a unanimous decision last June, the Supreme Court in Groff v. DeJoy heightened the...
Originalism Carries On
Federalist Society Review, Volume 24
A review of Erwin Chemerinsky, A Momentous Year in the Supreme Court: October Term 2021...
A Cord of Three Strands: How Kennedy v. Bremerton School District Changed Free Exercise, Establishment, and Free Speech Clause Doctrine
Federalist Society Review, Volume 24
In 2015, Bremerton High School football coach Joseph Kennedy lost his job for kneeling at...
Religious Liberty and Education: Kennedy, Carson, and Parental Rights
2022 National Lawyers Convention
This panel discussion will examine public and private education, with a focus on the relationship—and...
Religious Liberty at the Supreme Court 2022
Please join these experts as they review religious liberty at the Supreme Court in 2022. Featuring:...
A Discussion on Dobbs
Please join the Federalist Society's Practice Groups for a virtual event on Dobbs v. Jackson...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument Webinar: Kennedy v. Bremerton School District
On April 25, 2022, the U.S. Supreme Court will hear oral argument in Kennedy v....
A Seat at the Sitting - April 2022
The April Docket in 90 Minutes or Less
Each month, a panel of constitutional experts convenes to discuss the Court’s upcoming docket sitting by...
Panel Two: School Choice in the Courts [Archive Collection]
1999 Stranahan National Issues Forum
On March 26, 1999, the Federalist Society co-sponsored the Stranahan National Issues Forum with the...
Panel Two: School Choice and Education Reforms During COVID-19
2021 Third Circuit Chapters Conference
The COVID-19 pandemic resulted in over a year of virtual public schooling in some parts...
An Extended Essay on Church Autonomy
Federalist Society Review, Volume 22
The doctrine of church autonomy[1] is distinct from the two more familiar lines of cases...
Talks with Authors: Religious Liberty in Crisis
Religious Liberties Practice Group Teleforum
On June 16, 2021, The Federalist Society's Religious Liberties Practice Group hosted a teleforum titled...
Religious Schools, Collective Bargaining, & the Constitutional Legacy of NLRB v. Catholic Bishop
Federalist Society Review, Volume 22
It would be difficult to find a corner of American labor law more anomalous than...
We Are Free for a Reason
Federalist Society Review, Volume 22
A review of Free to Believe: The Battle Over Religious Liberty in America, by Luke...
States have been violating religious schools’ First Amendment rights for decades. The Supreme Court may be about to stop them.
The Supreme Court rarely goes out of its way to make sweeping pronouncements. The Justices...
Panel II: The Freedom of Religion [Archive Collection]
1986 National Student Symposium
On March 7-8, 1986, The Federalist Society hosted its annual National Student Symposium at Stanford...
Session II: SCOTUS after the Barrett Confirmation
2021 Annual Florida Chapters Conference
On January 30, 2021, The Federalist Society's Florida lawyers chapters hosted their annual Florida Chapters...
Religious Liberties: Religious Liberty and the New Court
2020 National Lawyers Convention
On November 9, 2020, The Federalist Society's Religious Liberties Practice Group hosted a virtual panel...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument Teleforum: Fulton v. City of Philadelphia
This teleforum reviews the November 4 oral argument in Fulton v. City of Philadelphia. In March...
After Espinoza, What’s Left of the Establishment Clause?
Federalist Society Review, Volume 21
Note from the Editor: The Federalist Society takes no positions on particular legal and public...
Litigation Update: COVID-19 and the Supreme Court’s Religious Liberty Cases
Amid a flurry of cancelations and postponements in response to the COVID-19 pandemic, many are...
Lemon is Dead
“Lemon is dead,” quoth the court, and there was much rejoicing. Happily, the glad tidings...
Credentials Not Required: Why an Employee’s Significant Religious Functions Should Suffice to Trigger the Ministerial Exception
Federalist Society Review, Volume 20
Note from the Editor: The Federalist Society takes no positions on particular legal and public...
The Future of the Establishment Clause in the Roberts Court
2019 National Lawyers Convention
On November 14, 2019, the Federalist Society's Religious Liberty Practice Group held a panel for...
The Future of the Establishment Clause in the Roberts Court
NLC Convention Panel: Religious Liberties Practice Group
Next Thursday’s Establishment Clause Panel at the Federalist Society National Lawyer’s Convention will be both...
Exploring American Legion: What Shelving Lemon Could Mean for Monuments Litigation
In 2015, the Arkansas legislature authorized placement of a privately-donated Ten Commandments monument on the...
The American Legion v. American Humanist Association - Post-Decision Podcast
SCOTUScast featuring Christopher DiPompeo
On June 20, 2019, the Supreme Court decided The American Legion v. American Humanist Association,...
Courthouse Steps Decision Teleforum: The American Legion v. American Humanist Association
For decades, the law surrounding the constitutionality of monuments and memorials has been in disarray,...
Courthouse Steps Decision Teleforum: The American Legion v. American Humanist Association
For decades, the law surrounding the constitutionality of monuments and memorials has been in disarray,...
Can a New Establishment Clause Jurisprudence Succeed in Protecting Religious Minorities Where Lemon Has Failed?
Federalist Society Review, Volume 20
Note from the Editor: The Federalist Society takes no positions on particular legal and public...
The Bladensburg WWI Memorial Cross
Government Expression of Religious Content and the Establishment Clause
On February 27, 2019, the Supreme Court of the United States heard oral argument in...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: The World War I Cross Cases
What is the nature of government involvement in religious matters, and what is the future...
Courthouse Steps Preview: The Maryland Peace Cross (American Legion v. American Humanist Association)
Do crosses on public land violate the Establishment Clause? More importantly, how should the Supreme...
Courthouse Steps: Trump v. Hawaii Decided
International & National Security Law and Religious Liberties Practice Group Teleforum
Trump v. Hawaii is the latest iteration of Hawaii’s challenge to President Trump’s Executive Order suspending...
Interesting Establishment Clause Case in the Eleventh Circuit - Kondrat'Yev v. City of Pensacola
In May, the Eleventh Circuit will hear argument in Kondrat'Yev v. City of Pensacola (No....
Is the "Parsonage Allowance" Allowed?
Religious Liberties Practice Group Teleforum
Last month, in a challenge brought by the Freedom from Religion Foundation, a Wisconsin federal...
Debate—State Blaine Amendments
2017 Annual Western Chapters Conference
The Supreme Court has agreed to hear oral arguments in Trinity Lutheran Church of Columbia, Inc. v....
Showcase Panel IV: ROUNDTABLE: Areas of Constitutional Doctrine Transformed
2016 National Lawyers Convention
The final Showcase panel examines Justice Scalia's transformation of five very important areas of Supreme...
The Contraceptive Mandate
Second Annual Executive Branch Review Conference
Religion has long had a special place in our society and in the Constitution. Has...
In Whose Name We Pray: Restoring the Establishment Clause in Town of Greece v. Galloway
Engage Volume 14, Issue 3 October 2013
Note from the Editor: This article is a discussion about the Establishment Clause issue in...
Supreme Court Preview: What Is in Store for October Term 2013?
Co-sponsored by the Practice Groups and the Faculty Division
October 7th will mark the first day of the 2013 Supreme Court term. Thus far,...
Who Said That?: A Simple Question That May Change the Way Courts View Legislative Prayer
Engage Volume 14, Issue 1 February 2013
Related Opinions & Briefs: • Petition for Writ of Certiorari, Town of Greece v. Galloway:...
Religious Liberties: The Ministerial Exception Case: Hosanna-Tabor Evangelical Lutheran Church and School v. EEOC
2011 National Lawyers Convention
The Religious Liberties Practice Group hosted this panel on "The Ministerial Exception Case: Hosanna-Tabor Evangelical...