Note from the Editor: The Federalist Society takes no positions on particular legal and public policy matters. Any expressions of opinion are those of the author. We welcome responses to the views presented here. To join the debate, please email us at info@fedsoc.org.
The Federalist Society mourns the passing of Professor Russell L. Weaver, of the University of Louisville Brandeis School of Law. In a scholarly career spanning more than four decades, his teaching and scholarship shaped generations of lawyers and academics, with particularly noteworthy work on preserving the freedom of speech in democracies grappling with the double-edged sword of rapid technological development.
As his award-winning achievements make clear, Prof. Weaver possessed many gifts—but the remarkable degree to which he put them at the service of others warrants special recognition. In an era marked by strong polarization, Russ was a transformative advocate for robust discussion—both inside and outside the academy—that encompassed a broad spectrum of viewpoints. This commitment was reflected not only in his own scholarly endeavors, but also his extraordinary decades of work bringing together thousands of scholars for timely, wide-ranging discussions at the annual gathering of the Southeastern Association of Law Schools (SEALS). Part of his determination to broaden the range of discussion in law schools took the form (among other things) of a recurring invitation to the Federalist Society to sponsor an annual reception at SEALS: an opportunity that over the past 15 years has grown into a wonderful occasion for the constructive sharing of goodwill, even camaraderie, among academics who often have strongly divergent first principles or methodologies, but a shared commitment to the rule of law and civil dialogue. The Society remains deeply grateful for this opportunity to engage with and learn from so many remarkable scholars—and aspiring academics. Indeed, the willingness of SEALS to provide so much support for junior scholars and those hoping to obtain their first tenure-track appointment (including the opportunity to test-run job talk papers) is a tribute to the depth of Russ's commitment to investing in future generations of scholars.
The Society likewise recognizes with affection Russ's longtime involvement in speaking to our Student Chapters, providing not only extracurricular intellectual engagement but also a real sense of belonging to many students who might otherwise have felt like outliers in the academic milieu.
In this year of the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence, it bears noting that the document charges the British with being "deaf to the voice of justice". As an academic Russ spoke boldly at times. But he also listened. He sought truth through dialogue, and his energies were in many ways devoted to providing a platform for the voices of other scholars—including those whose ideas diverged from his own or from prevailing orthodoxies. He will be greatly missed.