Facts of the Case
Diana Levine filed this personal injury action against Wyeth, the drug manufacturer, in state court in Vermont. Ms. Levine had intravenously injected Phenergan, a drug made by Wyeth and used to prevent allergies and motion sickness, into her arm, and complications arising from the injection eventually led to the amputation of her arm. Ms. Levine brought this claim asserting that Wyeth had failed to include a warning label describing the possible arterial injuries that could occur from negligent injection of the drug. Wyeth argued that because their warning label had been deemed acceptable by the FDA, a federal agency, any Vermont state regulations making the label insufficient were preempted by the federal approval. The Superior Court of Vermont found in favor of Ms. Levine and denied Wyeth's motion for a new trial.
The Supreme Court of Vermont affirmed this ruling on appeal, holding that the FDA requirements merely provide a floor, not a ceiling, for state regulation. Therefore, states are free to create more stringent labeling requirements than federal law provides.
Questions
Does federal law preempt state law in a personal injury action against a drug manufacturer for failing to include an appropriate warning label where the drug in question met the labeling requirements of the Food and Drug Administration?
Conclusions
-
No. The Supreme Court affirmed the Supreme Court of Vermont holding that federal law did not preempt Ms. Levine's state-law claim that Wyeth's labeling of Phenergan failed to warn of the dangers of its intravenous administration. With Justice John Paul Stevens writing for the majority and joined by Justice Anthony M. Kennedy, Justice David H. Souter, Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, and Justice Stephen G. Breyer, the Court first rejected Wyeth's argument that by unilaterally changing its labeling of Phenergan, it would have violated federal labeling regulations. Rather, the Court asserted that the manufacturer bears ultimate responsibility for the content of its labels at all times. The Court then rejected Wyeth's argument that requiring it to comply with the state-law duty to provide a stronger warning would interfere with Congress' purpose of entrusting the FDA with drug labeling decisions. Rather, the Court reasoned that Congress did not intend to preempt state-law failure to warn actions when it created the Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act.
Justice Breyer wrote a separate concurring opinion noting that the FDA may create regulations that preempt state law tort claims, but such a regulation was not at issue in Ms. Levine's case. Justice Clarence Thomas wrote separately, concurring only in the judgment. He criticized the majority opinion for implicitly endorsing a "far-reaching implied pre-emption doctrine" where the Court invalidates state laws based on perceived conflicts with federal statutes by extrapolating from evidence not found in the text of the statute itself. Justice Samuel A. Alito dissented and was joined by Chief Justice John G. Roberts and Justice Antonin G. Scalia. He disagreed with the Court's holding that a jury, rather than the FDA is ultimately responsible for regulating warning labels for prescription drugs. He argued this is incompatible with the Court's precedent in Geier v. American Honda Motor Co., which established the principles of conflict preemption.
A Seat at the Sitting - April 2026
Each month, a panel of constitutional experts convenes to discuss the Court’s upcoming docket sitting...
2019 Civil Justice Update
White Paper
Note from the Editor: The Federalist Society takes no positions on particular legal and public...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: Merck Sharp & Dohme Corp. v. Albrecht
In Merck Sharp & Dohme Corp. v. Albrecht, the Supreme Court has been asked to...
2018 Civil Justice Update
White Paper
Note from the Editor: The Federalist Society takes seriously its responsibility as a non-partisan institution...
Update: In re Fosamax (Alendronate Sodium) Products Liability Litigation - Podcast
Litigation Practice Group Podcast
In a recent decision, the Third Circuit held that hundreds of state-law claims alleging that...
Statewide vs. Local Right to Work Laws - Podcast
Labor and Employment Law Practice Group Podcast
In 1957, an article in the Stanford Law Review asked the question: can counties and cities pass...
Does EPA’s Clean Power Plan Proposal Violate the States’ Sovereign Rights?
Engage Volume 16, Issue 1
Note from the Editor: This article discusses the Environmental Protection Agency’s Clean Power Plan under...
Part II: Can States Require Proof of Citizenship for Voter Registration?: Arizona v. Inter Tribal Council of Arizona
Engage Volume 14, Issue 3 October 2013
Note from the Editor: This article discusses the Arizona v. Inter Tribal Council of Arizona...
Free To Choose Medicine
Engage Volume 14, Issue 3 October 2013
Note from the Editor: This article is about the Free To Choose Medicine concept....
Mutual Pharmaceutical Co. v. Bartlett - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 10-08-13 featuring Gregory Dickinson
On June 24, 2013, the Supreme Court announced its decision in Mutual Pharmaceutical Co. v....
Can States Require Proof of Citizenship for Voter Registration?--Arizona v. Inter Tribal Council of Arizona
Engage Volume 14, Issue 1 February 2013
Introduction This term the Court will hear a case examining a perceived clash between state...
Business Cases and the Roberts Supreme Court
Engage Volume 12, Issue 3, November 2011
The statement that the Supreme Court under Chief Justice Roberts, and more specifically the Court...
Quanta: Patent Rights in the Supreme Court
Intellectual Property Practice Group
LG Electronics owned a patent for a microprocessor chip, which it licensed to Intel, but...
2009 Annual Supreme Court Round Up
Washington, DC Lawyers Chapter
On July 10, 2009, former United States Solicitor General Theodore B. Olson delivered the Annual...
Oral Argument in Wyeth v. Levine Marks Change in Drug Litigation Preemption Debate
On November 3, 2008, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Wyeth v. Levine to...
SCOTUScast 1-27-09 featuring Erin Glenn Busby
Wyeth v. Levine
On Monday, November 3, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Wyeth v. Levine. The...
Luncheon Debate: When should FDA Regulation Preempt State Tort Liability
11th Annual Faculty Conference
Prof. Richard Epstein, University of Chicago School of Law Prof. Roderick Hills, New York University...
Litigation: Civil Litigation under the Roberts Court
2008 National Lawyers Convention
The Roberts Court -- is it pro-business? Many Court watchers say so. But, whether pro-business...
SCOTUScast 2-26-08 featuring Richard Nagareda
Riegel v. Medtronic
On February 20, 2008 the Supreme Court decided Riegel v. Medtronic. In Riegel, the Court...