Facts of the Case
Robert Stevens was convicted under 18 U.S.C. Section 48 in a Pennsylvania federal district court for "knowingly selling depictions of animal cruelty with the intention of placing those depictions in interstate commerce for commercial gain." His conviction stems from an investigation into the selling of videos related to illegal dog fighting. Mr. Stevens appealed his conviction arguing that 18 U.S.C. Section 48, on its face, was unconstitutional because it violated the Free Speech Clause of the First Amendment
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit agreed with Mr. Stevens and reversed his conviction, holding unconstitutional 18 U.S.C. Section 48. The court reasoned that the dog fighting videos he sold were protected speech and that 18 U.S.C. Section 48 did not serve a compelling governmental interest.
Questions
Is 18 U.S.C. Section 48, on its face, unconstitutional under the Free Speech Clause of the First Amendment?
Conclusions
-
Yes. The Supreme Court held that 18 U.S.C. § 48 is substantially overbroad, and therefore invalid under the First Amendment. With Chief Justice John G. Roberts writing for the majority, the Court reasoned that depictions of animal cruelty are not categorically unprotected by the First Amendment. The Court further reasoned that because a "substantial number" of § 48's applications are unconstitutional, the law is overbroad and, thus, invalid. Justice Samuel A. Alito dissented. He disagreed with the majority opinion arguing that § 48 was not intended to suppress speech, but rather to "prevent horrific acts of animal cruelty." He was concerned that the majority holding will practically legalize the sale of such videos and spur the resumption of their production.
Text-and-History or Means-End Scrutiny? A Response to Professor Nelson Lund's Critique of Bruen
Federalist Society Review, Volume 24
Professor Nelson Lund’s “Bruen’s Preliminary Preservation of the Second Amendment,” recently published in the Federalist...
United States v. Stevens [SCOTUSbrief]
Short video featuring David Forte
In an effort to quash the production of “crush” videos, Congress banned the knowing creation,...
Courthouse Steps Decision Teleforum: Caniglia v. Strom
On May 17, 2021, the Supreme Court released its decision in Caniglia v. Strom, which focused...
Courthouse Steps: NIFLA v. Becerra Decided
Religious Liberties and Free Speech & Election Law Practice Groups Teleforum
NIFLA is a religiously-affiliated pro-life pregnancy clinic that sought to enjoin the California Reproductive Freedom,...
Packingham v. North Carolina - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 3-30-17 featuring Ilya Shapiro
On February 27, 2017, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Packingham v. North Carolina....
Courthouse Steps: Packingham v. North Carolina - Podcast
Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group Podcast
In Packingham v. North Carolina, the Supreme Court will decide whether the First Amendment bars...
Business and the Roberts Court - Podcast
Litigation Practice Group Teleforum
In recent years, the Supreme Court appears to have taken a greater interest in "business"...
Free Speech & Election Law: Originalism and the First Amendment
2016 National Lawyers Convention
Has Originalism played a significant role in the Supreme Court's free speech jurisprudence? One scholar...
Project Veritas Action v. Conley: Undercover Newsgathering and the First Amendment
On March 4, Project Veritas Action Fund (PVA) filed suit in Massachusetts federal court against Suffolk County District...
Young Legal Scholars Paper Presentations
18th Annual Faculty Conference
This panel was part of the 18th Annual Federalist Society Faculty Conference held on January...
Criminal Law: Free Speech, Anti-Corruption, and the Criminalization of Government Affairs
2015 National Lawyers Convention
If we accept the premise that government, and government power, is growing, then the stakes...
Redskins Trademark in Court, and More - Podcast
Litigation Practice Group Podcast
Can the government police speech it thinks is offensive? The Lanham Act allows the government...
Showcase Panel I: Textualism and the Bill of Rights
2013 National Lawyers Convention
The new textualism has had a big impact on interpretation of the Bill of Rights....
Speaking Freely in Business
Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group Podcast
The United States Supreme Court is about to make a decision whether to grant cert...
United States v. Stevens – Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 04-27-10 featuring Jacob R. Loshin
On April 20, 2010, the Supreme Court announced its decision in United States v. Stevens....
United States v. Stevens – Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 04-27-10 featuring Jacob R. Loshin
On April 20, 2010, the Supreme Court announced its decision in United States v. Stevens....
United States v. Stevens - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 10-16-2009 featuring Jacob R. Loshin
On October 6, 2009, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in United States v. Stevens....
United States v. Stevens - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 10-16-2009 featuring Jacob R. Loshin
On October 6, 2009, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in United States v. Stevens....
Supreme Court October Term 2009: What Is in Store?
October 5th marks the first day of the 2009 Supreme Court term. Thus far the...
Supreme Court October Term 2009: What Is in Store?
National Press Club529 14th Street NW
Washington, DC 20045