Facts of the Case
A 1923 act of Congress banned the interstate shipment of "filled milk" (skimmed milk mixed with fat or oil other than milk fat). Carolene Products, a milk manufacturer, was indicted under the Act. The trial court dismissed the indictment. On appeal to the federal government, the court was tasked with determining whether the Act was unconstitutional under the Fifth Amendment. Carolene Products argued that the law lacked rational basis and also that Congress did not regulate the use of oleomargarine, which substituted vegetable fats for butter fat, in interstate commerce.
Questions
Does the law violate the Commerce Power granted to Congress in Article Section 8 and the Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment?
Conclusions
-
In an opinion authored by Justice Harlan Fiske Stone, the Court upheld the act. The majority reasoned Congress may restrict shipments of certain milk substitutes without also restricting butter. Considering that Congress had held many hearings prior to passing this law, it was reasonable to conclude that Congress believed it was necessary for public welfare. Carolene Products failed to meet its burden of proving that no rational basis for the law existed. Justice Pierce Butler concurred, and Justice James McReynolds dissented.
Panel I: Laboratories of Liberty: State Deregulation and Economic Freedom
2026 National Student Symposium
Featuring: Mr. Paul Avelar, Arizona Office Managing Attorney, Institute for Justice Mr. Danny Seiden, President...
Panel I: Laboratories of Liberty: State Deregulation and Economic Freedom
2026 National Student Symposium
Featuring: Mr. Paul Avelar, Arizona Office Managing Attorney, Institute for Justice Mr. Danny Seiden, President...
Analysis of the New Proposed “Waters of the United States” (WOTUS) Rule
On November 20th, 2025, the EPA and the Army Corps of Engineers proposed a rule...
Analysis of the New Proposed “Waters of the United States” (WOTUS) Rule
On November 20th, 2025, the EPA and the Army Corps of Engineers proposed a rule...
Panel Discussion: Legal Challenges Involving Gender Identity Post-Bostock
2023 Texas Chapters Conference
Litigation and legislation involving complex issues regarding gender identity are at the forefront of public...
Mere Natural Law
2023 National Lawyers Convention
The U.S. Supreme Court’s originalist jurisprudence has been on display in its most recent terms...
Fair Elections in an Era of Partisanship
2023 National Lawyers Convention
Recent years have seen unprecedented controversies about election rules, including mail-in ballots and drop boxes,...
Panel I: What is Democracy?
2023 National Student Symposium
There has been much discussion about threats to democracy over the past year. But conceptions...
Feddie Night Festivus: Shapiro vs. Everybody
The Federalist Society's Student Division &University of Tennessee College of Law Student Chapter present Feddie Night...
Does the Original Meaning of the Fourteenth Amendment Protect a Right to Work?
Recent scholarship says yes. At least one federal judge agrees. And soon, we may have an answer from the U.S. Supreme Court.
The story of unenumerated rights is a familiar one. Most law students learn it in...
Does the Original Meaning of the Fourteenth Amendment Protect a Right to Work?
Recent scholarship says yes. At least one federal judge agrees. And soon, we may have an answer from the U.S. Supreme Court.
The story of unenumerated rights is a familiar one. Most law students learn it in...
Tiwari v. Friedlander: Which Rational Basis Test is it Anyway?
In Tiwari v. Friedlander, the Petitioners ask the Supreme Court to grant certiorari to address...
Feddie Night Festivus: Blackman vs. Everybody!
Columbus School of Law Student Chapter
The Federalist Society's Student Division &Columbus School of Law Student Chapter present Feddie Night Festivus:Blackman vs. Everybody! FeaturingUnprecedented...
Mediating Rights: Anthony Sanders reviews Jamal Greene’s new book, How Rights Went Wrong
In a new Federalist Society Review article, Which Rights Are We Mediating? Anthony Sanders,...
Which Rights Are We Mediating?
Federalist Society Review, Volume 21
A review of How Rights Went Wrong: Why Our Obsession With Rights Is Tearing America...
Which Rights Are We Mediating?
Federalist Society Review, Volume 21
A review of How Rights Went Wrong: Why Our Obsession With Rights Is Tearing America...
The Right to Earn an Honest Living: Occupational Licensing Versus the American Dream
Little Rock Lawyers Chapter - Online Event
On March 1, 2021, the Federalist Society's Little Rock Lawyers Chapter hosted Paul Avelar to...
Deep Dive Episode 145 – The True Extent of Executive Power
Regulatory Transparency Project's Fourth Branch Podcast
On October 20, 2020, the Federalist Society’s Georgetown Law Student Chapter and the Regulatory Transparency...
COVID-19 Business Closures, Firearms Dealers, and the Second Amendment
As the United States faces the spread of COVID-19, officials in many jurisdictions have ordered the...
Panel 1: The Original Understanding of “Privileges or Immunities”
2019 National Student Symposium
On March 15-16, 2019, the Federalist Society's student chapter at the ASU Sandra Day O'Connor...
Panel: Who's Afraid of Substantive Due Process?: Original Meaning and the Due Process of Law
21st Annual Federalist Society Faculty Conference
Conventional wisdom holds that the original meaning of the "due process of law," as used...
Panel 1: Approaches to Constitutional and Statutory Interpretation
2018 Pennsylvania Chapters Conference
On October 19, 2018, the Federalist Society's Pennsylvania chapters hosted the 2018 Pennsylvania Chapters Conference...
Tenth Annual Rosenkranz Debate: Lochner v. New York
2017 National Lawyers Convention
RESOLVED: Lochner v. New York: Still Crazy After All These Years. The Tenth Annual Rosenkranz Debate was...
Lucas v. South Carolina Coastal Council at 25 - Podcast
Environmental Law & Property Rights Practice Group Podcast
This spring marks the 25th anniversary of the U.S. Supreme Court's decision in Lucas v....
Litigating State Constitutional Issues
2017 Annual Western Chapters Conference
The past forty years have seen a surge in efforts to litigate under state constitutional provisions...
Scrutiny for Me, But Not For Thee? New York Times Columnist Praises Courts for "Calling out Legislators" in Abortion and Voting Rights Cases
It is not often that a progressive columnist offers full-throated praise for judicial decisions to...
Don't Thread on Me
A landmark decision against bureaucratic browbeating has advocates for limited government, free markets, and shapely...
Don't Thread on Me
A landmark decision against bureaucratic browbeating has advocates for limited government, free markets, and shapely...
Supreme Court Concludes 2015 Term - Podcast
Practice Groups Podcast
On June 27, 2016, the United States Supreme Court concluded its October 2015 term by...
Book Review: The Right to Try
Engage, Volume 17, Issue 1
Note from the Editor: This book review discusses the controversial concept of the constitutional “right...
The Circuit Splits Are Out There—and the Court Should Resolve Them
Engage Volume 16, Issue 2
Note from the Editor: This article argues that the U.S. Supreme Court should resolve a...
The Circuit Splits Are Out There—and the Court Should Resolve Them
Engage Volume 16, Issue 2
Note from the Editor: This article argues that the U.S. Supreme Court should resolve a...
How First Amendment Procedures Protect First Amendment Substance
2014 National Lawyers Convention
While the substance of constitutional rights is always important, it is often the procedures surrounding...
Sixth Annual Rosenkranz Debate and Luncheon
2013 National Lawyers Convention
RESOLVED: Courts are too Deferential to the Legislature The Sixth Annual Rosenkranz Debate was held...
Book Review: Cosmic Constitutional Theory: Why Americans Are Losing Their Inalienable Right to Self-Governance
Engage Volume 14, Issue 2 July 2013
Other Reviews of Cosmic Constitutional Theory: •Marc O. Degirolami, The New Republic, Sept. 2012: http://www.newrepublic.com/book/review/cosmic-constitutional-theory-judicial-restraint...
Limits on Government Regulation of Real Property: Koontz v. St. Johns River Water Management District - Podcast
Environmental Law & Property Rights Practice Group Podcast
The right to improve privately-owned real property is recognized as basic and generally beneficial to...
Limited Government and the Bill of Rights - Faculty Book Podcast
Faculty Division Podcast 2-12-13 featuring Patrick Garry and Lee Strang
Limited Government and the Bill of Rights takes a novel approach to the constitutional connection between...
Panel 1: Roundtable on Judicial Deference v. Judicial Engagement
15th Annual Faculty Conference
The Federalist Society's Facutly Division hosted this roundtable discussion on "Judicial Deference v. Judicial Engagement"...
Intellectual Property: Undermining or Preserving Property Rights? The New Administrative Patents
2012 National Lawyers Convention
The Intellectual Property Practice Group hosted this panel on "Undermining or Preserving Property Rights? The...
Over-Criminalization and Public Opinion - Podcast
Criminal Law & Procedure Practice Group Podcast
Over the last thirty years, the number of federal criminal laws has increased by one-third....
Perry v. Schwarzenegger: Is Traditional Marriage Unconstitutional?
Engage Volume 12, Issue 3, November 2011
Note from the Editor: This article and the article in this issue by Mark Strasser...
Panel I: Economic Theory, Civic Virtue and the Meaning of the Constitution
2011 National Student Symposium
Justice Holmes' dissent in Lochner v. New York is well-known for the statement, "[A] constitution is not...
The Impact of Judicial Activism on the Moral Character of Citizens
UC Berkeley Student Chapter
On October 28, 2010, the UC Berkeley Student Chapter of the Federalist Society hosted this debate...
Stop the Beach Renourishment, Inc. v. Florida Department of Environmental Protection - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 07-12-10 featuring James S. Burling
On June 17, 2010, the Supreme Court announced its decision in Stop the Beach Renourishment,...
McDonald v. City of Chicago – Post-Argument Debate SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 03-03-10 featuring J. Gordon Hylton, Clark Neily, & Steven G. Calabresi
On March 2, 2010, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in McDonald v. City of...
DC v. Heller and the Future of Gun Control Legislation
Fordham Student Chapter, the American Constitution Society, and Fordham Law School Republicans
The Fordham Student Chapter co-hosted this event on January 22, 2009 with the American Constitution...
Administrative Law: The 25th Anniversary of Chevron
2008 National Lawyers Convention
Twenty-five years ago, in October Term 1983, the Supreme Court issued its opinion in Chevron...
SCOTUScast 3-24-08 featuring Andy Grewal
Boulware v. United States
On March 3, 2008 the Court decided the case of Boulware v. United States. The...
Panel II: Post Kelo Reform
10th Annual Faculty Conference
This panel discussion took place on January 4, 2008, at the Federalist Society's 10th Annual...
Property Rights in the United States
2007 National Lawyers Convention
The Federalist Society's Environmental Law & Property Rights Practice Group presented this debate at the...
Is the Military Commissions Act Constitutional?
San Francisco Lawyers Chapter
Congress passed the Act to overrule Hamdan v. Rumsfeld and to divest federal courts of...
Gay Marriage in California: Legal and Political Prospects
Religious Liberties Practice Group
In 1977, the California legislature amended its family code, Section 300, to read that marriage...
Dragooning State Officials into Federal Service
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group Newsletter - Volume 1, Issue 1, Fall 1996
In a century driven by the Progressive-Era view that ever-larger government can solve the manifold...