Facts of the Case
Jimcy McGirt, a member of the Muscogee (Creek) Nation was convicted of sex crimes against a child by the state of Oklahoma within the historical Creek Nation boundaries. He argued that Oklahoma could not exercise jurisdiction over him because under the Indian Major Crimes Act, any crime involving a Native American victim or perpetrator, or occurring within recognized reservation boundaries, is subject to federal jurisdiction, not state jurisdiction.
Questions
Can a state prosecute an enrolled member of the Creek Tribe for crimes committed within the historical Creek boundaries?
Conclusions
-
Land reserved for the Creek Nation since the 19th century remains “Indian country” under the Major Crimes Act (MCA), which grants the federal government exclusive jurisdiction to try certain major crimes committed by enrolled members of a tribe on that land. Justice Neil Gorsuch authored the 5-4 majority opinion holding that Oklahoma lacked jurisdiction to prosecute Jimcy McGirt.
The Court first noted that all parties agreed that McGirt’s crimes were committed on lands described as belonging to the Creek Nation in an 1866 treaty and federal statute. Though the early treaties did not refer to the Creek lands as a “reservation,” the Court has held that similar language in treaties from the same era was sufficient to create a reservation. An 1856 treaty promised that “no portion” of Creek lands “would ever be embraced or included within, or annexed to, any Territory or State” and that the Creek Nation would have the “unrestricted right of self-government,” with “full jurisdiction” over enrolled Tribe members and their property.
Once a federal reservation is established, only Congress can diminish or disestablish it through a “clear expression of congressional intent.” The Court acknowledged that Congress has broken many promises to the Tribe but none has manifested “clear expression of congressional intent” to disestablish the Creek Reservation. The Court rejected Oklahoma’s argument that Congress never established a reservation in the first place, finding that such a conclusion “would require willful blindness to the statutory language.” The Court also rejected Oklahoma’s argument that the Oklahoma Enabling Act transferred jurisdiction from federal courts to state courts as contrary to the plain terms of the MCA. The mere fact that Oklahoma has been exercising jurisdiction in these cases does not make it in any more correct. Indeed, “unlawful acts, performed long enough and with sufficient vigor, are never enough to amend the law.”
Chief Justice John Roberts authored a dissenting opinion, in which Justices Samuel Alito and Brett Kavanaugh joined, and in which Justice Clarence Thomas joined in part. The dissent accused the majority of examining the statutes in isolation rather than considering a broader inquiry, which would have led to the conclusion that a reservation did not exist when McGirt committed his crimes.
Justice Thomas authored a dissenting opinion to argue that the Court had no jurisdiction to review the judgment of the Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals because it rests on adequate and independent state ground.
Further analysis of the oral argument available at Oral Argument 2.0: https://argument2.oyez.org/2020/mcgirt-v-oklahoma/
After Dobbs and Samia: The Potential Implications of Applying a Dobbs Lens to the Supreme Court’s Constitutional Criminal Jurisprudence
2023 National Lawyers Convention
Stare Decisis, a Latin term meaning “let it stand,” is a key element of how...
Panel II: U.S. Supreme Court Review
2023 Florida Young Lawyers Summit
Featuring: Zack Smith, Legal Fellow and Manager, Supreme Court and Appellate Advocacy Program, Meese Center, The...
Criminal Cases in SCOTUS’s October 2021-22 Terms: Introduction
This is the first in a series of posts on criminal cases and crime-related civil...
A Seat at the Sitting - November 2022
The November Docket in 90 minutes or Less
Each month, a panel of experts convenes to discuss the Court’s upcoming docket sitting by...
The Original Understanding of the Indian Commerce Clause: An Update
Federalist Society Review, Volume 23
The Congress shall have Power . . . To regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and...
The Original Understanding of the Indian Commerce Clause: An Update
Federalist Society Review, Volume 23
The Congress shall have Power . . . To regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and...
Courthouse Steps Decision: Oklahoma v. Castro-Huerta
On June 29, 2022, the Supreme Court decided Oklahoma v. Castro-Huerta. In a 5-4 decision,...
Courthouse Steps Decisions: Denezpi and Ysleta
On June 13 and 15, 2022, the Supreme Court decided Denezpi v. United States and...
A Seat at the Sitting - April 2022
The April Docket in 90 Minutes or Less
Each month, a panel of constitutional experts convenes to discuss the Court’s upcoming docket sitting by...
Panel 3 - Should the Land of Lincoln Cancel Lincoln?
In midst of the pandemic, among the many urgent public demands, Chicago took the time...
A Seat at the Sitting - February 2022
The February-March Docket in 90 Minutes or Less
Each month, a panel of constitutional experts convenes to discuss the Court’s upcoming docket sitting by...
Feddie Night Festivus: Blackman vs. Everybody!
Columbus School of Law Student Chapter
The Federalist Society's Student Division &Columbus School of Law Student Chapter present Feddie Night Festivus:Blackman vs. Everybody! FeaturingUnprecedented...
Courthouse Steps Decision Webinar: Yellen v. Confederated Tribes of the Chehalis Reservation
Administrative Law & Regulation Practice Group Teleforum
The Supreme Court issued its decision in Yellen, Secretary of Treasury v. Confederated Tribes of...
Yellen v. Confederated Tribes of the Chehalis Reservation - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
Featuring Anthony Ferate and Jennifer Weddle
On June 25th, 2021 the Supreme Court decided Yellen v. Confederated Tribes of Chehalis Reservation,...
McGirt: One Year Later
Environmental Law & Property Rights Practice Group Teleforum
As the 2020 term concluded, the US Supreme Court ruled in a 5-4 decision that...
Courthouse Steps Decision Teleforum: United States v. Cooley
In a 9-0 opinion written by Justice Breyer that could have far-reaching implications, the Supreme Court...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument Teleforum: Yellen v. Confederated Tribes of the Chehalis Reservation
On April 19, 2021, the Supreme Court will hear oral argument in Yellen v. Confederated...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: United States v. Cooley
On March 23, 2021, the Supreme Court will hear oral argument in United States v. Cooley. ...
Litigation Update: Apache Stronghold v. United States
Apache Stronghold v. United States is an ongoing case involving religious land use. On February...
2021 Oklahoma Legislative Preview
Tulsa & Oklahoma City Lawyers Chapter - Virtual Event
On February 4, 2021, Oklahoma State Senator Julie Daniels, the Oklahoma Senate Judiciary Committee Chair,...
McGirt v. Oklahoma: The Decision [SCOTUSbrief]
Short video featuring Troy Eid
Under the Major Crimes Act, Indian tribes have concurrent jurisdiction in their reservation territories for...
McGirt v. Oklahoma: The Decision [SCOTUSbrief]
Short video featuring Troy Eid
Under the Major Crimes Act, Indian tribes have concurrent jurisdiction in their reservation territories for...
Recent Trends in the Roberts Court
Milwaukee Lawyers Chapter
On August 18, 2020, the Federalist Society's Milwaukee Lawyers Chapter hosted a virtual event on...
2020 Annual Supreme Court Round Up
Webinar & Live Stream
On August 10, 2020, the Federalist Society's Washington, D.C. Lawyers Chapter will present its annual...
Reviewing The Supreme Court’s 2019/20 Term: A Panel Discussion
Colorado Lawyers Chapter - Online Event
The Colorado Lawyers Chapter held a virtual review of the 2019-20 Supreme Court term on...
McGirt v. Oklahoma - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
featuring Andy Lester
On July 9, the Supreme Court handed down its opinion in McGirt v. Oklahoma. Jimcy...
McGirt v. Oklahoma - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
featuring Andy Lester
On July 9, the Supreme Court handed down its opinion in McGirt v. Oklahoma. Jimcy...
Courthouse Steps Decision: McGirt v. Oklahoma
On July 9, the Supreme Court released its decision in McGirt v. Oklahoma. By a vote...
McGirt v. Oklahoma - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
featuring Troy Eid
On May 11, 2020, the U.S. Supreme Court heard argument in McGirt v. Oklahoma, which...
McGirt v. Oklahoma - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
featuring Troy Eid
On May 11, 2020, the U.S. Supreme Court heard argument in McGirt v. Oklahoma, which...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument Teleforum: McGirt v. Oklahoma
Tribal jurisdiction is again before the Supreme Court. Following November 2018 arguments, Chief Justice John...
McGirt v. Oklahoma: State and Tribal Impact A Year Later
Tulsa Lawyers Chapter Event
Summit Club (Ballroom)15 West 6th Street
Tulsa, OK 74119