Facts of the Case
In 1990, Stephen Kimble obtained a patent for a Spider-Man toy that was set to expire in May 2010. Kimble claimed that he discussed the idea with the president of Marvel Enterprises Inc., and that he would be compensated for use of his ideas. Although no agreement was reached, Marvel produced a toy that was similar to Kimble's design. In 1997, Kimble sued for patent infringement, and the parties settled in 2001, with Marvel agreeing to purchase the patent and pay royalties to the petitioner without an expiration date. The case was subsequently dismissed. In 2006, Marvel entered a licensing agreement with Hasbro Inc. that gave it the right to produce the toy. Disagreements arose between Kimble and Marvel concerning the royalty payments, and Kimble claimed that the original patent would be infringed if royalties were not paid. Kimble sued Marvel in Arizona state court, and the case was then removed to the federal district court.
The magistrate judge determined that settlement agreement was a "hybrid" agreement, in which patent and non-patent rights were inseparable, and that the Supreme Court decision in Brulotte v. Thys Co. applied. In that case, the Court ruled that, when patents are sold in return for a royalty payment, the purchaser was not obligated to continue these payments beyond the expiration date of the patents because doing so would over-compensate the seller of the patent and improperly extend the patent monopoly beyond the intended time limit. On recommendation of the magistrate, the district court granted summary judgment in favor of Marvel and ruled that the settlement agreement transferred patent rights, but that it was unclear if non-patent rights were transferred. Kimble appealed and argued that the settlement agreement transferred both patent and non-patent rights and that, while royalty payments ended for the patent, they did not end for the toy itself. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed the decision of the district court.
Questions
Should the decision in Brulotte v. Thys Co, which held that a patentee cannot continue to receive royalty payments after the patent has expired, be overturned?
Conclusions
-
No. Justice Elena Kagan delivered the opinion for the 6-3 majority. The Court held that the precedent established in Brulotte v. Thys Co.—that a patentee cannot receive royalty payments after the patent has expired—should be upheld because there was no sufficient reason to overturn it. Patent law jurisprudence has typically struck down statutes that overly limit free access to formerly patented inventions, and the Brulotte decision was in line with these cases. Because no subsequent legal developments have made the rule announced in that decision obsolete and it has remained workable, there is no reason to overturn the decision. The Court also noted that Congress had ample opportunity to enact a statute that forecloses the Brulotte rule but has not done so.
Justice Samuel A. Alito, Jr. wrote a dissent in which he argued that, because the Brulotte rule impermissibly interferes in parties’ abilities to negotiate licensing agreements that reflect the true value of the product, the decision has no precedential weight and should be overturned. The Brulotte rule represents a poor interpretation of the Patent Act and promotes economic inefficiency, so the decision lacks the support of legal standing as well as public policy, and therefore the Court should not uphold it. Chief Justice John G. Roberts, Jr. and Justice Clarence Thomas joined in the dissent.
Antitrust and FTC Reform in the New Congress
In 2025, antitrust and consumer protection remain hot topics in the legal world as a...
Christine Wilson’s Expectations for Antitrust and the FTC
Join us on Tuesday, April 30th at 12:00 PM ET for a special lunch panel...
Negative Legislation
Federalist Society Review, Volume 22
Modern commentators have spilled much ink on the undemocratic nature of congressional delegations to executive...
The Future of the Past: Stare Decisis
2018 National Lawyers Convention
Stare decisis – “to stand by things decided” – is the doctrine under which courts...
Most Popular Videos of 2015
As a new year fast approaches, let's take a moment to look back at some...
Supremacy and the Supreme Court
Since Marbury v. Madison in 1803, it’s been “settled law” that the Supreme Court is...
An Opportunity Missed?: Kimble v. Marvel Enterprises - Podcast
Intellectual Property Practice Group Podcast
In Kimble v. Marvel Enterprises, citing stare decisis, the Court held that a patent holder...
Hands Off My Raisins: Supreme Court Decides Horne v. Department of Agriculture - Podcast
Environmental Law & Property Rights Practice Group Podcast
Under what circumstances can the government take your property without giving you compensation? Does it...
SCOTUS Orders and Opinions: 6/22/2015
ORDER LIST: 1 new grant - Kingdomware Techs v. US: Whether the Federal Circuit erred in construing...
Should a royalty agreement exceed the life of a patent?
Short video featuring Greg Dolin
Professor Greg Dolin of the University of Baltimore School of Law discusses the dispute in Kimble...
Patent Agreements, Patent Validity, and the Supreme Court - Podcast
Intellectual Property Practice Group Podcast
In two separate cases to be argued the week of March 30, 2015, the U.S....
Commil USA v. Cisco Systems and Kimble v. Marvel Enterprises - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 4-15-15 featuring Greg Dolin
On March 31, 2015, the Supreme Court heard oral argument for two cases: Commil USA,...