Facts of the Case
In 1997, the Texas legislature enacted a law requiring the University of Texas to admit all high school seniors who ranked in the top ten percent of their high school classes. After finding differences between the racial and ethnic makeup of the university's undergraduate population and the state's population, the University of Texas decided to modify its race-neutral admissions policy. The new policy continued to admit all in-state students who graduated in the top ten percent of their high school classes. For the remainder of the in-state freshman class the university would consider race as a factor in admission.
Abigail N. Fisher, a Caucasian female, applied for undergraduate admission to the University of Texas in 2008. Fisher was not in the top ten percent of her class, so she competed for admission with other non-top ten percent in-state applicants. The University of Texas denied Fisher's application.
Fisher filed suit against the university and other related defendants, claiming that the University of Texas' use of race as a consideration in admission decisions was in violation of the equal protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. The university argued that its use of race was a narrowly tailored means of pursuing greater diversity. The district court decided in favor of the University of Texas, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit affirmed the district court's decision. Fisher appealed the appellate court's decision.
Questions
Does the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment permit the consideration of race in undergraduate admissions decisions?
Conclusions
-
Yes, but only under a standard of strict judicial scrutiny. Justice Anthony M. Kennedy delivered the opinion for the 7-1 majority. The Supreme Court held that, in affirming the lower court's decision, the Court of Appeals did not hold the University's admission policies to a standard of strict scrutiny, so the judgment was incorrect. Based on previous judicial precedent in cases dealing with minority admissions, the Court has held that such cases are reviewable under the Fourteenth Amendment and that they must be reviewed under a standard of strict scrutiny to determine whether the policies are "precisely tailored to serve a compelling governmental interest." If the policy does not meet this standard, race may not be considered in the admissions process. The Court held that it was the duty of the reviewing court to "verify" that the University policy in question was necessary to achieve the benefits of diversity and that no race-neutral alternative would provide the same benefits. The Supreme Court held that the lower courts did not conduct a sufficient strict scrutiny examination in this case. Justice Antonin Scalia wrote a concurring opinion in which he argued that the Constitution prohibits governmental discrimination on the basis of race. However, because this case did not ask the Court to overrule precedent that allowed universities to consider diversity a compelling interest that justified race-based admission policies, he joined the majority's opinion in full. In his separate concurrence, Justice Clarence Thomas wrote that he joined the majority's opinion that the lower courts did not sufficiently apply strict scrutiny, but he also argued that the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment prohibits a state's use of race as a factor in higher education admissions. He further argued that there is nothing "necessary" about the benefits that flow from racial diversity in higher education, so there in no compelling state interest to promote it. Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg wrote a dissenting opinion in which she argued that the University's admission policy treats race as merely one factor in the overall decision to admit a student, which is permissible under previous judicial precedent. She also argued that the Equal Protection Clause does not require that state universities be blind to the history of overt discrimination and that it is preferable that they explicitly include race as a factor in admission decisions rather than attempt to obfuscate its role. Justice Elena Kagan did not participate in the discussion or decision of the case.
Hispanic-Serving Institutions and Emerging Constitutional Issues
Federalist Society Review, Volume 24
In 2019, Florida Gulf Coast University’s (FGCU) “Florida Educational Equity Report” noted that FGCU “continues...
Talks With Authors: Classified: The Untold Story of Racial Classification in America
In his recent book, Classified: The Untold Story of Racial Classification in America, Professor...
Private Sector Diversity Programs: Perks and Pitfalls
It is growing practice within the business community to engage in diversity initiatives in hiring,...
Title VI, College Admissions, and Public Opinion
A Regulatory Transparency Project Webinar
With the Supreme Court about to hear two cases involving the use of race in...
Litigation Update: Cert Granted in Students for Fair Admission v. Harvard and Students for Fair Admission v. UNC Chapel Hill
Breaking news: The Supreme Court granted certiorari in two petitions pending before the Supreme Court...
Panel One: Racial Preferences in Higher Education: What are the Consequences and What Will the Supreme Court Do?
2021 Third Circuit Chapters Conference
Despite the fact that Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibits racial...
Diversity and Elimination of Bias CLE Teleforum: An update to the Harvard Case and the Meaning of Diversity in a Multi-Racial Era
Professional Responsibilities Practice Group Diversity CLE Teleforum
Electronic Sign In: Click Here (Sign-in now!) Written Materials: Click Here Certificate of Attendance: Click Here (Fill in the form...
Diversity and Elimination of Bias CLE Teleforum: The Harvard Case and the Meaning of Diversity in a Multi-Racial Era
Professional Responsibilities & Legal Education Teleforum
*** Please note: CLE is no longer available for this teleforum/podcast.*** Electronic Sign In: Click...
Are U.S. Colleges and Universities Barring Asian Applicants Based on their Race?
Regulatory Transparency Project
On May 22, the Regulatory Transparency Project and the Center for Equal Opportunity co-sponsored a...
Litigation Update: UT-Austin Faces Lawsuit Over Race-Based Admissions - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
In July 2017, Students for Fair Admissions, a non-profit membership organization comprised of over 21,000...
Race-Based Admissions: Student Lawsuits Against Harvard and UNC Move Forward - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
In 2014, the Students for Fair Admissions ("SFFA"), a membership organization comprised of students, parents,...
Fisher v. UT–Austin and the Future of Racial Preferences in College Admissions
Federalist Society Review, Volume 17, Issue 2
Note from the Editor: This article discusses the Supreme Court’s recent decision in Fisher v. University...
2016 Annual Supreme Court Round Up
Washington, DC Lawyers Chapter
On July 22, 2016, Miguel Estrada of Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP delivered the Annual Supreme Court Round...
Fisher v. Univ. of Texas at Austin - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 7-12-16 featuring Roger Clegg
On June 23, 2016, the Supreme Court decided Fisher v. Univ. of Texas at Austin. This...
Fisher v. Univ. of Texas at Austin - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 7-12-16 featuring Roger Clegg
On June 23, 2016, the Supreme Court decided Fisher v. Univ. of Texas at Austin. This...
"Affirmative Action Gone Wild?": Supreme Court Upholds Race Preferences in Fisher v. University of Texas II
I like to think I am unusually gifted at political prognostication because, in 2004, I...
Supreme Court Rules on Affirmative Action and Immigration - Podcast
Civil Rights and Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Groups Podcast
On June 23, 2016, the United States Supreme Court issued a 4-3 decision in Fisher...
Supreme Court Rules on Affirmative Action and Immigration - Podcast
Civil Rights and Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Groups Podcast
On June 23, 2016, the United States Supreme Court issued a 4-3 decision in Fisher...
Decision Day Update
The Supreme Court released 5 more decisions this morning. Decisions in the other 3 cases...
Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 2-11-16 featuring Joshua P. Thompson
On December 9, 2015, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Fisher v. University of...
Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 2-11-16 featuring Joshua P. Thompson
On December 9, 2015, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Fisher v. University of...
Fisher II, Academic Mismatch, and the Constitution: A Legal Issue, or Just a Policy One?
Following Justice Scalia's controversial question about mismatch research at the Fisher v. Texas oral argument, some commentators have...
Fisher II, Academic Mismatch, and the Constitution: A Legal Issue, or Just a Policy One?
Following Justice Scalia's controversial question about mismatch research at the Fisher v. Texas oral argument, some...
Affirmative Action Again: Fisher v. University of Texas - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
On December 9, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Abigail Fisher v. University of...
Affirmative Action Again: Fisher v. University of Texas - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
On December 9, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Abigail Fisher v. University of...
On Heightening the Contradictions of Grutter v. Bollinger: Thoughts on the Fisher v. UT Oral Argument
Yesterday, Justice Scalia's controversial question about mismatch theory at the Fisher v. UT oral argument...
Race-Conscious College Admissions: Fisher v. University of Texas - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
Two years ago, the Supreme Court’s 7-1 ruling in Fisher v. University of Texas required...
Litigation: Ten Years of the Roberts Court
2015 National Lawyers Convention
It has been ten years since John Roberts was appointed as the 17th Chief Justice...
A Conflict of Principles: The Battle Over Affirmative Action at the University of Michigan
Engage Volume 16, Issue 3
Note from the Editor: This book review discusses the contentious issue of affirmative action. The Federalist...
Accreditation Overreach Part 2
Forcing Affirmative Action on Colleges and Universities
In my last blog post, I drew attention to my Wall Street Journal op-ed, "Why...
Supreme Court Preview: Fisher
An "Honest" Affirmative Action Defense?
In the long running case of Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin, insufficient notice...
Supreme Court Preview: Of Fisher II and Paper Tigers
“There are not many dull moments in the debate about race preferences in university admissions....
Supreme Court Preview: Fisher II
Holistic Review Is a Sham
Two years ago, the Supreme Court’s 7-1 ruling in Fisher v. UT-Austin (Fisher I) made clear that...
NYT Misses the Mark on Mismatch
This past weekend, the New York Times ran a lengthy article titled "A Prescription for...
College Admissions and Affirmative Action - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
The battle over the use of affirmative action in college admissions seems far from over,...
Supreme Court October Term 2014 Preview - Podcast
Practice Groups Courthouse Steps Podcast
A panel of notable constitutional experts discussed the likely highlights, including the denial of cert...
Copyright Originalism - Podcast
Intellectual Property Practice Group Podcast
Professor Tom W. Bell, Chapman University, Fowler School of Law, participated in a Teleforum conference call...
Panel II: Racial Preferences and Promoting Diversity: Are These Policies Taking Us in the Right Direction?
Civil Rights in the United States
The Obama administration is widely perceived to be an avid proponent of racial preferences. As...
Panel II: Racial Preferences and Promoting Diversity: Are These Policies Taking Us in the Right Direction?
Civil Rights in the United States
The Obama administration is widely perceived to be an avid proponent of racial preferences. As...
Is the Matthew Shepard and James Byrd Jr. Hate Crimes Act in Part Unconstitutional? - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
Congress premised the part of the Hate Crimes Prevention Act banning crimes based on race...
The Twilight of Race-Based Preferences in College Admissions
Michigan Lawyers Chapter
The Michigan Lawyers Chapter hosted this event on February 12, 2014, at Thomas M. Cooley...
A Lady or a Tiger?: Thoughts on Fisher v. University of Texas and the Future of Race Preferences in America
Engage Volume 14, Issue 3 October 2013
Note from the Editor: This article is about the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Fisher...
Civil Rights: Use of Disparate Impact Analysis
2013 National Lawyers Convention
A number of commentators have noted an expansion of the use of disparate impact analysis...
Schuette v. Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action Oral Argument Courthouse Steps - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
On Tuesday, October 15, the Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Schuette v. Coalition to Defend...
The Court Decides: The Prop 8 and DOMA Cases - Podcast
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group and Religious Liberties Practice Group Podcast
On June 26th, the U.S. Supreme Court decided two same sex marriage cases: the Proposition...
Shelby County Going Forward - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group and Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group Podcast
On Tuesday, June 25, the U.S. Supreme Court decided Shelby County v. Holder, a Voting Rights...
Supreme Court Update: Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
The affirmative action case, Fisher v. University of Texas, was decided, 7-1, by the U.S....
2013 Annual Supreme Court Round Up
Washington, DC Lawyers Chapter
On July 8, 2013, Miguel Estrada of Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP delivered the Annual Supreme...
The Growing Use of Disparate Impact Analysis - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
The use of disparate impact analysis is growing very rapidly, and it is becoming the...
Debate on Fisher and Shelby County - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group, American Constitution Society, and National Constitution Center Podcast
The Federalist Society co-sponsored a Teleforum call with the National Constitution Center and the American...
Patenting Human DNA: The Court's Decision - Podcast
Intellectual Property Practice Group Podcast
To listen, please right click on the audio file you wish to hear and then...
Fisher v. University of Texas - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 6-25-13 featuring Gail Heriot and Peter Kirsanow
On June 24, 2013 the Supreme Court announced its decision in Fisher v. University of...
The Internal Revenue Service - Podcast
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group Podcast
The IRS, and its purported targeting of conservative organizations in the processing of applications for...
Why the Supreme Court Should Strike Down Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act
Indianapolis Lawyers Chapter
On March 11, 2013, the Indianapolis Lawyers Chapter of the Federalist Society hosted an event...
On Marriage--And Religious Freedom?
Indianapolis Lawyers Chapter
On February 8, 2013, the Indianapolis Lawyers Chapter of the Federalist Society hosted an event...
Book Reviews: Mismatch and Wounds That Will Not Heal
Engage Volume 14, Issue 1 February 2013
Note from the Editor: This feature reviews two new books on affirmative action in anticipation...
Litigation: Business Cases in the Roberts Court: Perception and Reality
2012 National Lawyers Convention
The Litigation Practice Group hosted this panel on "Business Cases in the Roberts Court: Perception...
Civil Rights: Who Benefits from Affirmative Action and Race and Gender Consciousness?
2012 National Lawyers Convention
The Civil Rights Practice Group hosted this panel on "Who Benefits from Affirmative Action and...
Fisher v. University of Texas: Affirmative Action Revisited by the Supreme Court - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
Fisher v. University of Texas is being heralded as the blockbuster case of this year’s...
Moncrieffe v. Holder - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 10-16-12 featuring Scott Broyles
On October 10, 2012, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Moncrieffe v. Holder. The question...
Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 10-12-12 featuring Gail Heriot
On October 10, 2012, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Fisher v. University of...
Supreme Court Preview: What Is in Store for October Term 2012?
Co-sponsored by the Practice Groups, the Washington DC Lawyers Chapter, and the Faculty Division
October 1st marks the first day of the 2012 Supreme Court Term. Thus far the...
The Fisher Case: Mismatch & the Future of Affirmative Action - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
To listen, please right click on the audio file you wish to hear and then...
Supreme Court Preview: What Is in Store for October Term 2011?
October 3rd marks the first day of the 2011 Supreme Court term. This term the...
Diversity and Elimination of Bias CLE Teleforum: The Harvard Case and the Meaning of Diversity in a Multi-Racial Era
Professional Responsibilities & Legal Education Teleforum
TeleforumAffirmative Action Admissions at the Supreme Court: The Mulligan
Allegheny HYP Club 619 William Penn PlacePittsburgh, 15219