Facts of the Case
The State of Maine relies on local school administrative units (SAUs) to ensure that every school-age child in the state has access to a free education. Not every SAU operates its own public secondary school. To meet the state requirements, an SAU without its own public secondary school may either (1) contract with a secondary school to provide school privileges or (2) pay the tuition of a secondary school at which a particular student is accepted. In either circumstance, the secondary school must be either a public school or an “approved” private school.
To be an “approved” school, a private school must meet the state’s compulsory attendance requirements (which can be demonstrated by accreditation by a New England association of schools and colleges or by approval by the Maine Department of Education), and it must be “nonsectarian in accordance with the First Amendment.”
The Carsons, Gillises, and Nelsons live in SAUs that do not operate a public secondary school of their own but instead provide tuition assistance to parents who send their children to an “approved” private school. The three families opted to send their children to private schools that are accredited but do not meet the nonsectarian requirement because they are religiously affiliated. Because the schools are not “approved,” they do not qualify for tuition assistance. The families filed a lawsuit in federal court arguing that the “nonsectarian” requirement violates the Constitution on its face and as applied. On cross-motions for summary judgment, the district court granted judgment to the State and denied judgment to the plaintiffs. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit affirmed, noting that it had twice before rejected similar challenges, and even though the U.S. Supreme Court had decided two relevant cases in the interim, those cases do not produce a different outcome here.
Questions
Does a state law prohibiting students participating in an otherwise generally available student-aid program from choosing to use their aid to attend schools that provide religious, or “sectarian,” instruction violate the Religion Clauses or Equal Protection Clause of the U.S. Constitution?
Conclusions
-
Maine’s “nonsectarian” requirement for otherwise generally available tuition assistance payments to parents who live in school districts that do not operate a secondary school of their own violates the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment. Chief Justice Jonh Roberts authored the majority opinion of the Court.
Two cases resolve the dispute in this case. In Trinity Lutheran Church of Columbia, Inc. v. Comer, the Court held that the Free Exercise Clause did not permit Missouri to discriminate against otherwise eligible recipients by disqualifying them from a public benefit solely because of their religious character. And in Espinoza v. Montana Department of Revenue, the Court held that a provision of the Montana Constitution barring government aid to any school “controlled in whole or in part by any church, sect, or denomination” violated the Free Exercise Clause because it prohibited families from using otherwise available scholarship funds at religious schools. Applying those precedents to this case, Maine may not choose to subsidize some private schools but not others on the basis of religious character.
Justice Stephen Breyer authored a dissenting opinion, in which Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan joined, arguing that the majority gives “almost exclusive” attention to the Free Exercise Clause while paying “almost no attention” to the Establishment Clause. In Justice Breyer’s view, Maine’s nonsectarian requirement strikes the correct balance between the two clauses.
Justice Sotomayor dissented separately, as well, to highlight the Court’s “increasingly expansive view of the Free Exercise Clause” that “risks swallowing the space between the Religion Clauses.”
How Did the Founders View the Role of Education?
The Founders Gave Us the Tools Series
In this Federalist Society America 250 series, experts analyze modern legal and policy debates through...
Plenary Panel 4: Justice Alito’s Impact on Religious Liberties & Speech
An Examination of the Jurisprudence of Supreme Court Associate Justice Samuel Alito
This panel will analyze Justice Alito’s contributions to the Supreme Court’s religious liberty and free...
School Choice & the FTCSP
School choice has come more to the fore of public awareness in the past several...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: Chiles v. Salazar
In Chiles v. Salazar, the Court will consider the question of whether a Colorado law...
After Drummond: What’s Next in the Debate over Religious Charter Schools?
In Oklahoma Statewide Charter School Board v. Drummond, the U.S. Supreme Court took up the...
Checks and Balances: Deregulation Based on Supreme Court Rulings
Among the points emphasized by the second Trump administration has been a major push for...
A Significant Year for Religious Liberty?
An Update on the 2024-2025 Supreme Court Term
For the first time in years, the U.S. Supreme Court is addressing questions of religious...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: Oklahoma Statewide Charter School Board v. Drummond
On October 20, 2023, the Oklahoma Attorney General Gentner Drummond sued the Oklahoma Statewide Charter...
A Seat at the Sitting - April 2025
The April Docket in 90 Minutes or Less
Each month, a panel of constitutional experts convenes to discuss the Court’s upcoming docket sitting...
Tracking and Ending Religious Discrimination
A new project sponsored by a coalition of organizations seeks to track the various ways...
Closing Banquet and Fireside Chat with Hon. James C. Ho and Allyson Newton Ho, and Presentation of the Annual Joseph Story Award and Feddie Awards
2025 National Student Symposium
Overflow: Hutchins Hall Michigan Law School We are pleased to announce that the Honorable James...
Religious Liberty and the Court: Looking Ahead to the 2024-2025 Term
The Federalist Society is proud to host Mark Rienzi, President of the Becket Fund and...
Daniel Webster Debate Series: Does the Constitution Protect Parental Rights?
The Federalist Society's Georgetown Law Chapter'sDaniel Webster Debate Series presents Daniel Webster Debate Series:Does...
A Seat at the Sitting - October 2024
The October Docket in 90 Minutes or Less
Each month, a panel of constitutional experts convenes to discuss the Court’s upcoming docket sitting...
A Religious Charter School? A Discussion on the Limits of State Action and Demands of the Free Exercise Clause
On June 25, 2024, the Oklahoma Supreme Court ruled that the nation’s first religious charter...
Litigation Update: OKPLAC, Inc. v. Statewide Virtual Charter School Board
After Carson v. Makin (2023) --a U.S. Supreme Court case holding that Maine may not...
Litigation Update: OKPLAC, Inc. v. Statewide Virtual Charter School Board
After Carson v. Makin (2023) --a U.S. Supreme Court case holding that Maine may not...
Establishing an Agreement to Disagree About Church and State
Federalist Society Review, Volume 24
A review of Nathan Chapman & Michael McConnell, Agreeing to Disagree: How the Establishment Clause...
Talks with Authors: Agreeing to Disagree: How the Establishment Clause Protects Religious Diversity and Freedom of Conscience
Agreeing to Disagree: How the Establishment Clause Protects Religious Diversity and Freedom of Conscience investigates...
Panel II: School Choice
Policymaker interest in alternatives to traditional public schools has sharply increased post-pandemic, with some states...
Religious Charter Schools: Another Brick in the Wall of Separation?
The idea that religion should be isolated from our civil institutions has overwhelmingly captured the...
Religious Charter Schools: Another Brick in the Wall of Separation?
The idea that religion should be isolated from our civil institutions has overwhelmingly captured the...
Originalism Carries On
Federalist Society Review, Volume 24
A review of Erwin Chemerinsky, A Momentous Year in the Supreme Court: October Term 2021...
Originalism Carries On
Federalist Society Review, Volume 24
A review of Erwin Chemerinsky, A Momentous Year in the Supreme Court: October Term 2021...
A Cord of Three Strands: How Kennedy v. Bremerton School District Changed Free Exercise, Establishment, and Free Speech Clause Doctrine
Federalist Society Review, Volume 24
In 2015, Bremerton High School football coach Joseph Kennedy lost his job for kneeling at...
Nine Agencies Propose Regulations for Partnerships with Faith-Based and Neighborhood Organizations
On January 13, 2023, nine agencies issued a notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM) titled “Partnerships...
Religious Liberty and Education: Kennedy, Carson, and Parental Rights
2022 National Lawyers Convention
This panel discussion will examine public and private education, with a focus on the relationship—and...
Religious Liberty and Education: Kennedy, Carson, and Parental Rights
2022 National Lawyers Convention
This panel discussion will examine public and private education, with a focus on the relationship—and...
Young Lawyers Panel – Career Opportunities in Constitutional Litigation
Eighth Annual Texas Chapters Conference
Ryan Bangert, Senior Counsel and Vice President for Legal Strategy, Alliance Defending Freedom Arif Panju,...
Suing Religious Employers: The Extent of Exemptions in Title VII
Religious employers are exempt under §§ 702(a) and 703(e)(1), 42 U.S.C.2000e—1(a) and 2000e—2(e)(1), when sued...
Luncheon Speech with Former Attorney General William Barr
Featuring: Hon. William Barr, Former Attorney General of the United States
The Rise of the Undead Blaine Amendment
The Lemon test, a perennial ghoul of Establishment Clause jurisprudence, seems to have finally received...
The Rise of the Undead Blaine Amendment
The Lemon test, a perennial ghoul of Establishment Clause jurisprudence, seems to have finally received...
Religious Liberty at the Supreme Court 2022
Please join these experts as they review religious liberty at the Supreme Court in 2022. Featuring:...
A Discussion on Dobbs
Please join the Federalist Society's Practice Groups for a virtual event on Dobbs v. Jackson...
Courthouse Steps Decision: Carson v. Makin
On June 21, 2022, the Supreme Court decided Carson v. Makin. In a 6-3 opinion, the...
State Constitutions and Individual Liberty: State or Federal Government as Primary Custodian of Individual Rights?
A Regulatory Transparency Project Webinar
Join us for a discussion between David A. Carrillo, Christina Sandefur, and Robert F. Williams...
Panel Two: U.S. Supreme Court Review
Featuring: Prof. Christopher W. Schmidt, Professor of Law & Co-Director of ISCOTUS, Chicago-Kent College of Law Daniel...
A Seat at the Sitting - January 2022
The January Docket in 90 Minutes or Less
Join us for the fourth episode of the Federalist Society's Supreme Court Show: A Seat at...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument Webinar: Carson v. Makin
On December 8, 2021, the U.S. Supreme Court will hear oral arguments in Carson v....
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument Webinar: Carson v. Makin
On December 8, 2021, the U.S. Supreme Court will hear oral arguments in Carson v....
A Seat at the Sitting - December 2021
The December Docket in 90 Minutes or Less
Join us for the third episode of the Federalist Society's Supreme Court Show: A Seat at...
A Seat at the Sitting - December 2021
The December Docket in 90 Minutes or Less
Join us for the third episode of the Federalist Society's Supreme Court Show: A Seat at...
Panel 3: Supreme Court Preview
Fifth Annual Kentucky Chapters Conference
This panel discussed the upcoming Supreme Court term, which began on October 4, 2021....
Panel Two: School Choice and Education Reforms During COVID-19
2021 Third Circuit Chapters Conference
The COVID-19 pandemic resulted in over a year of virtual public schooling in some parts...
Carson v. Makin: Charting a Course Beyond the Status/Use Distinction
The Supreme Court has long interpreted the Establishment Clause as requiring “governmental neutrality between religion...
Carson v. Makin: Charting a Course Beyond the Status/Use Distinction
The Supreme Court has long interpreted the Establishment Clause as requiring “governmental neutrality between religion...
2021 Supreme Court Preview
Jacksonville Lawyers Chapter - Online Event
On September 29, 2021, the Federalist Society's Jacksonville Lawyers Chapter hosted a virtual discussion giving...
Learning to Change: New Takes on Education Reform
Federalist Society Review, Volume 22
A Review of: The Choice We Face: How Segregation, Race, and Power Have Shaped America’s...
Religious Liberty and Education: Kennedy, Carson, and Parental Rights
2022 National Lawyers Convention
The Mayflower Hotel1127 Connecticut Ave NW
Washington, DC 20006
2022 National Lawyers Convention
The Current State of the Legal Profession
The Mayflower Hotel1127 Connecticut Ave NW
Washington, DC 20006
Carson v. Makin: A Fireside Chat
Cincinnati Student Chapter
University of Cincinnati College of Law2540 W Clifton Ave
Cincinnati, OH 45221
Carson v. Makin and the Future of School Choice
Duke Student Chapter
Duke Law School210 Science Dr
Durham, NC 27708