Facts of the Case
The Boy Scouts of America revoked former Eagle Scout and assistant scoutmaster James Dale's adult membership when the organization discovered that Dale was a homosexual and a gay rights activist. In 1992, Dale filed suit against the Boy Scouts, alleging that the Boy Scouts had violated the New Jersey statute prohibiting discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation in places of public accommodation. The Boy Scouts, a private, not-for-profit organization, asserted that homosexual conduct was inconsistent with the values it was attempting to instill in young people. The New Jersey Superior Court held that New Jersey's public accommodations law was inapplicable because the Boy Scouts was not a place of public accommodation. The court also concluded that the Boy Scouts' First Amendment freedom of expressive association prevented the government from forcing the Boy Scouts to accept Dale as an adult leader. The court's Appellate Division held that New Jersey's public accommodations law applied to the Boy Scouts because of its broad-based membership solicitation and its connections with various public entities, and that the Boy Scouts violated it by revoking Dale's membership based on his homosexuality. The court rejected the Boy Scouts' federal constitutional claims. The New Jersey Supreme Court affirmed. The court held that application of New Jersey's public accommodations law did not violate the Boy Scouts' First Amendment right of expressive association because Dale's inclusion would not significantly affect members' abilities to carry out their purpose. Furthermore, the court concluded that reinstating Dale did not compel the Boy Scouts to express any message.
Questions
Does the application of New Jersey's public accommodations law violate the Boy Scouts' First Amendment right of expressive association to bar homosexuals from serving as troop leaders?
Conclusions
-
Yes. In a 5-4 opinion delivered by Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist, the Court held that "applying New Jersey's public accommodations law to require the Boy Scouts to admit Dale violates the Boy Scouts' First Amendment right of expressive association." In effect, the ruling gives the Boy Scouts of America a constitutional right to bar homosexuals from serving as troop leaders. Chief Justice Rehnquist wrote for the Court that, "[t]he Boy Scouts asserts that homosexual conduct is inconsistent with the values it seeks to instill," and that a gay troop leader's presence "would, at the very least, force the organization to send a message, both to the young members and the world, that the Boy Scouts accepts homosexual conduct as a legitimate form of behavior."
Religious Liberty and the Court - Looking Ahead to the Next Term
For the past few Supreme Court terms we have hosted Mark Rienzi, President of the...
Courthouse Steps Decision: 303 Creative v. Elenis
On June 30, 2023 U.S. Supreme Court decided 303 Creative LLC v. Elenis. Petitioner Lorie...
Measuring and Evaluating Public Responses to Religious Rights Rulings
Federalist Society Review, Volume 23
The story of Jack Phillips and his cake shop—Masterpiece Cakeshop—is by now familiar. Jack Phillips...
Is Colorado’s Compelling Interest in Eliminating Discrimination Sufficient to Overcome a Designer’s First Amendment Claims?
In 303 Creative LLC v. Elenis, one of the marquee cases of the current Supreme...
A Seat at the Sitting - December 2022
The December Docket in 90 minutes or less.
Each month, a panel of constitutional experts convenes to discuss the Court’s upcoming docket sitting...
Feddie Night Fights: Fulton v. City of Philadelphia: Fostering Faith or Fostering Hate?
Columbia Student Chapter
On November 20, 2020, The Federalist Society's Student Division and the Columbia Student Chapter hosted...
Balancing Religious Freedoms in a Pluralistic Society
Chicago Lawyers Chapter - Online Event
What should the nature of religious liberty look like in a pluralistic society? The Supreme...
Free Rider or Free to Speak: Friedrichs v. California Teachers Association Oral Argument Preview - Podcast
Labor & Employment Law Practice Group Podcast
On June 30, 2015, the Supreme Court decided to revisit whether the First Amendment permits...
Employment Non-Discrimination Act - Podcast
Religious Liberties Practice Group Podcast
A bill to enact the proposed Employment Non-Discrimination Act ("ENDA") was introduced into the 113th...
Liberty’s Refuge - Faculty Book Podcast
Faculty Division Podcast 07-06-12 featuring John Inazu and Michael McConnell
During the past decade, courts have struggled to reconcile anti-discrimination statutes with claims by private...
Liberty's Refuge: The Forgotten Freedom of Assembly
Faculty Division
Ask Americans what they think the First Amendment protects, and they will tell you “freedom...
Religious Liberties: The Ministerial Exception Case: Hosanna-Tabor Evangelical Lutheran Church and School v. EEOC
2011 National Lawyers Convention
The Religious Liberties Practice Group hosted this panel on "The Ministerial Exception Case: Hosanna-Tabor Evangelical...
Religious Liberties: Christian Legal Society vs. Martínez
2010 National Lawyers Convention
Prof. Richard W. Garnett, IV, Associate Dean, University of Notre Dame Law School Mr. Jordan...
Christian Legal Society v. Martinez – Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 04-23-10 featuring Richard A. Epstein
On April 19, 2010, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Christian Legal Society v....
Christian Legal Society v. Martínez
Religious Liberties Practice Group
The Federalist Society's Religious Liberties Practice Group, the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, and the...
The Employment Non-Discrimination Act
New Federal Initiatives Project
Brought to you by the Religious Liberties Practice Group The "Employment Non-Discrimination Act" ("ENDA") would amend...
Free Speech & Election Law: Freedom of Speech vs. Anti-Discrimination Laws
2008 National Lawyers Convention
An employer is sued for hostile work environment harassment because it doesn't stop its employees...
Bar Watch Bulletin November 2003
Spirit of Excellence Awardees
--The ABA has announced its "Spirit of Excellence Awards" which will be presented by the...