Facts of the Case
A group of probation officers sued their employer, the State of Maine, in 1992 alleging that the state had violated the overtime provisions of the 1938 Fair Labor Standards Act. Following the Court's decision in Seminole Tribe v. Florida (1996) which held that States are immune from private suits in federal court and that Congress lacks the authority to abrogate that immunity the probation officers' suit was dismissed in Federal district court. Alden and the other probation officers then sued Maine again for violating the Fair Labor Standards Act, this time in state court. The state trial court and the state supreme court both held that Maine had sovereign immunity and could not be sued by private parties in their own court.
Questions
May Congress use its powers under Article I of the Constitution to abrogate a state's sovereign immunity from private suits in its own courts?
Conclusions
-
No. A sharply divided court held in a 5-4 decision that Congress may not use its Article I powers to abrogate the states' sovereign immunity. Both the terms and history of the eleventh amendment suggest that States are immune from suits in their own courts. And more generally, the original understanding of the Constitution's structure and the terms of the tenth amendment confirm that states retained much of their sovereignty despite their agreeing that the national government would be supreme when exercising its enumerated powers.
A Seat at the Sitting - March 2022
The March Docket in 90 Minutes or Less
Each month, a panel of constitutional experts convenes to discuss the Court’s upcoming docket sitting...
Courthouse Steps Decision Teleforum: Allen v. Cooper
Intellectual Property Practice Group Teleforum
Of Federalism, Copyright, and Blackbeard’s Revenge: The recent Supreme Court ruling in Allen v. Cooper is the...
Deep Dive Episode 76 – State-Sponsored Piracy? The Allen v. Cooper Case
Regulatory Transparency Project's Fourth Branch Podcast
What happens when a state agency uses without authorization copyrighted videos and pictures of Blackbeard’s...
Courthouse Steps: Supreme Court Overrules Nevada v. Hall Establishing Sister State Sovereign Immunity
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group
In Franchise Tax Board of California v. Hyatt, the Supreme Court has overturned a 40-year-old precedent in...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: Franchise Tax Board of California v. Hyatt: Reviving Sister-State Sovereign Immunity
A Teleforum Call Sponsored by the Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group
After Gilbert Hyatt, the petitioner, moved to Nevada he was investigated by the Franchise Tax...
The Supreme Court Tackles Patent Reform: Further Reflections on the Oil States Case after Oral Argument Before the Supreme Court
Federalist Society Review, Volume 19
Note from the Editor: This article provides alternative answers to some of the questions posed...
New Frontiers for Tribal Immunity: Patents, Pharmaceuticals, and the PTAB
The courts and Congress have long acknowledged the sovereign status of Native American tribes. Tribes,...
The States and the NLRB: A Study in Comparative Sovereignty
Engage Volume 12, Issue 3, November 2011
Under a system of government that diffuses power and makes institutional “[a]mbition . . ....
Intellectual Property: American Exceptionalism or International Harmonization?
2007 National Lawyers Convention
The Federalist Society's Intellectual Property Practice Group presented this panel discussion at the 2007 Annual...
Intellectual Property Rights and State Sovereign Immunity: The Recent Supreme Court Decisions
Intellectual Property Practice Group Newsletter - Volume 3, Issue 2, Summer 1999
On June 23, 1999, the last day of the most recent Supreme Court Term, the...
Congressional Control Over State Sovereign Immunity: The Recent Supreme Court Decisions
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group Newsletter - Volume 3, Issue 1, Spring 1999
On June 23, 1999, the last day of the most recent Supreme Court Term, the...