Facts of the Case
After the 2000 census reduced the size of the Pennsylvania Congressional delegation by two members, the Republican-controlled state legislature passed a redistricting plan that clearly benefitted Republican candidates. Several members of the Democratic party sued in federal court, claiming that the plan was unconstitutional because it violated the one-person, one-vote principle of Article I, Section 2 of Constitution, the Equal Protection clause, the Privileges and Immunities clause, and the freedom of association.
The district court dismissed all but the Article I, Section 2 claim. It held that the voters bringing the suit had not proved that they would be denied representation, only that they would be represented by Republican officials. Because the plaintiffs (those bringing the suit) were not denied the right to vote, to be placed on the ballot box, to associate as a party, or to express their political opinions, their political discrimination claims failed.
However, the court found the act unconstitutional because it created districts with different numbers of voters, thereby violating the one-person, one-vote principle. Because the plaintiffs had shown that it was possible to create districts with smaller differences, and because the defendants had failed to justify the disparities resulting under their plan, it was therefore unconstitutional.
Questions
Can voters affiliated with a political party sue to block implementation of a Congressional redistricting plan by claiming that it was manipulated for purely political reasons? Does a state violate the Equal Protection clause of the 14th Amendment when it disregards neutral redistricting principles (such as trying to avoid splitting municipalities into different Congressional districts) in order to achieve an advantage for one political party? Does a state exceed its power under Article I of the Constitution when it draws Congressional districts to ensure that a minority party will consistently win a super-majority of the state's Congressional seats?
Conclusions
-
In a split decision that had no majority opinion, the Court decided not to intervene in this case because no appropriate judicial solution could be found. Justice Antonin Scalia, for a four-member plurality, wrote that the Court should declare all claims related to political (but not racial) gerrymandering nonjusticiable, meaning that courts could not hear them. Because no court had been able to find an appropriate remedy to political gerrymandering claims in the 18 years since the Court decided Davis v. Bandemer, 478 U.S. 109, which had held that such a remedy had not been found yet but might exist, Scalia wrote that it was time to recognize that the solution simply did not exist.
Justice Anthony Kennedy, however, wrote in his concurring opinion (which provided the deciding fifth vote for the judgment) that the Court should rule narrowly in this case that no appropriate judicial solution could be found, but not give up on finding one eventually.
Why Proportional Representation Will Not Stem Redistricting Litigation But Will Undermine Normative Representative Values
Federalist Society Review, Volume 21
Note from the Editor: The Federalist Society takes no positions on particular legal and public...
Courthouse Steps Decision: The Gerrymandering Cases, Rucho et al. v. Common Cause et al.
On June 27, the Supreme Court decided several redistricting cases in Rucho et al. v. Common...
Partisan Gerrymandering and Party Rights: Why Gill v. Whitford Undermines All Future Partisan-Gerrymandering Claims
Federalist Society Review, Volume 19
Note from the Editor: This article discusses the Supreme Court’s opinion in Gill v. Whitford...
Courthouse Steps: Gerrymandering in the Supreme Court
Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group Teleforum
The U.S. Supreme Court's docket included three cases this term on the legal limits of...
Gill v. Whitford - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast featuring David Casazza
On October 3, 2017, the Supreme Court heard argument in Gill v. Whitford, a case...
Supreme Court Preview: What Is in Store for October Term 2017?
Co-Sponsored by the Faculty Division and the Practice Groups
October 2nd will mark the first day of oral arguments for the 2017 Supreme Court...
SCOTUS Opinions & Orders Update
OPINIONS (1) Ziglar v. Abbasi (with Ashcroft v. Abbasi and Hasty v. Abbasi): By a vote of 4-2, the...
Courthouse Steps: Cooper v. Harris Redistricting Update - Podcast
Free Speech and Election Law Practice Group Podcast
On May 22, the Supreme Court threw out two North Carolina congressional districts as discriminatory....
The Legacy of Justice Scalia
2017 Annual Florida Chapters Conference
This panel, The Legacy of Justice Scalia, was held on February 3, 2017, at the...
Packing Districts?: Harris v. Arizona Independent Redistricting Commission - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
Last term, in a 5-4 decision, the Supreme Court upheld Arizona’s independent redistricting commission. State...
Shapiro v. McManus - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 12-14-15 featuring Michael T. Morley
On December 8, 2015, the Supreme Court decided Shapiro v. McManus. In this case several Maryland...
Part II: Can States Require Proof of Citizenship for Voter Registration?: Arizona v. Inter Tribal Council of Arizona
Engage Volume 14, Issue 3 October 2013
Note from the Editor: This article discusses the Arizona v. Inter Tribal Council of Arizona...
Can States Require Proof of Citizenship for Voter Registration?--Arizona v. Inter Tribal Council of Arizona
Engage Volume 14, Issue 1 February 2013
Introduction This term the Court will hear a case examining a perceived clash between state...