Facts of the Case
Since 1997, Microsoft has operated a web-based email service available for public use without charge (most recently called Outlook.com). Much of the data associated with this service is saved on datacenters operated by Microsoft and its subsidiaries, which are located throughout the world.
In 2013, Microsoft was served with a search and seizure warrant for the data pertaining to a particular user. That user's data was stored solely in Microsoft's datacenter in Dublin, Ireland. Microsoft disclosed all other responsive information requested in the warrant but moved the magistrate judge to quash the warrant with respect to the user data stored in Dublin. The magistrate judge denied Microsoft's motion to quash, finding that the Stored Communications Act (SCA) authorized the district court to issue a warrant for "information that is stored on servers abroad." The magistrate judge held that the place where the government would review the content (the United States), not the place where the content was stored (Ireland) was the relevant place of seizure.
Microsoft appealed the magistrate judge's decision, and the district court affirmed after reviewing de novo. The district court also held Microsoft in civil contempt for refusing to comply fully with the warrant. The Second Circuit held that the SCA does not authorize courts to issue and enforce against US-based service providers warrants for the seizure of customer email content that is stored exclusively on foreign servers and thus reversed the district court's denial of the motion to quash, vacated the finding of contempt, and remanded the case to the district court.
Questions
Is an email provider who has been served with a warrant required, under 18 U.S.C. § 2703, to provide the federal government with emails, even when the email records are stored exclusively outside the United States?
Conclusions
-
While this case was pending, Congress passed and the President signed into law the Clarifying Lawful Overseas Use of Data Act, which amended the Stored Communications Act, 18 U.S.C. § 2701, et seq., to require email providers to disclose emails in its "possession, custody, or control," even if the emails are stored outside the United States. The government then procured and served Microsoft with a new warrant pursuant to the amended law, and the parties agreed that the new warrant had replaced the original warrant at issue in this case. The Court explained that because there was no longer any live dispute between the parties, the case had become moot. The Court vacated the ruling on review and remanded the case to the Second Circuit with instructions to vacate the district court's contempt finding and its denial of Microsoft's motion to quash, and to direct the district court to dismiss the case as moot.
Hon. Robert H. Bork Memorial Lecture
2022 National Lawyers Convention
The 2022 National Lawyers Convention will take place November 10-12, 2022 at the Mayflower Hotel in...
Panel II: Antitrust in the the Age of the Trillion-Dollar Company
A National Symposium on Law and Technology
Featuring: A. Douglas Melamed, Professor, Stanford Law School, and ex-General Counsel, Intel Aaron Schur, Deputy General...
Panel One: How We Got Here: The Evolution of Antitrust Law and the Consumer Welfare Standard
The Antitrust Paradox: Where We've Been and Where We're Going
On September 15, 2021, The Federalist Society's Practice Groups hosted a conference titled The Antitrust...
Department of Justice: Executive Supervision or Independence?
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group Teleforum
On June 17, 2021, The Federalist Society's Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group hosted...
An Interview with Makan Delrahim, Former Assistant Attorney General for the Department of Justice Antitrust Division
Svetlana S. Gans, a member of the Federalist Society’s Corporations, Securities, & Antitrust Practice Group...
Fireside Chat with Bilal Sayyed, former FTC Director, Office of Policy Planning
The Federalist Society's Corporations, Securities & Antitrust Practice Group and Regulatory Transparency Project are pleased...
Why the DOJ Has a Strong Case Against Google
That's Debatable is a new blog initiative bringing together legal and policy experts with differing...
Deep Dive Episode 144 – United States v. Google: Examining the Historic Antitrust Case Against Big Tech
Regulatory Transparency Project's Fourth Branch Podcast
On October 20, 2020, the Department of Justice (DOJ) filed its much-anticipated lawsuit against Google....
United States v. Google
Corporations, Antitrust & Securities Practice Group and The Bork Foundation Teleforum
This week, the United States Department of Justice launched its rumored antitrust law suit against...
Antitrust Populism and the Conservative Movement
Pennsylvania Student Chapter
On October 7, 2020, the Federalist Society's Pennsylvania Student Chapter and the Regulatory Transparency Project...
Deep Dive Episode 137 – Antitrust Populism and the Conservative Movement
Regulatory Transparency Project's Fourth Branch Podcast
On October 7, 2020, the Federalist Society's Pennsylvania Student Chapter and the Regulatory Transparency Project...
FTC v. Qualcomm: The Ninth Circuit on Tech Antitrust
Please join us for a teleforum discussing the Ninth Circuit’s recent opinion in this important case,...
Deep Dive Episode 123 – Antitrust Investigations into Big Tech Companies
A Regulatory Transparency Project Teleforum
American tech companies like Google, Apple, Facebook, and Amazon are some of the most successful...
Do We Need to Rethink Antitrust for Big Tech?
Penn Law Federalist Society Symposium: Regulating Big Tech
On March 4, 2020, the Regulatory Transparency Project sponsored a symposium with the University of...
The Future of Antitrust: New Challenges to the Consumer Welfare Paradigm and Legislative Proposals
2019 National Lawyers Convention
On November 14, 2019, the Federalist Society's Corporations, Securities, & Antitrust Practice Group hosted a...
Panel Two: Regulation of Big Tech
Third Circuit Chapters Conference
On October 24, 2019, The Federalist Society held its annual Third Circuit Chapters Conference. This...
Social Media Oversight: The Debate Over Regulation and Antitrust Enforcement on Tech Titans
Russian interference in the 2016 election, Facebook and Cambridge Analytica, and claims of political bias...
Panel I: Generational Impact of The Antitrust
Antitrust Paradox Conference
In 1978, Judge Robert Bork published the book The Antitrust Paradox. The Antitrust Paradox has become one of...
Opening Remarks
Antitrust Paradox Conference
Featuring: Hon. Makan Delrahim, Assistant Attorney General, Antitrust Division, Department of Justice Introduction: Dean Reuter,...
Clean Power Plan Litigation Update - Podcast
Environmental Law & Property Rights Practice Group Podcast
On Tuesday, September 27, the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals will hear West Virginia v....
Panel I: Capitalism and Inequality
2016 National Student Symposium
Free markets have exponentially improved the well-being of humanity and lifted more people out of...
Antitrust and High-tech: Regulatory Risks for Innovation and Competition
Engage Volume 14, Issue 1 February 2013
I. Target Selection in an Innovation Economy A. Regulatory Power, Regulations’ Problems, and Antitrust While...
U.S. v. Microsoft, 10 Years Later: Who Won, Who Lost, and Did It Matter?
San Francisco Lawyers Chapter
Ten years ago, Microsoft dominated the personal computer market with its ever-expanding operating system. Today,...
U.S. v. Microsoft, 10 Years Later: Who Won, Who Lost, and Did It Matter?
San Francisco Lawyers Chapter
Ten years ago, Microsoft dominated the personal computer market with its ever-expanding operating system. Today,...
Is Google Monopolizing Something, and If So, What?
Corporations, Securities and Antitrust Practice Group
Last June, Christine Varney, then a lawyer in private practice, now President Obama's nominee to...
Intellectual Property: American Exceptionalism or International Harmonization?
2007 National Lawyers Convention
The Federalist Society's Intellectual Property Practice Group presented this panel discussion at the 2007 Annual...
Regulatory Double-Dipping
2006 National Lawyers Convention
The Federalist Society's Corporations Practice Group presented this panel discussion at the 2006 Annual National...
CLOUD Act
TeleforumCourthouse Steps: U.S. v. Microsoft
Corporations, Securities, and Antitrust Practice Group Teleforum
TeleforumU.S. v. Microsoft, 10 Years Later: Who Won, Who Lost, and Did It Matter?
San Francisco Lawyers Chapter
Bingham McCutchen3 Embarcadero Center
San Francisco, CA 94111