Facts of the Case
The 1992 Cable Television Consumer Protection and Competition Act required cable television systems to set aside some of their channels for local broadcast television. In 1994, the Supreme Court held that these must-carry provisions pass constitutional muster. (See Turner Broadcasting v. FCC, decided June 27, 1994). The Court then remanded the case to determine whether Congress had adequate factual support for its conclusion that the must-carry provision is necessary. A special three-judge district court held that there was sufficient evidence that the must-carry provision furthered important governmental objectives and that the provision was narrowly tailored to promote those interests. The broadcasters appealed directly to the Supreme Court.
Questions
Is the 1992 "must carry" law an unconstitutional intrusion on cable operators' editorial autonomy, a form of Government-compelled speech that violates the First Amendment?
Conclusions
-
No. In a 5-to-4 decision, the Court held that Congress "has an independent interest in preserving a multiplicity of broadcasters." The outcome supported Congress's right to judge what approach would best insure a competitive communications marketplace.
Showcase Panel II: Private Control Over Public Discussion
2021 National Lawyers Convention
The 2021 National Lawyers Convention took place November 11-13, 2021 at the Mayflower Hotel in...
Panel III: Speech-Policing the Virtual Town Square
A National Symposium on Law and Technology
Featuring: Brian Barnes, Partner, Cooper & Kirk PLLC Antonio García-Martínez, Author, Chaos Monkeys, and ex-Advisor, Twitter Michael...
Private Entities and Public Concern
Freedom of Thought Six-Part Series: Part 6
Aside from the purely legal questions already addressed in this programming series, how should we...
Limiting the Right to Exclude: Common Carrier and Market Dominance
Freedom of Thought Six-Part Zoom Webinar Series: Part 3
The recent concurrence by Justice Thomas in Biden v. Knight First Amendment Institute has raised new questions about how...
Free Speech and Compelled Speech: First Amendment Challenges to a Marketplace of Ideas
Freedom of Thought Six-Part Series: Part 1
Section 230 has been understood to shield internet platforms from liability for content posted by...
Debate: Social Media, Free Speech, and Section 230
Southwest Florida Lawyers Chapter - Online Event
On March 18, 2021, the Federalist Society's Southwest Florida Lawyers Chapter hosted Prof. Eugene Volokh...
Broadcast Journalism and the First Amendment: A Conversation with the FCC’s General Counsel
Broadcasters—not the FCC—are responsible for selecting the material that they air. This is why the...
To Bear Arms for Self-Defense: A “Right of the People” or a Privilege of the Few? Part 2
Federalist Society Review, Volume 21
Note from the Editor: The Federalist Society takes no positions on particular legal and public...
Freedom of Speech and Private Power
2019 National Lawyers Convention
On November 15, 2019, the Federalist Society's Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group hosted...
A Reader on Net Neutrality and Restoring Internet Freedom
In December 2017, the Federal Communications Commission adopted its landmark Restoring Internet Freedom Order that...
Litigation Update: United States Telecom Association v. Federal Communications Commission - Podcast
Telecommunications Practice Group Podcast
On May 1, the D.C. Circuit denied petitions for en banc review of United States...
The FCC Forgot Something in Piecing Together Its Complex Proposal for Broadband Privacy Regulation: Consumers
Federalist Society Review, Volume 17, Issue 3
Note from the Editor: This article discusses the FCC’s proposed rules for broadband privacy, and...
Net Neutrality Litigation - Podcast
Litigation Practice Group Podcast
After suffering two judicial setbacks, most recently in the D.C. Circuit’s Verizon v. FCC decision...
Free Speech and Hostile Environment "Harassment"
Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group Newsletter - Volume 1, Issue 2, Spring 1997
Harassment claims are often based primarily on speech, such as allegedly racist or sexist comments,...