Facts of the Case
The Fourteenth Amendment protects every person's right to due process of law. The Fifteenth Amendment protects citizens from having their right to vote abridged or denied due to "race, color, or previous condition of servitude." The Tenth Amendment reserves all rights not granted to the federal government to the individual states. Article Four of the Constitution guarantees the right of self-government for each state.
The Voting Rights Act of 1965 was enacted as a response to the nearly century-long history of voting discrimination. Section 5 prohibits eligible districts from enacting changes to their election laws and procedures without gaining official authorization. Section 4(b) defines the eligible districts as ones that had a voting test in place as of November 1, 1964 and less than 50% turnout for the 1964 presidential election. Such districts must prove to the Attorney General or a three-judge panel of a Washington, D.C. district court that the change "neither has the purpose nor will have the effect" of negatively impacting any individual's right to vote based on race or minority status. Section 5 was originally enacted for five years, but has been continually renewed since that time.
Shelby County, Alabama, filed suit in district court and sought both a declaratory judgment that Section 5 and Section 4(b) are unconstitutional and a permanent injunction against their enforcement. The district court upheld the constitutionality of the Sections and granted summary judgment for the Attorney General. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit held that Congress did not exceed its powers by reauthorizing Section 5 and that Section 4(b) is still relevant to the issue of voting discrimination.
Questions
Does the renewal of Section 5 of the Voter Rights Act under the constraints of Section 4(b) exceed Congress' authority under the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Amendments, and therefore violate the Tenth Amendment and Article Four of the Constitution?
Conclusions
-
Yes, Section 4 of the Voting Rights Act is unconstitutional. Chief Justice John G. Roberts, Jr. delivered the opinion of the 5-4 majority. The Court held that Section 4 of the Voting Rights Act imposes current burdens that are no longer responsive to the current conditions in the voting districts in question. Although the constraints this section places on specific states made sense in the 1960s and 1970s, they do not any longer and now represent an unconstitutional violation of the power to regulate elections that the Constitution reserves for the states. The Court also held that the formula for determining whether changes to a state's voting procedure should be federally reviewed is now outdated and does not reflect the changes that have occurred in the last 50 years in narrowing the voting turnout gap in the states in question.
In his concurring opinion, Justice Clarence Thomas argued that Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act is unconstitutional in addition to Section 4. He wrote that the blatant discrimination against certain voters that Section 5 was intended to prohibit is no longer evident. Without such extraordinary circumstances, Congress cannot constitutionally justify placing the burden of Section 5 on the states in question.
Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg wrote a dissent in which she argued that Congress' power to enforce the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Amendments encompasses legislative action such as the Voting Rights Act. The legislative history and text of the Amendments as well as previous judicial precedent support Congress' authority to enact legislation that specifically targets potential state abuses. However, Congress does not have unlimited authority but must show that the means taken rationally advance a legitimate objective, as is the case with the Voting Rights Act. The evidence Congress gathered to determine whether to renew the Voting Rights Act sufficiently proved that there was still a current need to justify the burdens placed on the states in question. She also argued that, by holding Section 4 unconstitutional, the majority's opinion makes it impossible to effectively enforce Section 5. Justice Stephen G. Breyer, Justice Sonia Sotomayor, and Justice Elena Kagan joined in the dissent.
Plenary Session 3: From Sea to Shining Sea—Lawfare and Hot Topics in State Legislatures
Inaugural Legislative Branch Summit
Featuring: Hon. Derek Brown, Attorney General, State of Utah Mr. O.H. Skinner, Executive Director, Alliance...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: Louisiana v. Callais (Round 2)
Louisiana's congressional districts, which it redrew following the 2020 census, currently sit in a state...
Litigation Update: AAER v. Fearless Fund
The Fearless Fund ran the “Strivers Grant Contest,” which awards $20,000 and other benefits “only...
Panel II: The Democratic Election Process: What is Fair and Who Decides Fairness?
2023 National Student Symposium
Democracy begins with elections. But the process for voting in our elections has been increasingly...
Panel I: What is Democracy?
2023 National Student Symposium
There has been much discussion about threats to democracy over the past year. But conceptions...
William S. Consovoy, 1974-2023
To commemorate the repose of Will Consovoy, we will be posting reflections and expressions of...
Panel One: Redistricting in Florida: 2010s vs. 2020s
Eighth Annual Florida Chapters Conference
The first panel of the Federalist Society's Eighth Annual Florida Chapters Conference featured an impressive...
Federal Consent Decrees: Good Governance, an Expansion of Federal Power, or Both?
2021 National Lawyers Convention
The 2021 National Lawyers Convention took place November 11-13, 2021 at the Mayflower Hotel in...
Panel One: Racial Preferences in Higher Education: What are the Consequences and What Will the Supreme Court Do?
2021 Third Circuit Chapters Conference
Despite the fact that Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibits racial...
Courthouse Steps Decision Webinar: Brnovich v. Democratic National Convention
Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group Teleforum
On July 1, 2021, the Supreme Court issued its decision in Brnovich, Attorney General of Arizona...
Deep Dive Episode 184 – Federalism or a Federal Standard? Fuel Economy and Greenhouse Gas Emissions Standards
Regulatory Transparency Project's Fourth Branch Podcast
Federal and state government authority to mandate automobile manufacturers and consumers switch to electric cars...
Supreme Court Review: Justice Gorsuch at Year One
2018 Texas Chapters Conference
On September 7-8, 2018, the Federalist Society's Fort Worth Lawyers Chapter hosted the fourth annual...
The Supreme Court in Crisis: A Good Read, But No Crisis
Federalist Society Review, Volume 19
A review of: American Justice 2017: The Supreme Court in Crisis, by Kimberly Robinson (University...
The Supreme Court in Crisis: A Good Read, But No Crisis
Federalist Society Review, Volume 19
A review of: American Justice 2017: The Supreme Court in Crisis, by Kimberly Robinson (University...
Hate Crimes and the Thirteenth Amendment
Hate crimes are abhorrent to all decent persons. But does Congress have the power to...
Hate Crimes and the Thirteenth Amendment
Hate crimes are abhorrent to all decent persons. But does Congress have the power to...
Nevada Recall
Civil Rights Practice Group
A current lawsuit in federal court in Nevada is endeavoring to stop a recall election...
Showcase Panel IV: Administrative Agencies and the Separation of Powers
2017 National Lawyers Convention
This panel will examine the history of the emergence of the Administrative State and will...
Is Everyone Now for Federalism?
2017 National Lawyers Convention
President Trump's administration has helped renew interest in federalism among Democrats and liberals. Is there...
Congressional Oversight of Voting Rights
Fifth Annual Executive Branch Review Conference
The Fifth Annual Executive Branch Review Conference will examine the changing and often convoluted relationship...
Courthouse Steps: Cooper v. Harris Redistricting Update - Podcast
Free Speech and Election Law Practice Group Podcast
On May 22, the Supreme Court threw out two North Carolina congressional districts as discriminatory....
New Applications of Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act to Vote Denial Cases
Federalist Society Review, Volume 18
Note from the Editor: This article discusses recent federal appellate court decisions with respect to...
The Thirteenth Amendment 150 Years Later
19th Annual Faculty Conference
December 2015 marked 150 years since the ratification of the Thirteenth Amendment—an occasion of singular...
McCrory v. Harris and Bethune-Hill v. Virginia State Board of Elections - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 12-21-16 featuring Jack Park
On December 5, 2016, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in McCrory v. Harris and...
Texas State Bar Racial and Gender Quotas Head to Court
In a recent ad, the State Bar of Texas announced that it is accepting applications for...
The Morality of Consent - Podcast
Professional Responsibilities Practice Group Podcast
The Federalist Society's Legal Classics Revisited series returns to the writing of Professor Alexander Bickel...
Stolen Sovereignty: How to Stop Unelected Judges from Transforming America - Podcast
Administrative Law & Regulation Practice Group Podcast
Stolen Sovereignty: How to Stop Unelected Judges from Transforming America, by Daniel Horowitz, discusses the...
Voter ID: A Debate - Podcast
Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group Podcast
Recent North Carolina, North Dakota, Texas, and Wisconsin court decisions have invalidated voter ID laws...
Court Rulings on Election Law - Podcast
Civil Rights and Free Speech & Election Law Practice Groups Teleforum
There have been a series of recent court decisions at both the federal district court...
Packing Districts?: Supreme Court Decides Harris v. Arizona Independent Redistricting Commission - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
On April 20, the United States Supreme Court issued a unanimous opinion in Harris v....
Wittman v. Personhuballah - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 3-30-16 featuring Derek Muller
On March 21, 2016, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Wittman v. Personhuballah. In...
New Jersey Doubles Down on Sports Betting - Podcast
Litigation Practice Group Podcast
The Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act (PASPA) forbids any state (other than Nevada) from...
Harris v. Arizona Independent Redistricting Commission - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 2-11-16 featuring Mark F. Hearne II
On December 8, 2015, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Harris v. Arizona Independent...
Harris v. Arizona Independent Redistricting Commission - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 2-11-16 featuring Mark F. Hearne II
On December 8, 2015, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Harris v. Arizona Independent...
Packing Districts?: Harris v. Arizona Independent Redistricting Commission - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
Last term, in a 5-4 decision, the Supreme Court upheld Arizona’s independent redistricting commission. State...
Litigation: Ten Years of the Roberts Court
2015 National Lawyers Convention
It has been ten years since John Roberts was appointed as the 17th Chief Justice...
2015 ABA Annual Meeting Report: Programming
From July 30th to August 4th, the American Bar Association met in Chicago for its...
2015 ABA Annual Meeting Report: Programming
From July 30th to August 4th, the American Bar Association met in Chicago for its...
Alabama Legislative Black Caucus v. Alabama - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 5-28-15 featuring Stephen Davis
On March 25, 2015 the Supreme Court decided Alabama Legislative Black Caucus v. Alabama, which...
Disparate Impact Liability and the Fair Housing Act: Texas Department of Housing and Community Affairs v. The Inclusive Communities Project, Inc. - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
On Wednesday, January 21, 2015, the Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Texas Department of...
Challenging Racial Preferences in Government Contracts - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
While the Supreme Court in City of Richmond v. J.A. Croson Co. (1989) and Adarand...
Supreme Court Preview: What Is in Store for October Term 2014?
Co-Sponsored by the Faculty Division and the Practice Groups
October 6th will mark the first day of the 2014 Supreme Court term. Thus far, the...
Panel III: The Future of Voting Rights
Civil Rights in the United States
The Supreme Court’s ruling in Shelby County v. Holder, which disabled Section 5 of the Voting...
Panel III: The Future of Voting Rights
Civil Rights in the United States
The Supreme Court’s ruling in Shelby County v. Holder, which disabled Section 5 of the Voting...
Harris v. Quinn - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 7-28-14 featuring Andrew Grossman
On June 30, 2014, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Harris v. Quinn. The...
Unionizing Domestic Workers?: Harris v. Quinn Decided - Podcast
Labor & Employment Law Practice Group Podcast
Is Harris v. Quinn a landmark in labor law? The case asked the Court to decide...
Is the Matthew Shepard and James Byrd Jr. Hate Crimes Act in Part Unconstitutional? - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
Congress premised the part of the Hate Crimes Prevention Act banning crimes based on race...
Closing Panel: The Electorate and the Courts
2013 National Lawyers Convention
The Federalist Society's Practice Groups presented this panel on "The Electorate and the Courts" on...
Civil Rights: Use of Disparate Impact Analysis
2013 National Lawyers Convention
A number of commentators have noted an expansion of the use of disparate impact analysis...
Testimony on “The Voting Rights Act after the Supreme Court’s Decision in Shelby County”
Engage Volume 14, Issue 2 July 2013
Note from the Editor: This article is based on testimony given by the author before...
Testimony on “The Voting Rights Act after the Supreme Court’s Decision in Shelby County”
Engage Volume 14, Issue 2 July 2013
Note from the Editor: This article is based on testimony given by the author before...
The Court Decides: The Prop 8 and DOMA Cases - Podcast
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group and Religious Liberties Practice Group Podcast
On June 26th, the U.S. Supreme Court decided two same sex marriage cases: the Proposition...
Shelby County Going Forward - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group and Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group Podcast
On Tuesday, June 25, the U.S. Supreme Court decided Shelby County v. Holder, a Voting Rights...
2013 Annual Supreme Court Round Up
Washington, DC Lawyers Chapter
On July 8, 2013, Miguel Estrada of Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP delivered the Annual Supreme...
Shelby County v. Holder - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 7-8-13 featuring Abigail Thernstrom
On June 25, 2013, the Supreme Court announced its decision in Shelby County v. Holder....
Shelby County v. Holder - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 7-8-13 featuring Abigail Thernstrom
On June 25, 2013, the Supreme Court announced its decision in Shelby County v. Holder....
The Growing Use of Disparate Impact Analysis - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
The use of disparate impact analysis is growing very rapidly, and it is becoming the...
Debate on Fisher and Shelby County - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group, American Constitution Society, and National Constitution Center Podcast
The Federalist Society co-sponsored a Teleforum call with the National Constitution Center and the American...
Patenting Human DNA: The Court's Decision - Podcast
Intellectual Property Practice Group Podcast
To listen, please right click on the audio file you wish to hear and then...
Shelby County, Alabama v. Holder: Must Congress Update the Voting Rights Act’s Coverage Formula for Preclearance?
Engage Volume 14, Issue 1 February 2013
Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act requires “covered jurisdictions”—mostly, but not exclusively, in the...
Shelby County, Alabama v. Holder: Must Congress Update the Voting Rights Act’s Coverage Formula for Preclearance?
Engage Volume 14, Issue 1 February 2013
Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act requires “covered jurisdictions”—mostly, but not exclusively, in the...
Why the Supreme Court Should Strike Down Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act
Indianapolis Lawyers Chapter
On March 11, 2013, the Indianapolis Lawyers Chapter of the Federalist Society hosted an event...
The Voting Rights Act in the Supreme Court: Shelby County v. Holder - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
On Wednesday, February 27, the U.S. Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Shelby County v. Holder....
The Voting Rights Act in the Supreme Court: Shelby County v. Holder - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
On Wednesday, February 27, the U.S. Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Shelby County v. Holder....
Is American Justice Blind, Or Blind To A "Prosecutocracy"? - Podcast
Criminal Law & Procedure Practice Group Podcast
Federal convict Conrad Lord Black argued at National Review Online last fall in "Blind Justice" that America's...
Your DNA: Maryland v. King - Podcast
Criminal Law & Procedure Practice Group Podcast
On February 26, 2013, the U.S. Supreme Court heard oral argument in the case of Maryland...
Gun Control: Assessing Constitutionality and Effectiveness - Podcast
Criminal Law & Procedure Practice Group Podcast
President Obama has proposed, and Congress is currently debating, various gun control measures in reaction...
Shelby County v. Holder - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 2-27-13 featuring Michael Carvin
On February 27, 2013, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Shelby County v. Holder. The...
Shelby County v. Holder - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 2-27-13 featuring Michael Carvin
On February 27, 2013, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Shelby County v. Holder. The...
Sleeping Giant?: Section Two of the Thirteenth Amendment, Hate Crimes Legislation, and Academia’s Favorite New Vehicle for the Expansion of Federal Power
Engage Volume 13, Issue 3 October 2012
A brief look at the Thirteenth Amendment might suggest that it has rather limited application...
Supreme Court Preview: What Is in Store for October Term 2012?
Co-sponsored by the Practice Groups, the Washington DC Lawyers Chapter, and the Faculty Division
October 1st marks the first day of the 2012 Supreme Court Term. Thus far the...
Is Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act Constitutional? - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
To listen, please right click on the audio file you wish to hear and then...
Is Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act Constitutional? - Podcast
Civil Rights Practice Group Podcast
To listen, please right click on the audio file you wish to hear and then...
2021 National Lawyers Convention
Public and Private Power: Preserving Freedom or Preventing Harm?
The Mayflower Hotel1127 Connecticut Avenue, NW
Washington, DC 20036
Courthouse Steps Decision Webinar: Brnovich v. Democratic National Convention
Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group Teleforum
TeleforumShelby County v. Holder Five Years Later
Ohio Northern Student Chapter
Tilton Hall of Law415 S. Gilbert Street
Ada, OH 45810
Civil Rights in the United States
Sponsored by the Federalist Society's Civil Rights Practice Group, the Cato Institute, and the Heritage Foundation
The Mayflower Hotel1127 Connecticut Avenue, N.W.
Washington, DC 20036