Facts of the Case
Christopher Simmons was sentenced to death in 1993, when he was only 17. A series of appeals to state and federal courts lasted until 2002, but each appeal was rejected. Then, in 2002, the Missouri Supreme Court stayed Simmon's execution while the U.S. Supreme Court decided Atkins v. Virginia, a case that dealt with the execution of the mentally disabled. After the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that executing the mentally disabled (or "mentally retarded" in the vernacular of the day) violated the Eighth and 14th Amendment prohibitions on cruel and unusual punishment because a majority of Americans found it cruel and unusual, the Missouri Supreme Court decided to reconsider Simmons' case.
Using the reasoning from the Atkins case, the Missouri court decided, 6-to-3, that the U.S. Supreme Court's 1989 decision in Stanford v. Kentucky, which held that executing minors was not unconstitutional, was no longer valid. The opinion in Stanford v. Kentucky had relied on a finding that a majority of Americans did not consider the execution of minors to be cruel and unusual. The Missouri court, citing numerous laws passed since 1989 that limited the scope of the death penalty, held that national opinion had changed. Finding that a majority of Americans were now opposed to the execution of minors, the court held that such executions were now unconstitutional.
On appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court, the government argued that allowing a state court to overturn a Supreme Court decision by looking at "evolving standards" would be dangerous, because state courts could just as easily decide that executions prohibited by the Supreme Court (such as the execution of the mentally ill in Atkins v. Virginia) were now permissible due to a change in the beliefs of the American people.
Questions
Does the execution of minors violate the prohibition of "cruel and unusual punishment" found in the Eighth Amendment and applied to the states through the incorporation doctrine of the 14th Amendment?
Conclusions
-
Yes. In a 5-4 opinion delivered by Justice Anthony Kennedy, the Court ruled that standards of decency have evolved so that executing minors is "cruel and unusual punishment" prohibited by the Eighth Amendment. The majority cited a consensus against the juvenile death penalty among state legislatures, and its own determination that the death penalty is a disproportionate punishment for minors. Finally the Court pointed to "overwhelming" international opinion against the juvenile death penalty. Chief Justice William Rehnquist and Justices Antonin Scalia, Sandra Day O'Connor, and Clarence Thomas all dissented.
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument Teleforum: Mathena v. Malvo (D.C. Sniper Case)
Criminal Law Practice Group Teleforum
Lee Boyd Malvo and John Allen Muhammad killed 10 people in 2002. The attacks took...
Capital Punishment After the 2016 Elections - Podcast
Criminal Law & Procedure Practice Group Podcast
In recent decades, there has been much study and debate in the criminal justice community...
Capital Punishment Once Again Before the Supreme Court: Kansas v. Gleason and Kansas v. Carr - Podcast
Criminal Law & Procedure Practice Group Podcast
Somewhat overlooked at the end of the United States Supreme Court’s October 2014 term was...
Jackson v. Hobbs and Miller v. Alabama - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 03-28-12 featuring John Stinneford
On March 20, 2012 the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Jackson v. Hobbs and Miller v. Alabama....
J.D.B. v. North Carolina - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 08-04-11 featuring Carissa Byrne Hessick
On June 16, 2011, the Supreme Court announced its decision in J.D.B. v. North Carolina....
J.D.B. v. North Carolina - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 04-14-11 featuring Carissa Byrne Hessick
On March 23, 2011, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in J.D.B. v. North Carolina,...
Supreme Court October Term 2009: What Is in Store?
October 5th marks the first day of the 2009 Supreme Court term. Thus far the...
International Law as an Interpretive Aid in Supreme Court Jurisprudence
The Supreme Court’s use of international and foreign law has garnered substantial commentary in recent...
A Look Back at the October Supreme Court 2007 Term
Is the DC gun ban constitutional? Do Guantanamo Bay prisoners have a constitutional right to...
Supreme Court Term
Online Debate
The Supreme Court ended its OT07 term on June 26, 2008. We are hosting a live...