Facts of the Case
Minnesota's Constitution provides for the selection of all state judges by popular election. The announcement clause of the Minnesota Supreme Court's canon of judicial conduct prohibits a candidate from announcing his or her views on disputed legal or political issues. While running for associate justice of the Minnesota Supreme Court, Gregory Wersal filed suit, seeking a declaration that the announce clause violates the First Amendment and an injunction against its enforcement. Wersal alleged that he was forced to refrain from announcing his views on disputed issues during the 1998 campaign, to the point where he declined response to questions put to him by the press and public, out of concern that he might run afoul of the announce clause. The District Court found that the announcement clause did not violate the First Amendment. The Court of Appeals affirmed.
Questions
Does the First Amendment permit the Minnesota Supreme Court to prohibit candidates for judicial election in that State from announcing their views on disputed legal and political issues?
Conclusions
-
No. In a 5-4 opinion delivered by Justice Antonin Scalia, the Court held that the announce clause violates the First Amendment. The Court reasoned that the announce clause prohibits speech based on its content and burdens a category of speech that is at the core of First Amendment freedoms - speech about the qualifications of candidates for public office. Moreover, the Court concluded that the clause did not serve to preserve the state judiciary's impartiality, its argued compelling state interest. "There is an obvious tension between the article of Minnesota's popularly approved Constitution which provides that judges shall be elected, and the Minnesota Supreme Court's announce clause which places most subjects of interest to the voters off limits," wrote Justice Scalia.
Judicial Elections and Free Speech
Varying Approaches to Handling the Intersection of Judicial Elections and the Constitutional Guarantee of the Right to Free Speech
Judicial selection in the states is not uniform, but most states have some form of...
Panel II: The Future of the Wisconsin Supreme Court
Panelists will offer their diverse perspectives on the current state of the Wisconsin Supreme Court...
Judicial Selection in Kentucky
2018 Kentucky Chapters Conference
On October 29, 2018, the Federalist Society's Kentucky lawyers chapters hosted the second annual Kentucky...
Ethics CLE Teleforum 2018: New Issue in Legal Ethics, ABA Model Rule 8.4(g)
Professional Responsibilities and Legal Education Practice Group
Professional Responsibility & Legal Education Practice Group Teleforum CLE not offered if Teleforum listened to...
The Case for Political Appointment of Judges
State Courts Project Teleforum
Join us in a discussion with our experts, Professor Brian Fitzpatrick and Professor Stephen Ware,...
Williams-Yulee v. The Florida Bar - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 5-14-15 featuring Brian Fitzpatrick and Erik Jaffe
On January 20, 2015, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Williams-Yulee v. The Florida...
Supreme Court Upholds Ban on Judicial Election Fundraising - Podcast
Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group Podcast
On April 29, the United States Supreme Court issued a 5-4 opinion in Williams-Yulee v....
Williams-Yulee v. The Florida Bar - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 2-5-15 featuring Erik Jaffe and Ed Whelan
On January 20, 2015, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Williams-Yulee v. The Florida...
35 Years of Retention Elections of Appellate Court Judges in Florida: Has the System Measured Up?
Miami Lawyers Chapter
On September 11, 2012, the Miami Lawyers Chapter hosted a debate on "35 Years of...
Judicial Elections and Speech Restrictions - Podcast
Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group Podcast
To listen, please right click on the audio file you wish to hear and then...
A Survey of Empirical Evidence Concerning Judicial Elections
State Courts White Paper
The election of state judges is a controversial topic. Consider, for example, this quote from...
A Survey of Empirical Evidence Concerning Judicial Elections
State Courts White Paper
The election of state judges is a controversial topic. Consider, for example, this quote from...
Panel Discussion on Judicial Selection in North Carolina
Triangle Lawyers Chapter
Although North Carolina currently elects its judicial officials, various groups are pushing to eliminate judicial...
Panel 3: Judicial Ethics
14th Annual Faculty Conference
The Federalist Society's Facutly Division hosted this panel on "Judicial Ethics" on Friday, January 6,...
Professional Responsibility: The Bloody Crossroads: Republican Party of Minnesota v. White Runs Into Caperton v. Massey
2010 National Lawyers Convention
Mr. James Bopp, Jr., Bopp, Coleson, and Bostrom and General Counsel, James Madison Center for...
Barwatch Bulletin -- February 16, 2009
February 16, 2009
House of Delegates Considers RecommendationsThe ABA's House of Delegates met today to vote on recommendations...
Showcase Panel IV: Regulation of Judicial Conduct: Silencing Judges or Avoiding Improper Influence?
2008 National Lawyers Convention
Is recent congressional interest in curtailing participation of judges in conferences and educational programs a...
Showcase Panel I: Judicial Selection: Federal and State
2008 National Lawyers Convention
Is the process we use for selecting judges broken at both the federal and the...
Special Session: Judicial Independence Dialogue
2008 National Lawyers Convention
Hon. William H., Pryor Jr., United States Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit Mr. H. Thomas...
Debate: The Merits of Electing Our Judges
2008 National Student Symposium
The Federalist Society's Student Division presented this debate at the 2008 Annual Student Symposium on...
Responses to Judicial Corruption: The Press, Prosecution, Professional Responsibility, Political Controls
Las Vegas Lawyers Chapter
Almost a year ago, the Los Angeles Times ran a series of articles entitled "Juice...
The Supreme Court Limits State Censorship of Judicial Campaign Speech
The election of state judges has been controversial at least since the Progressive Era. For...