Facts of the Case
When Google implemented its Android Operating System (Android OS), it wrote its own programming language based on Java, which is owned by Oracle. To facilitate developers writing their own programs for Android OS, Google’s version used the same names, organization, and functionality as Java's Application Programming Interfaces (APIs).
Oracle sued Google for copyright infringement, but the federal district judge held that APIs are not subject to copyright because permitting a private entity to own the copyright to a programming language would stifle innovation and collaboration, contrary to the goals of copyright. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit reversed the lower court, finding that the Java APIs are copyrightable but leaving open the possibility of a fair use defense. The U.S. Supreme Court denied Google’s petition for certiorari.
Upon remand to the district court, a jury found that Google's use of the Java API was fair use. Oracle appealed, and the Federal Circuit again reversed the lower court. The Federal Circuit held that Google's use was not fair as a matter of law.
Questions
Does copyright protection extend to a software interface?
If so, does the petitioner’s use of a software interface in the context of creating a new computer program constitute fair use?
Conclusions
-
Assuming a software interface may be subject to copyright protection, Google’s limited copying of the Java SE Application Programming Interface constituted a fair use of that material under copyright law. Justice Stephen Breyer authored the 6-2 majority opinion.
Copyright law aims to promote the progress of science and useful arts, by simultaneously granting creators exclusive copyrights and limiting the scope of such rights through the fair use doctrine. To decide no more than necessary to resolve the case, the Court assumed that software code is subject to copyright protection.
Courts consider four statutory factors in evaluating whether a secondary use is fair. First, Google’s use of the Java APIs is transformative. Google copied only what was necessary to allow programmers to work in a different computing environment but with a familiar programming language. Second, the copied lines are “inherently bound together with uncopyrightable ideas,” suggesting that the application of fair use to this context is unlikely to undermine the general copyright protection that Congress provided for computer programs. Third, Google copied only .4% of the entire API, weighing in favor of fair use. Finally, the record shows that Google’s new smartphone platform is not a market substitute for Java SE. Because all four factors support a finding of fair use, Google’s limited copying constituted fair use.
Justice Clarence Thomas authored a dissenting opinion, in which Justice Samuel Alito joined, arguing that the Court should have addressed the question whether Oracle’s code is copyrightable. Justice Thomas would have concluded that it is, and then he would have found that Google’s use of that copyrighted code was not fair. By copying Oracle’s code, Google “erased 97.5% of the value of Oracle’s partnership with Amazon, made tens of billions of dollars, and established its position as the owner of the largest mobile operating system in the world.”
Justice Amy Coney Barrett took no part in the consideration or decision of the case.
Further analysis of the oral argument available at Oral Argument 2.0: https://argument2.oyez.org/2020/google-llc-v-oracle-america-inc/
AI Training vs. Copyright Law: Updates from the Copyright Office and the Courts
Whether AI training and generation is a fair use under copyright law puts two important...
AI Meets Copyright: Understanding New York Times v. OpenAI
Artificial intelligence is the most important technological tool being developed today, but the use of...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: Andy Warhol Foundation for the Visual Arts, Inc. v. Goldsmith
The Supreme Court is considering a lawsuit between rock and roll photographer Lynn Goldsmith and...
Justice Breyer: His Legacy and Thoughts on His Replacement
Minnesota Lawyers Chapter
The Minnesota Lawyers Chapter of the Federalist Society held a Zoom webinar discussing Justice Breyer, his...
Courthouse Steps Decision: Unicolors, Inc v. H&M Hennes & Mauritz, LP
Join us virtually to hear a discussion on the Supreme Court's recent decision in Unicolors,...
IP Law and Culture
2021 National Lawyers Convention
The 2021 National Lawyers Convention took place November 11-13, 2021 at the Mayflower Hotel in...
Courthouse Steps Decision Webinar: Google v. Oracle
On April 5, 2021, the U.S. Supreme Court decided Google v. Oracle. In a 6-2 decision,...
Intellectual Property: Intellectual Property Rights and the Rule of Law
2020 National Lawyers Convention
On November 11, 2020, The Federalist Society's Intellectual Property Practice Group hosted a virtual panel...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument Teleforum: Ford Motor Company v. Montana Eighth Judicial District Court
Liability in motor vehicle accidents is frequently an issue necessitating litigation, but not typically at...
Google LLC v. Oracle America Inc. - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
featuring Michael Risch
The Supreme Court heard oral arguments for Google LLC v. Oracle America Inc. on October...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument Teleforum: Google v. Oracle
Google copied over 11,000 lines of computer code, called declaring code, owned by Oracle. Ten...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument Teleforum: Texas v. New Mexico
As an act of original jusrisdiction, the Supreme Court appointed a river master to resolve...
In Google v. Oracle, the Supreme Court Should Protect Copyright in the Tech Industry
From Mark Twain to Marvel Comics to Microsoft Windows, America has a rich history of...
Trade Secrets Litigation: Do Damages Awarded in Texas Case Have Broader Ramifications?
Intellectual property (IP) theft has taken an increasingly prominent place in the news as various...