Facts of the Case
Under the Copyright and Patent Clause of the Constitution, Article 1, section 8, "Congress shall have Power...to promote the Progress of Science...by securing [to Authors] for limited Times...the exclusive Right to their...Writings." In the 1998 Copyright Term Extension Act (CTEA), Congress enlarged the duration of copyrights by 20 years, making copyrights now run from creation until 70 years after the author's death. Petitioners, whose products or services build on copyrighted works that have entered the public domain, argued that the CTEA violates both the Copyright Clause's "limited Times" prescription and the First Amendment's free speech guarantee. They claimed Congress cannot extend the copyright term for published works with existing copyrights. The District Court and the District of Columbia Circuit disagreed.
Questions
Does the 1998 Copyright Term Extension Act's extension of existing copyrights exceed Congress's power under the Copyright Clause? Does the CTEA's extension of existing and future copyrights violate the First Amendment?
Conclusions
-
No and no. In a 7-2 opinion delivered by Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, the Court held that Congress acted within its authority and did not transgress constitutional limitations in placing existing and future copyrights in parity in the CTEA. Disagreeing with the argument that a copyright once set is fixed, the majority found that the CTEA "continues the unbroken congressional practice of treating future and existing copyrights in parity for term extension purposes," and is a permissible exercise of Congress's power under the Copyright Clause. Moreover, the Court held that the CTEA's extension of existing and future copyrights does not violate the First Amendment. Justices John Paul Stevens and Stephen G. Breyer dissented, arguing that the CTEA amounted to a grant of perpetual copyright that undermined public interests.
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument: Andy Warhol Foundation for the Visual Arts, Inc. v. Goldsmith
The Supreme Court is considering a lawsuit between rock and roll photographer Lynn Goldsmith and...
Courthouse Steps: Impression Products, Inc. v. Lexmark International, Inc. - Podcast
Intellectual Property Practice Group Podcast
The Supreme Court handed down one of its most significant decisions in patent law in...
Copyright Revision
2014 National Lawyers Convention
The U.S. Supreme Court has in the past several years begun to take several intellectual...
Copyright Originalism - Podcast
Intellectual Property Practice Group Podcast
Professor Tom W. Bell, Chapman University, Fowler School of Law, participated in a Teleforum conference call...
Petrella v. Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 6-4-14 featuring Christina Mulligan
On May 19, 2014, the Supreme Court issued its opinion in Petrella v. Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer. The...
Winning the Copyright War: Copyright’s Merger Doctrine and Natural Rights Theory as Solutions to the Problem of Reconciling Copyright and Free Speech
Engage Volume 14, Issue 1 February 2013
I. Introduction A. Overview Concerns that the enforcement of copyright law might conflict with First...
Laws of Creation: An Examination of Intellectual Property Rights
Intellectual Property Practice Group
The historic approach to encouraging innovation and creativity by granting property rights, enshrined in the...
Golan v. Holder - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 1-27-12 featuring Christopher Newman
On January 18, 2012, the Supreme Court announced its decision in Golan v. Holder. The question...
Golan v. Holder - Post-Argument SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 10-18-11 featuring Christopher Newman
On October 5, 2011, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Golan v. Holder. The question...
Supreme Court Preview: What Is in Store for October Term 2011?
October 3rd marks the first day of the 2011 Supreme Court term. This term the...
Copyright v. Copyleft
Seton Hall Student Chapter
The Federalist Society's Seton Hall Student Chapter presented this panel discussion on September 17, 2009, at Seton...
The 2008 Election and the Federal Courts
Michigan Lawyers Chapter
On October 28, 2008, the Michigan Lawyers Chapter presented a debate on "The 2008 Election...
Eldred v. Ashcroft: The Supreme Court's Mickey Mouse Copyright Decision
Recently decided by the Supreme Court is the case of Eldred v. Ashcroft, which challenged...
Eldred v. Ashcroft: Just Another Mickey Mouse Copyright Case?
Currently on the Supreme Court’s docket is the case of Eldred v. Ashcroft, which challenges...