Facts of the Case
In 2005, the Indiana Legislature passed a law requiring all voters who cast a ballot in person to present a photo ID issued by the United States or the State of Indiana. Plaintiffs including the local Democratic Party and interest groups representing minority and elderly citizens argued that the law constituted an undue burden on the right to vote. At trial, the plaintiffs did not produce any witnesses who claimed they would be unable to meet the law's requirements. The district court and the court of appeals both upheld the law. However, the three-judge appellate panel was deeply divided. Dissenting Judge Terrence Evans claimed that the law was a thinly-veiled attempt to dampen turnout by those likely to vote for Democratic candidates.
Questions
Does a law that requires voters to present either a state or federal photo identification unduly burden citizens' right to vote?
Conclusions
-
By a vote of 6 to 3, the Court upheld the law, concluding that the photo I.D. requirement was closely related to Indiana's legitimate state interests in preventing voter fraud. The slight burden the law imposed on voters' rights did not outweigh these interests, which the Court characterized as "neutral and nondiscriminatory." Although there was no majority opinion, the Court's decision included concurring opinions written by Justices John Paul Stevens and Antonin Scalia. Justices David Souter and Stephen Breyer each wrote dissenting opinions. Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg joined Justice Souter's dissent.
Integrity or Interference?: Evaluating the Constitutionality of Georgia's Election Integrity Act
Federalist Society Review, Volume 25
Recent political earthquakes such as the assassination attempt against former president Donald Trump and President...
Courthouse Steps Decision Webinar: Brnovich v. Democratic National Convention
Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group Teleforum
On July 1, 2021, the Supreme Court issued its decision in Brnovich, Attorney General of Arizona...
Courthouse Steps Oral Argument Teleforum: Brnovich v. Democratic National Committee
In Brnovich v. Democratic National Committee and the consolidated case of Arizona Republican Party v. Democratic National Committee,...
7th Circuit Lets Wisconsin Voter ID Law Stand for 2016 General Election
On August 26, 2016, the 7th Circuit, in a per curiam opinion, denied Wisconsin voter...
Voter ID: A Debate - Podcast
Free Speech & Election Law Practice Group Podcast
Recent North Carolina, North Dakota, Texas, and Wisconsin court decisions have invalidated voter ID laws...
Court Rulings on Election Law - Podcast
Civil Rights and Free Speech & Election Law Practice Groups Teleforum
There have been a series of recent court decisions at both the federal district court...
Voter Identification and the Right to Vote
Iowa Lawyers Chapter
In recent years, states across the country have considered or implemented stricter voter identification requirements,...
Voter Identification and the Right to Vote
Iowa Lawyers Chapter
In recent years, states across the country have considered or implemented stricter voter identification requirements,...
Doe v. Reed - Post-Decision SCOTUScast
SCOTUScast 07-19-10 featuring Bradley A. Smith
On June 24, 2010, the Supreme Court announced its decision in Doe v. Reed. In...
ACLU of New Mexico, et al. v. Santillanes
Civil Rights Practice Group
In 2005, the voters of Albuquerque passed an amendment to the city charter requiring photo...
Crawford v. Marion County Election Board and the Future of Supreme Court Jurisprudence Concerning the Regulation of Elections
Crawford v. Marion County Election Bd. assumes an important place in election law jurisprudence, not...
Bar Watch Bulletin August 9 & 10, 2008
SCOTUS Review, American Press & War, the 14th Amendment, Human Rights, Climate Change, Women in Law, and Immigration
The American Bar Association's Annual Meeting will be taking place from August 7-12 in New...
A Look Back at the October Supreme Court 2007 Term
Is the DC gun ban constitutional? Do Guantanamo Bay prisoners have a constitutional right to...
Supreme Court Term
Online Debate
The Supreme Court ended its OT07 term on June 26, 2008. We are hosting a live...
SCOTUScast 5-5-08 featuring Hans von Spakovsky
Crawford v. Marion County
On April 28, 2008, in Crawford v. Marion County, the Supreme Court dismissed a constitutional...
SCOTUScast 1-14-08 featuring Allison Hayward
Crawford v. Marion County
Crawford v. Marion County, argued in front of the Supreme Court on January 9th 2008,...
Crawford v. Marion County
Online Debate
Crawford v. Marion County, argued in front of the Supreme Court on January 9th 2008, challenges...