Facts of the Case
Rose Cipollone died at 58 from lung cancer. She smoked for 42 years. Before her death, she and her husband sued several cigarette manufacturers in federal court for damages resulting from Mrs. Cipollone lung cancer. A trial court judgment of $400,000 was reserved in the U.S. Court of Appeals. The Cipollone family appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court.
Questions
Do federally mandated cigarette warnings pre-empt the Cipollones' common law claims against cigarette manufacturers?
Conclusions
-
In a complicated 7-to-2 decision, the Court held that federally mandated warnings do not bar smokers from suing manufacturers under state personal-injury laws. The justices ruled that such suits cannot be based on claims that cigarette advertising failed to warn smokers of smoking dangers. But the justices also ruled that individuals may press claims alleging that the tobacco companies made fraudulent or inaccurate statements in their advertising or that the companies conspired to mislead people about the health hazards of smoking.
SCOTUScast 2-8-09 with Andrew Morriss
Altria Group v. Good
On Monday, December 15, the Supreme Court announced its decision in Altria Group v. Good,...
Luncheon Debate: When should FDA Regulation Preempt State Tort Liability
11th Annual Faculty Conference
Prof. Richard Epstein, University of Chicago School of Law Prof. Roderick Hills, New York University...
SCOTUScast 10-17-08 featuring Andrew Morriss
Altria Group v. Good
On Monday, October 6, the Supreme Court officially opened the October 2008 term by hearing...
SCOTUScast 2-26-08 featuring Richard Nagareda
Riegel v. Medtronic
On February 20, 2008 the Supreme Court decided Riegel v. Medtronic. In Riegel, the Court...
The Roberts Court Wades into Products Liability Preemption Waters: Riegel v. Medtronic, Inc.
With Riegel v. Medtronic, Inc., the Roberts Court makes its inaugural foray this term into...