Facts of the Case
In 1961, Morris Hasson, a Los Angeles grocery store manager, was shot and killed during a robbery attempt. Paul Imbler was convicted of the murder after three eyewitnesses identified him as the gunman. After the trial, the prosecutor, Deputy District Attorney Richard Pachtman, wrote to the Governor of California and described newly discovered evidence that undermined the testimony of one of the eyewitnesses. In light of the letter, Imbler challenged his incarceration in state court, where his petition was denied, and later in federal court. The federal district court found that Pachtman had knowingly used false testimony during the trial and suppressed evidence favorable to Imbler, so the district court ordered Imbler released from prison. Imbler then filed an action against Pachtman in federal court under Section 1983 of the Civil Rights Act of 1871, which allows a party to recover damages from any person who acts “under color of state law” to deprive another of a constitutional right. The district court held that Pachtman was immune for civil liability for acts done in his capacity as prosecutor and dismissed the complaint. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed the dismissal on appeal.
Questions
Does a prosecutor have absolute immunity from civil liability for actions taken within the scope of his duties in bringing and pursuing a criminal prosecution?
Conclusions
-
Yes. Justice Lewis F. Powell, Jr. delivered the opinion for the 8-0 majority. The Court held that prosecutors have the same absolute immunity under Section 1983 that they had under common law in malicious prosecution suits. In both situations, there are similar public policy concerns related to the need for prosecutorial independence. The Court declined to consider whether a prosecutor was entitled to similar level of immunity for actions taken in the role of an administrator or investigator.
Justice Byron R. White wrote an opinion concurring in the judgment in which he agreed that a prosecutor is absolutely immune for the knowing or reckless presentation of false testimony, but that absolute immunity should not shield claims against a prosecutor for the unconstitutional suppression of evidence. Justice White argued that the denial of immunity would encourage prosecutors to turn over more information than necessary, which would be beneficial to the judicial process overall. Justice William J. Brennan, Jr. and Justice Thurgood Marshall joined the opinion concurring in the judgment.
Courthouse Steps Decision: Determining Finality for Pursuing Liability: The Implications of Thompson v. Clark
In Thompson v. Clark, the plaintiff sought to bring a civil suit claiming he was...
Prosecutorial Immunity
Criminal Law Procedure Practice Group Teleforum
Prosecutors cannot be sued for injuries caused by their own misconduct. For example, even if...
Could a New Section 1983 Covering Federal Officials Curb Executive Branch Abuse of Constitutional Rights?
Federalist Society Review, Volume 17, Issue 3
Note from the Editor: This article notes public distrust of the federal government in light...
Pros and Cons: Our Criminal Justice System at Work - Podcast
Criminal Law & Procedure Practice Group Podcast
Our panelists will discuss the criminal justice system generally, and the role of the prosecutor...
Federal Monitoring of Local Policing - Podcast
Criminal Law & Procedure Practice Group Podcast
Is it within a federal court's authority to order local police officers to wear video...
SCOTUScast 6-17-09 featuring Stephen McAllister
Van de Kamp v. Goldstein
On Monday, January 26, the Supreme Court announced its decision in Van de Kamp v....
Stoneridge Investment v. Scientific Atlanta
Online Debate
On January 15, 2008 the Supreme Court decided the Stoneridge Investment v. Scientific Atlanta case. The Court...
Stephen R. McAllister is a native Kansan who grew up in Lucas, Kansas and graduated from Lucas-Luray High School. Growing up, he also lived in Hiawatha and Chanute, Kansas. He received both his B.A. and his J.D. degrees from the University of Kansas.