Facts of the Case
Paula Corbin Jones sued President Bill Clinton. She alleged that while she was an Arkansas state employee, she suffered several "abhorrent" sexual advances from then Arkansas Governor Clinton. Jones claimed that her continued rejection of Clinton's advances ultimately resulted in punishment by her state supervisors. Following a District Court's grant of Clinton's request that all matters relating to the suit be suspended, pending a ruling on his prior request to have the suit dismissed on grounds of presidential immunity, Clinton sought to invoke his immunity to completely dismiss the Jones suit against him. While the District Judge denied Clinton's immunity request, the judge ordered the stay of any trial in the matter until after Clinton's Presidency. On appeal, the Eighth Circuit affirmed the dismissal denial but reversed the trial deferment ruling since it would be a "functional equivalent" to an unlawful grant of temporary presidential immunity.
Questions
Is a serving President, for separation of powers reasons, entitled to absolute immunity from civil litigation arising out of events which transpired prior to his taking office?
Conclusions
-
No. In a unanimous opinion, the Court held that the Constitution does not grant a sitting President immunity from civil litigation except under highly unusual circumstances. After noting the great respect and dignity owed to the Executive office, the Court held that neither separation of powers nor the need for confidentiality of high-level information can justify an unqualified Presidential immunity from judicial process. While the independence of our government's branches must be protected under the doctrine of separation of powers, the Constitution does not prohibit these branches from exercising any control over one another. This, the Court added, is true despite the procedural burdens which Article III jurisdiction may impose on the time, attention, and resources of the Chief Executive.
Federalism & Separation of Powers: A Revival of the Separation of Powers at the Supreme Court?
2024 National Lawyers Convention
The Supreme Court’s most recent term was one of significance with respect to the separation...
Annual Hon. Robert H. Bork Memorial Lecture
2023 National Lawyers Convention
The 2023 National Lawyers Convention will take place November 9-11, 2022 at the Mayflower Hotel...
The End of Independent Agencies? Restoring Presidential Control of the Executive Branch
Federalist Society Review, Volume 22
On the day that President Joe Biden took office, among his first official acts was...
Executive Privilege and Congressional Oversight
What is the proper balance between Congressional oversight and Executive privilege? As it becomes clear...
Presidential Conflicts? - Podcast
Practice Group Podcast
“Suggestions that President-elect Donald Trump put his business holdings in a 'blind trust,' which would...
Impeachment Wrap — Looking For Mr. Goldman
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group Newsletter - Volume 3, Issue 2, Summer 1999
If you turned on TV anytime during the past year, you know that no professional...
Clinton v. Jones: Are Presidents "Temporarily Immune" from Suit Based Upon Their Unofficial Acts?
Federalism & Separation of Powers Practice Group Newsletter - Volume 1, Issue 1, Fall 1996
An alleged 1991 encounter between Paula Corbin Jones, an Arkansas state employee, and then-Governor Bill...