Facts of the Case
Baltimore wharf owner John Barron alleged that construction by the city had diverted water flow in the harbor area. He argued that sand accumulations in the harbor deprived Barron of deep waters, which reduced his profits. He sued the city to recover a portion of his financial losses. The trial court awarded him $4,500 in damages, which the state appellate court struck down.
Questions
Does the Fifth Amendment deny the states as well as the national government the right to take private property for public use without justly compensating the property's owner?
Conclusions
-
Writing for the unanimous Court, Chief Justice Marshall found that the limitations on government articulated in the Fifth Amendment were specifically intended to limit the powers of the national government. Citing the intent of the framers and the development of the Bill of Rights (the first 10 amendments) as an exclusive check on the federal government, Marshall reasoned that the Supreme Court had no jurisdiction in this case since the Fifth Amendment was not applicable to the states. This meant that Barron was not entitled to damages for his property loss from the city under the Fifth Amendment provision on just compensation for a government taking.
Remembering Gordon Wood: The Revolution, the Constitution, and the Work of History
Gordon S. Wood, who passed away in June, was one of the nation’s most influential...
The State of the Research on the Privileges or Immunities Clause
Harvard Student Chapter
Event Video: The State of the Research on the Privileges or Immunities Clause
Panel VI: 1995 National Student Symposium, The Original Meaning of the Fourteenth Amendment [Archive Collection]
1995 National Student Symposium
On April 7-9, 1995, the Federalist Society held its fourteenth annual National Student Symposium at...
Panel V: Is Originalism Possible? Historical Indeterminacy
1995 National Student Symposium
On April 7-9, 1995, the Federalist Society held its fourteenth annual National Student Symposium at...
Feddie Night Festivus: Blackman vs. Everybody!
Columbus School of Law Student Chapter
The Federalist Society's Student Division &Columbus School of Law Student Chapter present Feddie Night Festivus:Blackman vs. Everybody! FeaturingUnprecedented...
Religious Liberty after Fulton v. City of Philadelphia
2021 National Lawyers Convention
The 2021 National Lawyers Convention took place November 11-13, 2021 at the Mayflower Hotel in...
Panel III: The Modern Role of the Privileges or Immunities Clause [Archive Collection]
1988 National Student Symposium
On March 4-5, 1988, The Federalist Society's University of Virginia student chapter hosted the National...
Originalism and Constitutional Property Rights Jurisprudence
2019 National Lawyers Convention
On November 16, 2019, the Federalist Society's Environmental Law & Property Rights Practice Group hosted...
Panel 1: The Original Understanding of “Privileges or Immunities”
2019 National Student Symposium
On March 15-16, 2019, the Federalist Society's student chapter at the ASU Sandra Day O'Connor...
The ARTICLE ONE Act
Counting by news cycles, it seems like ages ago, but on March 12, Senator Lee...
The ARTICLE ONE Act
Counting by news cycles, it seems like ages ago, but on March 12, Senator Lee...
In Memoriam: Ron Rotunda
Professional Responsibilities & Legal Education Practice Group Teleforum
In this Teleforum, Prof. Ely of Vanderbilt Law, Prof. Presser of Northwestern, and our Professional...
Reconstructing First Principles: The Fourteenth Amendment and the Constitution
2018 National Student Symposium
The Fourteenth Amendment dramatically changed constitutional law. How are we to understand these changes? Did...
Showcase Panel I: Textualism and the Bill of Rights
2013 National Lawyers Convention
The new textualism has had a big impact on interpretation of the Bill of Rights....
Arkansas Game and Fish: Property Rights in the Supreme Court - Podcast
Environmental Law & Property Rights Practice Group Podcast
In early October, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Arkansas Game and Fish v....
Firearms Law and the Second Amendment - Faculty Book Podcast
Faculty Division Podcast 08-07-12 featuring Nicholas Johnson, Michael O'Shea and Adam Winkler
This podcast discusses Firearms Law and the Second Amendment: Regulation, Rights and Policy by authors...
Illuminating Citizens United: What the Decision Really Did
Engage Volume 12, Issue 3, November 2011
In January 2010, the U.S. Supreme Court issued one of its most controversial decisions in...
McDonald v. City of Chicago – Cert Granted SCOTUScast Debate
SCOTUScast 11-09-2009 featuring Kurt Lash, Nelson Lund, and Clark Neily
On September 30, 2009, the Supreme Court granted certiorari in the case of McDonald v....
The Great Debate: Justice John Paul Stevens - October 23, 1985
Speech by Justice John Paul Stevens before the Federal Bar Association on October 23, 1985
Justice John Paul Stevens Before the Federal Bar Association October 23, 1985, Chicago, Illinois What...
The Great Debate: Justice John Paul Stevens - October 23, 1985
Speech by Justice John Paul Stevens before the Federal Bar Association on October 23, 1985
Justice John Paul Stevens Before the Federal Bar Association October 23, 1985, Chicago, Illinois What...
The Great Debate: Attorney General Ed Meese III - July 9, 1985
Speech by Attorney General Edwin Meese III before the American Bar Association on July 9, 1985
? Attorney General Edwin Meese III Before the American Bar Association July 9, 1985, Washington,...
The Great Debate: Attorney General Ed Meese III - July 9, 1985
Speech by Attorney General Edwin Meese III before the American Bar Association on July 9, 1985
? Attorney General Edwin Meese III Before the American Bar Association July 9, 1985, Washington,...
2021 National Lawyers Convention
Public and Private Power: Preserving Freedom or Preventing Harm?
The Mayflower Hotel1127 Connecticut Avenue, NW
Washington, DC 20036